Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more throwawayjava's commentslogin

1. Surprisingly, students from small private colleges like Olin are more likely to pursue graduate degrees. IDK if this holds for Olin specifically.

2. Olin is a great school. I doubt undergraduates from Olin are paid substantially differently from those at Stanford. There is probably data on this.

3. Seems the most likely explanation. Or just random chance.


Exactly, all 3 of your conclusions are true :)

1) My class had 30+% go into PhD programs, with over half of them receiving Fulbright/NSF/comparable prestigious research grants.

2) Earlier Olin classes graduated a larger percentage of people to take on high-paying jobs at Google/MS/IBM (and later FB/Twitter). It has shifted towards more academia and entrepreneurs

3) As one of (only) four international students in the first class (5% of the incoming class), yes, fewer international students. Yes, international students come from cultures less encouraging of entrepreneurship. While I'm definitely from one of those, being at Olin brought me around to entrepreneurship -- I wasn't interested until nearing graduation, reinforcing the article's point that Olin nurtures and graduates founders more effectively than other schools. I would almost certainly have worked a high-paying software dev job if I attended Stanford instead.


If that plane ever plans to enter US or EU airspace, there is a literal air-gap between the IFE and the flight systems.


The Federal Aviation Administration has issued special conditions for the certification of the 787 to deal with the fact that there is no "literal airgap" in recent airliners even though that was initially mandated by the airworthiness standards:

> These special conditions are issued for the Boeing Model 787-8 airplane. This airplane will have novel or unusual design features when compared to the state of technology envisioned in the airworthiness standards for transport category airplanes. The architecture of the Boeing Model 787-8 computer systems and networks may allow access to external systems and networks

[1] https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2007/12/28/E7-2507...


Then how is it showing the flight metrics?

I wouldn’t guess they would add double sensors for all that information.

Or did you mean well protected, instead of literal air gap?


I am not a Boeing engineer, but I do have some experience in avionics design.

The flight critical systems would be isolated from in-flight entertainment system (IFE). The IFE probably has a listen-only tap to flight metric info on an ARINC databus from the flight computer. I did a quick search and looks like 787 uses ARINC 667, a fiber optic interconnect.


One way connection of some kind? Its not an air gap but may functionally work the same way.


Optoisolators are a prolific and an extremely cheap electrical component that performs the "air-gap" functionality.


Electrical safety airgapping and information security airgapping are different, and entirely unrelated. If data can pass from one side to the other it's not airgapped (from an infosec perspective).


Fiber needs transmitter and receiver transducers. If each side has only one of those, data can literally flow only in one direction. So it's still infosec-airgapped in the other.


No, data diodes are a different (but related) concept. An airgap implies no information transfer, either in or out. Use an airgap when information leakage must be stopped (as well as remote attacks), use a data diode when information can be released but you need to stop remote attacks.

Fiber optic connections aren't required, anything with separate transmit and receive lines can be turned into a data diode (as long as the protocols used permit it). RS232 null modem cables with the RX lines disconnected are a classic.


No, that's not airgapping.


I don't know enough about airplanes to know if it would be unencrypted but they radio all of that same data to the ground in some way, could the IFE system just passively listen to that broadcast?


GPS + external sensors for pressure, wheels, …


TBF "what calculus is" -- i.e., the level of rigor at which topics are taught -- varies a lot even among college courses called "calculus"...

In particular, IMO the distance between AP calculus and honors calculus at an ivy is larger than the difference between this material and AP calculus.


Up to a point, but does it not all grow out of the concept of limits?


I would say that the fundamental idea to understand is the concept of changing ratios.

Limits seems to me to be more a tool in order to calculate the ratios than a fundamental concept.


I agree with that. You can hand limits as a tool to someone already comfortable with the concepts and present them as a way to quantify their intuitive understanding.


But without limits, you cannot actually do much with the concepts. Whether you call limits a concept or a tool, they are essential to the practice of calculus, and, historically, to its emergence (and not trivially so, either.)


Yeah but you can do well on the AP calculus exam without understanding limits, if you can calculate derivatives and solve some word problems related to derivatives.

Hence, the gap between "5 year old calculus" and "high school calculus" is smaller than the gap between "high school calculus" and "actual calculus"


I completely agree with you.

(It's worth nothing that fracking and coal mining are even worse.)


In addition to the 10 percent cut, "or reinvested" is the answer.


Yeah, this is how statistics is taught in a lot of psych departments. A bunch of tests and rules of thumb about when to use which equations, together with some training on a piece of software.

IMO the "pragmatic rules-of-thumb" approach to teaching/understanding statistics is probably the genesis point of the reproducability crisis. This mindset toward stats has probably done more damage to Psychology than anything else in the history of the field.

So, proceed with caution.


>IMO the "pragmatic rules-of-thumb" approach to teaching/understanding statistics is probably the genesis point of the reproducability crisis. This mindset toward stats has probably done more damage to Psychology than anything else in the history of the field.

Sure, but then we have another problem: if you need to know measure theory to run an experiment, nobody will run experiments. And lots of mathematical statistics just goes ahead and uses the measure theory.


There's a middle-ground, though.


> Presumably: that you are allowed to use it during exams in the USA.

Nope, this calculator is not allowed on any of the major standardized tests.

https://collegereadiness.collegeboard.org/sat/taking-the-tes...

https://apstudent.collegeboard.org/takingtheexam/exam-polici...

http://www.act.org/content/dam/act/unsecured/documents/ACT-c...

And many -- perhaps most -- high school teachers have a similar "white list based" policy because they're unable or unwilling to a) admit that any graphing calculator makes cheating basically impossible to prevent without extremely careful proctoring; and/or b) emphasize learning even at the expense of weakening the signaling value of credentials.

IMO tests should be designed sot that calculators aren't necessary. I can't ever remember using a calculator in university, and that's really the only place I actually learned any mathematics in a classroom setting.


From the website¹:

> The NumWorks Graphing Calculator matches all the requirements of the ACT calculator policy and is permitted for use on that test. It is currently under review by the College Board for use on the SAT.

¹https://www.numworks.com


Until this calculator is listed on the ACT website, I wouldn't risk using it. You will be turned away if you show up with an unapproved calculator.


> The IRB requires a procedure that doesn't avoid it

The IRB requires getting informed consent from the patient. This is not unreasonable. In fact, IMO, experimenting on people and then publishing the results of those experiments without prior informed consent is grossly unreasonable and creepy.

Parent's point is that the author concedes that in a psych ward context, even asking for consent carries serious risks. I'm not sure if this is true because I have no personal experience, but the author seems to believe it is true.

Look, it sucks that doing any research in a psych ward carries substantial risk. But that doesn't mean that you can perform experiments on psych patients without their informed consent. Even if you think that the experiment is NBD. Guess what? You're not the patient and it's not your medical data, so it's not your call. Insisting otherwise is incredibly disrespectful and dehumanizing toward psych ward patients. They are humans, they have rights, and an inconvenienced researcher is not a reasonable justification for nullifying those rights.

Are there aspects of IRBs that are infuriating and unnecessary? Absolutely. But requiring informed consent before medical data is used in a non-treatment context is -- and should be -- a basic right afforded to every patient. Even psych patients.

I hate IRBs, especially for questionnaires, and especially the stupid training. But posts like yours convince me that both are sadly necessary.


> Like, why should we conclude that we need that sort of consent to administer a questionnaire for experimental purposes (i.e.: gaining generally useful knowledge), but that there are no substantial issues of consent when it’s for diagnostic purposes (i.e.: gaining information about that particular patient) instead?

1. Researcher incentives. Data => publications => prestige. If the procedure actually contains some inherent risk (e.g., a surgery) then this mismatch between the priorities of the physician and the priorities of the researcher matters. Even (actually, especially!!!) if the physician and the researcher are the same person.

2. Publication. De-anonymization is a real risk even if you're careful to only talk about patient # N in the publication.

3. Patient preference. Just because I allow my hosting provider to access my servers for the purpose of maintenance doesn't mean I'm OK with them accessing my servers for the purpose of surveillance or to read my personal emails. Purpose matters. Some patients won't want data about them used in the context of a scientific study. Patients should and do have the right to insist on that preference. Frankly, the presumption otherwise is exactly why IRBs exist.

This story sounds stupid because -- aside from de-anonymization or data leaks -- there are actually no substantive risks associated with this study. Change "questionnaire" to "open heart surgery" and all of this process starts to make a lot more sense.

FWIW I'm not saying IRB's aren't completely overbearing when it comes to benign studies. They totally are. But that doesn't mean these processes aren't well-justified in other circumstances.

(Also, a lot of this pain is completely avoidable if you learn and follow the rules, which isn't actually nearly as hard as this post makes it out to be IME.)


Big ones absolutely do. I'm not sure how small floods can get before the answer is no. IMNAG.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: