Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more throwawayjava's commentslogin

Right. This is something that people often miss when they say ridiculous things are illegal. The whole point of judicial review is that just because the legislature says something is legal/illegal, doesn't mean it actually is.


OK, I'm another data point for "studied category theory; program in an ML dialect; think it's silly".

Most all the theorist/logician/algebraist-turned-programmer folks I know all feel more-or-less the same way.

Just explain the pattern in english. Might as well call it a FooDeBar. Giving axioms and such is usually a waste of The Man's money and my time.

That said, I think it's extremely valuable to see this sort of thing in an academic or side project/enrichment activity setting. The mindset and mental model are fantastically helpful. See dshnkao's post, for example.


Just to be clear, you're advocating:

1. Don't use terminology from academic category theory / abstract algebra in computer programming

2. But if you haven't studied these things, and you are a programmer, it might be very enlightening to do so.

Is that right?


> category theory / abstract algebra

Woah there!

But otherwise, yes.

Most working mathematicians have seen category theory and borrow bits and pieces of notation and such. But most of their work is done in far more concrete settings.

Working programmers should adopt the same arrangement.

It's a subtle position, but not an inconsistent one. I promise :-)


"people movers" made me laugh.

You could, but might face liability. Also, perhaps not a full time job but also not easy to schedule. So you'd be paying someone to sit around 90% of the time.


The work was first posted to arxiv in 2012. It can take a while until a result is understood by enough experts to confirm its correctness. Imagine if journalists wrote an article claiming P=NP is closed every time someone posted their attempt to arxiv.

Also, this work very recently won a prestigious award.

Also, result published ---> result accepted ---> journalist writes high-quality piece explaining result to lay people can take years.

> the lack of an actual citation was very disturbing

The first linked text in the article is a link to the arxiv paper.


>>> at around the 1960s/1970s.

>> the U. S. began, even if just a little bit, to pull its head out of its ass with respect to equality and rights

> Please watch your tone... There are plenty of people with more nuanced opinions on gender roles that aren't bigoted.

But the opinions codified in policy prior to the 1960s/1970s were objectively horrifying.

Brown v. Board was decided in 1954.

Jim Crow was going strong in the 50's and hung on into the 60's.

Harvard Medical School did not (purposefully) admit women until '45; Princeton until '69. Title IX passed in the 70's and gender parity in university admissions didn't happen until '81.

The first no fault divorce law wasn't passed until '69.

The Equal Pay Act was passed in '63.

IMO there isn't a non-bigoted defense of -- or inappropriate tone for criticizing -- the confluence of those policies.

(Also, "watch your tone" is condescending and defensive. Unless you support returning to Jim Crow and repealing the Equal Pay Act, there's no reason to be defensive.)


I agree that most of above is objectively horrifying, but the tone of your post was overly emotional and attracts the kinds who vote based on emotion instead of logic. "the U. S. began... to pull its head out of its ass," is not professional.

> there isn't a non-bigoted defense of -- or inappropriate tone for criticizing -- the confluence of those policies.

>it was the era of "women's lib", or in full "women's liberation". IOW, "a woman's place is in the home, preferably barefoot and pregnant" began to go out the window.

Some people don't think it's a bad thing that women were given the opportunity to be homemakers instead of laborers. I agree that policies at the time were too extreme, but many others and I also believe that perfect gender parity in all careers is also extreme. What is considered "equal" varies depending on the person.

> Also, "watch your tone" is condescending and defensive.

Interpret it how you like. I was critiquing a behavior that I felt hurt the conversation and if left unchecked, has the potential to damage the culture of this site.


So you think emphasizing rhetorical persuasion over reasoned persuasion is detrimental to productive conversation.

But then proceed to make an entire post about rhetorical content even though you completely agree with the post's logical conclusions.

And then use that critique of language -- not logic -- as a springboard for a counter-argument that isn't even responsive to the author's original claim (which you say you agree with anyways).

That position is untenable. Be consistent, especially if you're advancing an argument in favor of logic!

> Interpret it how you like. I was critiquing...

No, you missed my point. The tone of your writing comes off as condescending, regardless of your intent. It is the sort of thing a parent says to a child, or a judge to an unruly defendant. I literally cannot think of a way to read "watch you tone" in a way that is not condescending.

It is reasonable to tell someone to please phrase something in a more polite manner.

It is completely unreasonable to do so in a condescending tone, and many people will down-vote you for doing so.

IMO there is nothing wrong with blunt language on an internet forum. You apparently disagree, except when it comes to your own speech.

Again, be consistent.

> but the tone of your post

Not my post.


I think the point is that if you're right you shouldn't have to play dirty with rhetoric to prove your point.


What's damaging to the culture of this site is describing strong gender bias and oppression as "women were given the opportunity to be homemakers instead of laborers."

The phrase is not "professional" but do you think it's wrong? Would you say policies where, for example, women couldn't get credit cards without their husband's permission, or black people couldn't go to certain schools, cannot be described as the country having its head in its ass?

I don't think full gender parity in all careers is likely to happen, nor necessarily a worthy goal. Full gender parity in opportunity, however, is extremely important, and this era you're romanticizing with an outrageously misleading description was far, far, far from equal opportunity.


> What's damaging to the culture of this site is describing strong gender bias and oppression as "women were given the opportunity to be homemakers instead of laborers."

I assume by that you're saying that shaming people is ok if they "deserve" to be shamed.

You can't take the hacker news rule, "You should be civil to each other." and say it should apply it selectively to those who you agree with.

It doesn't make hacker news "better" to have only one viewpoint, by shaming all others because they don't match the mob approved groupthink of what right and wrong is.


No, I'm saying that the offense of using strong language when describing something bad is completely trivial when compared to using nice language to lie about both past and present in service of the counterargument.

Bad faith arguments wrapped in nice language are vastly more destructive to the conversation then a little foul language.

We should not misinterpret "be civil" as "don't use the word 'ass.'"


How is that a lie, though? How do you know it's a bad faith argument? You know what bad faith means, right? That someone is not representing what they truly believe.

Again, you're shaming people that disagree with you.

> We should not misinterpret "be civil" as "don't use the word 'ass.'"

We also shouldn't misinterpret "be civil" as only allow certain sets of viewpoints to be conveyed.


How do you know anything? How do I know that you're talking about my comment and not, say, explaining the lifecycle of the sabre-toothed tiger? At some point you have to rely on individual understanding of language.

Should we allow all viewpoints to be conveyed? Should we allow the viewpoint that Hitler did nothing wrong? Or that your parents were chimpanzees? Or that you're a fuckhead? I don't see how "be civil" and "allow stating all viewpoints" can possibly be compatible.


I was talking about you being able to peer into someone's head and then label them mischievous and a liar. That's different from denying understanding of the semantics of language and how they apply to the real world.

> Should we allow all viewpoints to be conveyed? Should we allow the viewpoint that Hitler did nothing wrong? Or that your parents were chimpanzees? Or that you're a fuckhead? I don't see how "be civil" and "allow stating all viewpoints" can possibly be compatible.

If I express a viewpoint that has been proven wrong thousands of times, such as "Hitler did nothing wrong", I'm not seeking discussion, but rather seeking to annoy. That's obvious and not being civil.

If I hide insults in my argument, that's also not being civil.

However, if I express a controversial but novel opinion on a subject that is not closed, it shouldn't automatically be lumped into being the same as the first two categories.


> The phrase is not "professional" but do you think it's wrong? Would you say policies where, for example, women couldn't get credit cards without their husband's permission, or black people couldn't go to certain schools, cannot be described as the country having its head in its ass?

It's not wrong, but speaking that way also doesn't foster a nuanced conversation with emotion in check, hence is bad for the site's culture IMO. And yes, I do think those policies are wrong. There is a big difference between culture and policy though.

> Full gender parity in opportunity, however, is extremely important, and this era you're romanticizing with an outrageously misleading description was far, far, far from equal opportunity.

I agree 100%. The issue is that _many_ people see full gender parity as equality, and in fact may be the majority viewpoint depending on how this site is skewed. If this site fosters an environment where people with slightly abnormal yet nonextremist viewpoints are downvoted to oblivion, it has the potential to form a huge echo chamber where issues like gender parity, cultural values, and any other slightly political issue cannot be discussed. It's not a good environment, even if it matches the majority viewpoint at the time.

edit: Also, speaking this way pushes people to vote based on emotion instead of whether or not the comment contributed to the conversation.


> it has the potential to form a huge echo chamber where issues like gender parity, cultural values, and any other slightly political issue cannot be discussed

As a reminder, the post to which you originally replied was answering this question:

>>>>> Did anything significant happen [in the 1960s/1970s] to cause this, or is it just an interesting anomaly?

This is a very reasonable and important question about "gender parity, cultural values, and other political issues".

IMO the parent provided a pretty decent, if pithy, answer. You have stated that you agree with the substance of parent's answer.

> edit: Also, speaking this way pushes people to vote based on emotion instead of whether or not the comment contributed to the conversation.

The way I see it, OP answered an important question in a mostly accurate manner. Their language was perhaps crass, but the substance of the "head out of their ass" claim -- that the US prior to 1960 was very bigoted and the political movement to end that bigotry contributed in part but not in whole to a move toward gender parity -- is one that you even seem to agree with.

So, parent wrote an accurate answer to a significant question about the very topics you deem important.

In turn, you replied with a condescending rebuke of his tone, a sequence of straw-men that distract from the original conversation about the cause of historical trends in employment, and a sequence of inconsistent positions about the role of rhetoric in argumentation.

I don't think these sorts of meta-conversations are particularly useful, but the content of your posts contradicts your stated preferences.


You are right. I had an issue with the crass language, made a bunch of assumptions on their opinions, and responded very poorly. Your post helps me see this, thank you.


> The issue is that _many_ people see full gender parity as equality

No. This is a massive strawman that is often repeated to justify the following counter-argument: "well, why aren't you complaining about all the other industries that don't have gender parity?", but it is not actually representative of the opposing viewpoint.


I'd much rather have a reasonable statement made in course language than an outrageous lie wrapped in friendly-sounding language.

"The issue is that _many_ people see full gender parity as equality...." What is this based on? I see this stated pretty often, but I don't think I've ever encountered someone who thinks this way.


I'm not sure the statement that "women were given the opportunity to be homemakers instead of laborers" really jives with reality.


It's OK not to be convinced by an argument, even a mathematical proof, and especially an informal proof.

But Cantor's argument is correct.

If you don't find a mathematical proof convincing even though all the trained mathematicians seem to believe the proof is correct, here's my advice. You should FIRST convert the proof into a sequence of valid deductions in a fixed logic. (If you cannot do this, you don't understand the proof/theorem; perhaps (re-)take a few mathematics courses.) If you can find a mistake in the completely formal proof, then you can convert that mistake into an informal explanation. If your disagreement boils down to a disagreement with a axiom in the formal system even though most mathematicians accept it as an adequate foundations, realize you're getting close to philosophy.

This advice is meant for people at the first phase in Terry Tao's hierarchy of mathematical maturity. So not great advice if you're a genius or a trained mathematician (read: people call you doctor).

> There is only one infinity. It means "repeat". It is simply the interplay of finite state with process. You can think of it as an "infinite loop" in programming. To say that one infinity is smaller than another is to deny that the smaller is infinite. Infinite means without bound.

But "modeling non-terminating loops in a computer program" is NOT the motivation for real numbers, so this foundational criticism of completing the rationals makes absolutely no sense.


> But "modeling non-terminating loops in a computer program" is NOT the motivation for real numbers

Indeed Turing himself proved that there are non-computable real numbers.


> That said, if anyone can think of something that I can do to help, I'm all ears.

You already live in this world.

Who cares if Goolge won't host these videos on youtube? I don't understand why this matters. There are millions of other video upload sites, all of which are extremely easy to find and use. There are literally too many open source options for sharing files to count, and many of them are even usable by non-technical folk. Millions of people shared videos online for at least a good decade before youtube became popular.

Maintain a local copy of everything you put on the cloud.


You seriously see no material difference in having your video on the YouTube vs on randomvideowebsite.com? It's not merely a question of finding a host to upload your file.


Not to mention the trouble when nobody will allow you to host your legal content because they disagree with the message. Hell, even registrars are refusing to point to an IP address.

I know... We all hate Nazis. I get it. I don't like them and, being not white, they definitely don't like me. But, they are the current good example of what happens when the controllers decide you can no longer share your legal content.

I don't know what the solution is, but I want a world where even the deplorable are able to express their thoughts and feelings. I want a world where we aren't cowards and trying to force conformity. I want a world where even the worst of us can express themselves, using the same tools as others, so long as it is legal content.

Yes, speech must have restrictions. However, we already know what those restrictions are. I guess I'm just a hopeless idealist.


It wasn't too long ago that we had the McCarthy era, where speech professing communism was effectively targeted by what were basically thought police.

Just as then you don't have to advocate free speech because you are a communist, now you don't have to advocate it because you are a Nazi. You advocate it to protect against authoritarianism.


That's why I do it. I hold what is now considered an extreme view on free speech. I don't even have anything politically incorrect to say, really. I just strongly believe in the freedom to express ideas.

A survey of young people really disturbs me. Some 40% don't believe we should have the right to free speech. I'll be damned if I know how to fix this. I see the same sentiments expressed by some people here.

Credible threats, slander, and libel are already illegal - as are a few others, such as divulging classified information. Speech needs all the protection it can get and, unfortunately, that means defending speech I don't particularly care for and people who would legitimately harm me if given the chance.

Speech we agree with doesn't need protection, nobody wants to silence it. However, that's subject to change based on the whims of society and the government. I guess I've become an extremist, even though I'm pretty sure I haven't changed. I just love free speech.


Yep, younger generations are being brain washed, unfortunately, to believe in an un-American authoritarian view on speech.

I agree with you. If you dont believe in free speech for those you disagree with, then you don't believe in free speech at all.


I literally defend literal Nazis. The Nazis hate me but they actually seem slightly less hyperbolic than those who dislike that I defend their basic human rights.

The White Nationalists tell me they'd kick me out of the country, which is funny because I'm mostly Native American. The others (I don't have a name for them) tell me that I don't even have a right to support their right to free expression. I'd rather be told that I'm hated then be told I have no right to speak.

Really, I think we can pretty much all agree that the Internet is largely a basic human right. With that, so shouldn't other protections apply. I think it's probably going to take regulation to get beyond this. I'm kind of hoping it's sensible regulation but it seems destined to happen eventually.


> A survey of young people really disturbs me. Some 40% don't believe we should have the right to free speech.

Do you have a link to this?



I appreciate your argument and the "when they came for me" quote. As an intellectual argument doesn't the government also exist to protect people, this is mostly about where the line is drawn between protecting society from some of its harmful members and protecting society from the government. Hard line to draw


What I would say is that while gov has a role to protect people's physical safety, what else do you believe is a legitimate role in protecting people from? Is it government's responsibility to care for your emotions? Do you think gov should cover our ears from mean words? Burn books that say things that you disagree with? Who decides what is disagreeable? Me? You? Trump? Eric Schmidt?

In a way, speech is already a very effective democratic institution. The more decentralized and the more participants, the more democratic. But if this voice is transferred from the people to the gov, the more power is handed from the people to the elites, and most likely the faster we will devolve into authoritarianism.


There are cults, groups and generally evil people who gain memeber ship thru words - brain washing - those groups then cause physical harm, waiting for the harm to happen doesn't sound like protecting society

While I appreciate your view I don't know where you live or who you are and I bet there is a group of people out there that hates you, and you would have a different view on freedom to publish the on google / Facebook when they target you


To your first paragraph: Take another issue, like marijuana or alcohol prohibition. I don't have to personally be into those to say that it's not a legitimate role of government to tell me whether I can use them. Also here, you can find that some will die every year because of them, and make the same argument you made: that government should jump ahead and not allow it. If they dont, then they aren't protecting society, so your argument goes.

Unfortunately here it's clear that life is far from perfect, but the moral question to ask is how can we make the best of it for all people? Should we ban everything because a few die: cars, sugar--what about swimming pools? Back flips? You see, I don't think this argument you made logically leads us to a very good world. Government can't protect us from everything. At some point we have to rely on faith in humanity. Not to mention with every power handed over from the people is given into the hands of government's propensity for corruption...

So while I don't approve of every group that will use free speech same as I dont use marijuana or have a swimming pool, but I don't think it's a legitimate role of government to regulate any of that.

In other words, I think more people will suffer w/o free speech than w/ it, but no solution will be perfect.

Ok, however your second paragrapah is really concerning me.


> I want a world where even the deplorable are able to express their thoughts and feelings.

Yes, but we (speaking as a person, not a representative of any company) don't have to supply them with a platform to spread their hate and we don't have to sit idly by while they do it.

> Yes, speech must have restrictions. However, we already know what those restrictions are

Do we? What are they?


You and parent seem to have missed my point.

I'm not defending google. I'm pointing out that using google is a choice, a choice with lots of alternatives.

Google's choice not to host certain things is itself a speech act. Don't try to police Google's speech. Instead, make sure there are plenty of alternatives to Google for the people who Google doesn't want to host.

If there's no alternative to google, then google's policing becomes a problem. THAT is why it's important that governments not censor speech -- you don't have alternative choices for government. And THAT is why privately owned censor-happy monopolies of the press are just as huge a threat to free speech as governments.

But -- and this is my point -- there are a near infinite number of alternatives to google. Google does not have a monopoly of the press.

If someone believes they can't speak freely because youtube won't host your videos, then that incorrect belief is a huge problem. A much larger problem than youtube choosing not to host their videos.


1. No, I don't see that huge of a difference. I really don't think that youtube has nearly as much influence over what the vast majority of people see as you seem to think it does.

2. Regardless, the solution is to become less dependent on corporate-owned ad-distribution networks for finding information. And help others do the same.

Modifying corporate behavior to match your preferences will never be a sufficient replacement for an informed, inquisitive, and self-sufficient populace. So focus on solving the latter problem instead of complaining about the first.

I think some people are reading my comments as a defense of Google. But I'm not defending google. I'm pointing out that the tools you need to get out from under Google already exist and are available today, as long as you want to speak (as opposed to e.g. make money from advertising).

If you use google services, you're making a choice. A choice with lots of alternatives. Telling people otherwise does google a huge favor.


If people dislike Google that much, they should set their own websites, there are plenty of video hosting service out there that doesn't have as tight a control as Youtube has.

The only reason that you want to post on Youtube, other than any other sites is that you want to make make money out of it.


Wait until you lose your gmail that you've used for everything for the last 10 years as a collateral damage.

You can't really maintain a local copy of a "control of @gmail.com" domain to be able for people to continue sending you messages.


For me it'd be max 7 days. And probably 99.999% spam.

What I said about video sites applies equally well to email. You don't even have to host your own; just choose a provider you trust. (If you disabuse yourself of the attitude that you shouldn't have to pay for email, there are more decent options than I could possibly hope to count.)

The "dependence" on Google for hosting videos and email accounts is entirely self-imposed. Honestly, if you want to fight Google's "monopoly", the only effective way is to point out the obvious fact that there are perfectly good alternatives.


This is why I have my own domain. I saw my use of my @gmail address as an issue a decade ago.


You should be hosting your own if you're serious about email.


Agreed, I suppose, but there are two further problems.

First, gmail then tends to screw you on deliverability for using an unknown source - and since everyone else uses gmail, you're still at Google's mercy when trying to communicate.

And second... that's our solution? Anyone who isn't capable of hosting their own email doesn't get to trust their access to their records? At a certain point we need to acknowledge that the company-centric structure is going to define tech for 98% of people, and that this will affect even the 2% who can step outside those bounds.


What else, government provided email hosting?


Nah, if I'm skeptical of Google's ethics I'm vastly more skeptical of that. Easy decentralization or quality data guarantees, preferably.

I'd feel better about Google if they offered a hard guarantee that any takedown would be done with notice to allow file recovery, and offered an easy, useful "export all my crap" feature for all users, takedown or not. (I'm aware that the recovery window is probably illegal at the moment.) I'd also like things better if they shelled out on some actual human reviewers and offered real support when they screw up.

What I actually want in the long run is for someone to offer decentralized, private hosting, or else build a tool to make self-hosting comparably easy to getting other email. As a stopgap, encrypted hosting would stop this sort of intrusion, but again hits legal takedown issues. "Click some buttons, pay $30, get privately-hosted email with no overseer" is my ideal endgame here.


For sufficiently weak notions of equality.

;-)


The 6.66 billion dollar question.


I mean, it sounds like he was trying help intimidate already fidgety witnesses. That's not just wasting the court's time.


What? I don't have context for what else has occurred, but it sounds like the lawyer in this case was objecting to the bond that the judge put on his client?


Person A was on trial for (attempted?) murder. Person B posts to InstaFaceGram that Person A will be free soon. Person B then shows up to court and starts live-streaming the court proceedings, included of witnesses, to a sketch-sounding Facebook group.

Person B then lies to judge about what he was doing and so the judge throws him in jail for 6 months for contempt.

The probable witness tampering probably had something to do with the harsh contempt punishment.


Ohhhhh. I see where I was wrong. I had only watched the second reference in op's post. Thank you for explaining.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: