What small businesses? Local business competing with Amazon were killed off more than a decade ago by Walmart.
If the status quo when Amazon started was a high minimum wage with strong unions and employee (or at least local) ownership, this might be a more compelling argument. As it is, the capitalists in Bentonville are losing out to the capitalists in Seattle because the former rely on massively state-subsidized labor while the latter just axes the labor all-together.
I'm not saying it isn't a problem, but this isn't something that was created by (or even made worse by) Amazon. This is an important point because without a proper diagnosis, we'll never find the cure.
Also, Amazon beating Walmart is an exemplar of free markets at work -- one competitor besting another on merit alone (actually, even DESPITE massive federal and state tax incentives propping up the losing side!) Maybe the conclusion you should be drawing from your dislike of the status quo is that free markets aren't a panacea after all?
Finally, I'll note that Amazon distribution facilities -- for all the valid criticisms -- at least pay a (barely) living wage in many areas. Walmart pays substantially less.
Let's not get carried away here. In the most recent quarter, Walmart had revenues of $123B vs Amazon's $38B. Walmart still has time to figure out the ecommerce game.
> It wasn't until Celera started embarrassing the NIH effort that shotgun sequencing was taken up in earnest.
Sure.
But I disagree with the overall premise and think you're over-simplifying in the extreme. What really made the Human Genome Project possible was the Moore-like curve in sequencing throughput that occurred throughout the lifetime of the Human Genome Project. There were many contributing factors that kept the curve going (including the other Moore curve!)
Also, Sangar never got a Nobel in Medicine (just in Chemistry). So even if shotgun sequencing is the idea that deserves the Nobel for Human Genome Project -- which again, isn't exactly an incontestable assertion -- then it's Sangar, not Venter, who was robbed. Awarding Venter with a scientific award for his political work pushing Sangar's science would be an odd choice, not to mention at odds with your apparent overall feelings about the role of politics in Nobel awards.
Which... maybe they both deserve a Nobel for their contributions to the Genome Project. Probably so, in my opinion. It's almost like the supply of Nobels is artificially constrained and not everyone who deserves one can get one...
> Later, his idea of then taking shotgun sequencing and applying it to whatever DNA you could find floating in the Sargasso Sea or any random teaspoon of dirt literally opened a whole new world of evolutionary biology.
Lots of people use shotgun sequencing for all sorts of high-profile and important stuff that is literally opening a whole new world of all sorts of important fields.
And there's a lot of stuff going on outside of genetic sequencing that also deserves Nobels.
> Finally, his more recent work on creating a fully synthetic organism is continuing to push forward the bleeding edge of biotechnology by laying a foundation all of humanity is sure to build on for decades to come.
So maybe a Nobel will be awarded in the decades to come. Nobels are given for impact, not promise, and impact takes decades to accrue even for the most impactful work.
I would never say someone like Venter "doesn't deserve a Nobel". But getting all bent out of shape that he doesn't have one is kinda weird, especially since he's not exactly starved of other sources of recognition -- both inside and outside Academia -- for his contributions. Lots of people who played outsized roles in the Human Genome Project exist in relative obscurity relative to Venter. Which isn't to say he doesn't deserve his recognition, but I just don't understand the particular drum you're beating here.
> but...the research being awarded is over 30 years old!
This is not irregular for the Nobel and Nobel-like awards.
> To say there's not been any more noteworthy and validated discoveries in Medicine since the mid '80s, well, I just don't buy it.
Who said otherwise?
> in Academia, politics and "playing by the rules" is valued far more than actual results.
The Nobel is an award whose supply is -- by design and definition -- massively and artificially constrained. Politics is just what happens when there are fewer resources than people who by all accounts deserve the resource. So Of course such awards are political. Your observation is just a tautology.
Also, you can replace "in Academia" with "in life" and the statement will be just as true.
> Just for starters, the fact that Venter still does not have a Nobel is a crime
Okay, and what about all of the other names that also could have come after "Just for starters"? Not everyone who deserves a Nobel will get one. That's life.
Technology isn't science. Science is a systematic discipline meant to understand the world in naturalistic terms. Technology has come to heavily rely on science, because it gives good, reliable results. Better than the hit/miss tinkering from before.
Learning from experience isn't science. Trial and error isn't science. There's more to it than that. Of course humans have been learning from trial and error since before we were homo sapiens. But we also explained things in terms of ancestral spirits, angry gods who needed to be appeased, creation stories, etc.
Along with all that learning came a lot of crazy beliefs and practices. It wasn't until science was an actual practice that we began to have systematic naturalistic explanations we could fit controlled experimental results into.
> Learning from experience isn't science. Trial and error isn't science. There's more to it than that.
Alhazen's Book of Optics is "not science" in exactly the same sense that constructions in Euclid's Elements are "not algorithms". Both claims are drawing, IMO, indefensible post-hoc epistemic lines in the sand.
> Along with all that learning came a lot of crazy beliefs and practices
I don't see why this matters.
1. Scientists, following a scientific process (perhaps not particularly well, but that's just a Scotsman argument), found themselves believing all types of crazy shit. Read about the 1950's. Science certainly dispels a lot of superstition, but it's not a bulwark against bad or lazy thinking.
2. Just because there existed supernatural explanations for e.g., crop rotation or glasses doesn't mean that the people who discovered those things weren't following a fundamentally scientific process.
> But we also explained things in terms of ancestral spirits, angry gods who needed to be appeased, creation stories, etc.
And?
Hell, there are still people who believe lightening and eclipses are supernatural events. It does not follow that we don't have a science that explains these phenomenon.
Parent's original point is just that libraries/frameworks are a much safer way of writing programs that handle untrusted input in security-critical settings.
Nothing you've said contradicts this original point (and I think it's a correct assessment). A compelling counter-argument, IMO, would be a demonstration of how to incorporate tried-and-trusted security checks into a bash script.
>> I would struggle to justify the work I'd need to do to write the equivalent in C (or python, where it would be slower) for one command that's only run in the release process.
The original article lists the CVEs that justify the extra work. You may say "that doesn't matter because any input to the release process must come from a trusted source anyways", but:
1) missing input validation can cause accidental catastrophic bugs just as easily as it can cause intentional catastrophic vulnerabilities, and
2) the whole point of defense in depth is that you shouldn't go around punching preventable holes in your defenses. IMO it shouldn't be possible to escalate from "request a build of the branch named 'X'" to "owning the release server".
(author here) Yes, but you have to take into account the context. Every minute you spend "securing" your RELEASE
NOTES is better spent securing the APPLICATION.
A lot of people seem to be missing the point -- this is a quick solution that also correct (*). It's a middle ground.
Yes it has drawbacks, and I analyzed those extensively in the article. Engineering is about tradeoffs. Given infinite resources, yes you want to do the "right thing". But you don't have infinite resources.
This is an interesting debate, but I think it misses the most important point: cost.
The Navy can buy thousands of Xbox controllers for the cost of even a single bespoke controller. The US has on the order of 100 submarines. Replacement controllers for the lifetime of each submarine -- even multiplied by 10 -- is a hilariously small cost compared to the alternatives.
So buy 1,000+ Xbox controllers and keep them in a warehouse. Problem solved.
> buy 1,000+ Xbox controllers and keep them in a warehouse.
Yes, I was going to suggest this. It would solve the availability issue and reduce the malware issue. If it's replacing a $38,000 item, they could buy 1,265 extra per sub.
> but I'd gladly pay 25 cents after reading a great article if it didn't require entering CC info and bouncing between three different webpages... Unfortunately, this would require immense coordination between web standards, browsers, OS vendors, and banks to implement
If you're okay with customers choosing to make piece-work payments after consuming the material, the problem becomes much easier because micro-payments don't have to be instantaneous or binding.
All you need is a not-terribly-insecure ledger that the consumer has full read/write access to, and approves of every month (perhaps implicitly for bills under $X). This removes a lot of the security/trust/coordination issues -- an 90% solution is good enough if you just double-check with the consumer before doing anything actually important. Similar to the proposal here: https://techcrunch.com/2017/09/17/the-learned-helplessness-o... Micro-payments made by browser software (sim. SSNs) become spam-reducing mechanisms rather than trusted tokens.
Of course, this doesn't work if you want true micro-payments; i.e., where the consumer pays for access to the material, instead of making a piece-work contribution after having already consumed the material.
And american signature-less swipe transactions and now the contactless sub-30-quid payment thing in .uk seem to make it pretty clear that below a certain amount, consumers really don't give a shit about explicitly approving things.
I think the most effective approach is somewhere in the middle -- you have to praise successful efforts. The more crucial part is organizing the curriculum so that every student has enough opportunities to "win" that they maintain confidence, but "lose" often enough that they don't become complacent.
That's hard enough to do in a 1:1 setting, let alone a 30:1 classroom. I think there's some benefit to 1:1 tutoring/individual enrichment any time a student isn't smack dab in the middle of the bell curve.
This is absolutely my experience -- even a few positive reinforcements ("Wow, that was a super clever idea! I wouldn't have thought of solving the problem that way!") can change students' mindset, at least in a particular class/subject.
It's amazing how few students are actually as bad as they appear to be on first pass. I basically go into every student/teacher interaction assuming the kid is above average, and I'm very rarely disappointed. That's because "average" is often pulled way down by issues surrounding self-image and study behavior, both of which have no bearing on raw ability.
Basically, "confidence + hard work" is usually enough to take a kid from below average to slightly above average.
If the status quo when Amazon started was a high minimum wage with strong unions and employee (or at least local) ownership, this might be a more compelling argument. As it is, the capitalists in Bentonville are losing out to the capitalists in Seattle because the former rely on massively state-subsidized labor while the latter just axes the labor all-together.
I'm not saying it isn't a problem, but this isn't something that was created by (or even made worse by) Amazon. This is an important point because without a proper diagnosis, we'll never find the cure.
Also, Amazon beating Walmart is an exemplar of free markets at work -- one competitor besting another on merit alone (actually, even DESPITE massive federal and state tax incentives propping up the losing side!) Maybe the conclusion you should be drawing from your dislike of the status quo is that free markets aren't a panacea after all?
Finally, I'll note that Amazon distribution facilities -- for all the valid criticisms -- at least pay a (barely) living wage in many areas. Walmart pays substantially less.