> the average American now scrapes by makes minimum wage working odd hours at a Starbucks with no benefits
The average American has adequate health benefits [1] and makes around $25/hr [2,3].
> We just export all this pollution to China.
We sure do.
> Instead of a good unionized manufacturing job
But I question the assertion that without China we would still have strong unionized manufacturing labor. In fact, globalization was just one component of an ultimately successful, century-long coordinated attack on unionized labor.
[1] About 100 million Americans have no or inadequate healthcare, which is of course inexcusable but still means the "average" American does have healthcare. And this being the USA, that healthcare is likely tied to employment.
The "median" here samples 16-year-olds in high school, retired people, stay-at-home parents, voluntarily part-time workers, and many others who we would expect to have little or no income.
Among full-time workers, as reported by the BLS, median income was about $45,000.
That's a rather special case; the nature of the HALE program means that you can't allow someone to ask "do SSNs X and Y belong to the same natural person?". Whereas such a question would be entirely reasonable for the SS issuing authority to answer under more normal circumstances.
(as for whether this case was actually a case of fraud, well, "the heart of Yould’s defense was that she thought she was allowed, under the hale program, to use the new Social Security number to apply for the loans above the lifetime cap and to use one name as a co-signer for loans to the other" pretty much sums it up for me... who would think that?!)
It's a bit more subtle than that, in the same way that the cost of an ad is larger than the cost to place that ad somewhere. But on steroids.
If you just show up and dump $300k on some politicians laps, the effect isn't likely to be particularly overwhelming. You need to cultivate relationships, wait for a good moment (when the money is disproportionately valuable to said politician), at least sell the perception that you're able and willing to dish up more in the future, etc.
So the actual cost is a lot higher than the amount the politician actually receives.
There are indexes[0] which categorise passports in what can be loosely defined as "powerful."
Some of these things may include not having to apply for a visa before entering a country (i.e visa-on-arrival or visa-free entry), cheaper visa costs or even free visas if they're required.
The New Zealand passport[1] is a good example (although not necessarily the best) of a "powerful" passport in this regard. Compare this to a Syrian passport[2] (extreme example) or a Colombian passport[3] (moderate example).
Posters are popular because they are cheap and compact, both for the presenters and (more importantly) for the conference.
Posters are usually used in high-volume settings with very light review. "Everybody" attending the conference gets to present a poster if they want to.
> a video... an interactive computer screen
Now you need 500 monitors at the conference venue, power cables, etc. The costs add up big time; hotels make a killing on this type of thing.
> a talk
You want to limit the number of talks so that the accepted talks are actually well-attended! So, not everyone gets to give a talk. Also, most people who give talks also present a poster because maybe there was a parallel session that stole some of your audience (who are interested enough to find you at the poster session).
At least in CS, no one is choosing a poster over a talk! talks are reserved for the work that passed the highest bar of peer review this year. (That said, I always recommend people present posters for some of the reasons described below. Even though talks are "higher status", IMO posters are often more effective once people are engaged.)
> a demonstration
These are sometimes rolled into poster sessions, but require more space and planning on the part of the organizers. Space at conferences is often hard to find.
> an interactive exhibit, a diorama, a play
This is kinda funny coming from a CS/math background. I guess in some fields this could make sense but would have the same drawbacks as videos or talks, respectively.
Thanks for a thorough, clear answer. The last two ideas were only to illustrate that one can imagine many more possibilities; personally, my last diorama was in 4th grade.
> except when something related to free software is at stake in politics.
They're the Mozilla Foundation, not the Free Software Foundation.
The free software movement has always been intertwined with more or less radical political movements to lesser or greater extents over time. It's only relatively recently that "open source" is primarily the thing you do so you have a GitHub profile that will land you a 100k paycheck.
Because there are people of various political ideologies that contribute to Mozilla and to free software. If tomorrow Mozilla decided "we support X ideology", then the organization would lose credibility and support from a lot of people. If the Mozilla CEO wants to do that, then fine, we'll find another organization to support and to look up to.
>And requesting the latter to be politically neutral is... well.
I don't see any incompatibility between free software and any political ideology.
> I don't see any incompatibility between free software and any political ideology.
My point (now edited into the comment) was that political activism has been intertwined with free software for a long time. Just think about the absurdity someone complaining about leftist politics at Richard Stallman's Free Software Foundation. This intertwining isn't some new thing, and it shouldn't be surprising.
> I don't see any incompatibility between free software and any political ideology.
But for many of the original strong advocates for free software, there was an enormous link between larger political issues and free software.
You can argue that those links aren't fundamentally necessary or have eroded over time, but to deny them is an anti-historical understanding of the free/open source software movement.
> then the organization would lose credibility and support from a lot of people. If the Mozilla CEO wants to do that, then fine, we'll find another organization to support and to look up to.
Open source wasn't always so mainstream. My money is that the people who have been around for decades aren't fased by these sorts of threats.
>political activism has been intertwined with free software for a long time.
Only in the sense of privacy and civil freedoms e.g free speech, copyright. Not in the sense of capitalism/socialism, collectivism/individualism, more taxes/less taxes. In this case, Mozilla supported an organization that is openly against capitalism. I would have applauded Mozilla if they'd supported an organization in favor of free speech, privacy, freedom of information, etc. But that wasn't the case. Capitalism is a gray area for the free software community: some support it, others fight against it.
The difference is back then it was OK to be political about American politics because it only affected Americans. Now technology touches every part of the world and information travels in seconds via social media.
There are a lot of software developers I used to respect and followed on Twitter whom I stopped following because I got sick of their American politics tweets. I'm sure it's the same dynamics with American celebrities tweeting about Donald Trump. Most of the world don't care about Donald Trump nor want to hear about some privileged rich Americans complaining about their politics.
They havre their own shit to worry about and don't have time to be force-fed all the American political propaganda.
I can understand individuals being political, but if you're an organization like Mozilla, you have a clear goal, and that is NOT left politics. They should aspire to be as neutral as they can.
Neutrality is not something anyone should ever aspire to. It is something you do when it is otherwise correct, not something you set out to do. To do otherwise is contradictory and absurd.
If they come out in support of an issue, they will also gain support from people on that side of the issue.
Free software goes pretty strongly against market capital as a philosophy.
It goes against the idea that people will pay for things they need/want. It goes against the idea that commerce will spawn progress.
That's fine, and people don't need to be that ideological. But if you want to promote free software, then: basic income, single payer, the 30 hour week, greater research spending, stronger practice of public domain-ing government financed work will all help
And lots of more left-leaning orgs will go along that.
> It pains me that my generation, a generation of people who dream of being makers and business owners...
Not just business owners, but startup founders. Also, emphasis on the "owner" not the "maker". There's no real fetish for hackers disconnected from business ownership in the zeitgeist.
Why would a temporarily embarrassed monopolist support monopoly busting?
Would there be so many “temporarily embarrassed monopolists” if people had an easier time imagining a world in which they didn’t have to be the end all be all winner in order to build and be proud of something sustainable?
The average American has adequate health benefits [1] and makes around $25/hr [2,3].
> We just export all this pollution to China.
We sure do.
> Instead of a good unionized manufacturing job
But I question the assertion that without China we would still have strong unionized manufacturing labor. In fact, globalization was just one component of an ultimately successful, century-long coordinated attack on unionized labor.
[1] About 100 million Americans have no or inadequate healthcare, which is of course inexcusable but still means the "average" American does have healthcare. And this being the USA, that healthcare is likely tied to employment.
[2] https://www.fool.com/investing/general/2015/01/18/how-does-y...
[3] There are problems with [2], but computing (Mean Household Income https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Household_income_in_the_United... )/2 earners/52/40 = $17/hour as a very conservative lower bound.