Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more throwawayjava's commentslogin

I believe the reason that the root post is the top-voted comment is that it poses a helpful question: how do we fix this?

My suggestion is that people stop being so damn concerned about their moral status and start caring more about actually fixing things.

A system with de facto separate and unequal schools is just as bad as a system with de jure separate and unequal schools. Whether that's the result of an emergent phenomenon or explicit planning has little effect on the people stuck in the system.

If someone's fragile moral ego gets in the way of an accurate description of the problem... well, that person's ego is the problem.

FWIW you see the same problem in flailing engineering projects.


> My suggestion is that people stop being so damn concerned about their moral status and start caring more about actually fixing things.

This is silly. Moral status is a necessary component of political capital. The entire reason the progressive left stuck to their confusing "systemic racism" term is because it conveniently allows them to strip dissidents and critics of the political capital necessary to implement their fixes or even advance the national discourse. Of course, we could think wishfully about a world where politics were irrelevant (as I sometimes do), but that's not productive.


What alternative term would you use to refer to racially disparate outcomes that are the result of how large systems operate?

The term "systemic racism" was coined and stuck because it's evocative of the actual idea, not as some sort of grand conspiracy to strip you of your honor.

But I don't care. We can call it "silly putty" if it means we can actually talk about it instead of closely defending our honor. And if you have an alternative name that is evocative of the underlying problem and doesn't offend you, I'd love to hear it.

> This is silly

It is my experience that when people disarm themselves, productive conversations are possible.

Perhaps I'm wrong. But if so, then there's no solution anyways. So we might as well try.


It's hard to believe you care about advancing the conversation when you respond with straw men and ad hominems. Of course, I'm used to it because I challenge positions like yours a lot. Still, the constant need to redirect these bad faith rebuttals is exhausting.

To be clear, I don't care much for "my honor". Like I said, I care about making good outcomes politically tenable. As for conspiracy theories, that's literally what "systemic racism" is. And we could talk about it if it weren't for all of the weasel words and slander.

If you cared about the conversation, you'd be trying to get rid of the weasel words instead of attacking the people who call them out.


> It's hard to believe you care about advancing the conversation when you respond with straw men and ad hominems

You're right. Chalk it up to frustration in a different thread. My apologies.

> As for conspiracy theories, that's literally what "systemic racism" is

I mean, that's clearly hyperbolic, right? Systemic racism is a real thing -- see red lining or Jim Crow. We can at least agree that the concept is useful and refers to a real phenomenon, even if we're going to debate the severity/degree of that phenomenon in the present.

> you'd be trying to get rid of the weasel words

I don't think systemic racism is a weasel word. I think it's a well-chosen, evocative, and just damn accurate noun for the concept it represents.

Again, do you have an alternative word?


> You're right. Chalk it up to frustration in a different thread. My apologies.

Thank you for the apology; I understand the cumulative frustration bit. Hopefully I wasn't the cause of the frustration in the other thread.

> Again, do you have an alternative word?

I would say "disparate outcomes that correlate with race" or some such. I don't object to "systemic racism" when it specifically means "disparate outcomes caused by racism" (e.g., redlining and jim crow); however, it's often used as a blanket term for any racial disparity whether or not there is evidence that it's actually part of the system and not simply the result of different choices made by different groups, or an artifact of documented historical oppression. In the latter case, its effect is to shut down any conversation about the actual cause of the disparity, because anyone who questions the systemic racism explanation is guilty of endorsing racism.

So if that's not a weasel word, it's something similarly nefarious and inhibitive of dialog.

I really think all parties (or at least those who aren't threatened by advancing the dialog) are better served by clear, meaningful terms, and I don't think that's what we have with "systemic racism". Insofar as it means what you say, then it's grossly and widely misused, which has the same effect as if the word were meaningless to begin with.


I don't think the line you're trying to draw is easy -- or even possible -- to draw.

What about cities that were originally segregated via red-lining, but now remain extremely segregated along those same geographic lines today even after those policies have been eliminated? Is that systemic racism?

In almost all cases, systemic racism is caused by a complex mix of historical racism, contemporary racism, and rational economic choices that aren't taken with explicit racial intent but none-the-less help sustain the inertia of the system.


> What about cities that were originally segregated via red-lining, but now remain extremely segregated along those same geographic lines today even after those policies have been eliminated? Is that systemic racism?

Disclaimer: This is mostly exploring a society where racism (as it is traditionally defined) has been completely removed. This isn't what we have (we both agree on this point), but the exercise is still useful in theory.

Assuming all such policies are removed, I would confidently say "no" for lots of reasons. Firstly, integration doesn't happen the moment racist forces are removed. Minority groups can and often do self-segregate for reasons that no reasonable person would identify as anti-minority racism (e.g., the social stability in a shared culture, hatred for people who look like historical oppressors [I guess this one is racism, but not one that is talked about under the rubric of 'systemic racism'], etc). Secondly, all else equal, a system in which wealth grows linearly would still see a growing disparity between disparate races even apart from racism; this is not desirable, but it's still not "systemic racism" in any meaningful sense. Thirdly, there are economies of scale to be had by participating in the majority culture, privileging those who've integrated over those who haven't--if you remove barriers to integration and some minority groups haven't integrated, they're at a disadvantage. Some might argue that this is systemic racism because the system privileges one group over another, but it's only related to race insofar as races tend to correlate with cultures, and also because it is a universal cultural reality completely divorced from any racist motive. Lastly, (by definition) different cultures make different decisions in different distributions--if some cultures make decisions that lead to poorer outcomes even if those cultures are the manifestation of historical oppression, it's still not systemic racism if all active forces of racism have been removed from the system.

Of course, all of this goes out the window if "the system" encompasses minority cultures and "racism" is allowed to mean "any disparity between races"; however, no one uses it in that sense, or at least every time a moderate or conservative brings up one of these "different choices -> different outcomes" possibilities, legions of university professors and other esteemed progressives shout them down, "no, it's systemic racism!" implying that "systemic racism" excludes cultures that choose their own disparities.

Of course, this whole semantic exploration is testament to the ambiguous nature of the term.


When I'm feeling contemplative, I really want to read something continental for the evening. But when I have shit to do, I snap into an analytic frame of mind.

I feel the same way about programming languages; the Kierkegaardian crowd (C++, Perl) are great for evening enjoyment, but I'd prefer something from the more analytic tradition to language design when there's work to be done.


I tend to agree... for me, C++ is a great solution for problems I don't tend to have in my workaday life.


For a lot of what I do (large-scale, scientific computing), C++ is exactly what I need: it's expressive/compact when I need it to be, and its compile-time metaprogramming lets me do things faster in ways no other language can.

For testing and interactive analysis, I can easily use pybind11 to generate bindings. And because python integration is so easy, I can know many other people will be able to use it.

That's the balance I like best.


so you program in prolog or coq when you really need to get stuff done?


It's just an analogy, and I didn't claim it's perfect :-)

But there's a divide between language authors who sound like engineers/mathematicians and language authors who sound like continental philosphers.

I'd include languages like Java, Python, Go, Haskell, OCaml to be in the "analytic tradition" as well. And yes. lots of people get lots of work done in those languages :-)


I'd agree that Python and OCaml are analytic. But personally I find Java much more "continental" than C++, in that it combines aesthetics and function in a way that is both time-tested/consistent and expressive. C++ has always felt like a programming language designed with the same philosophy in mind that Frankenstein had when creating his monster.


Comparing C++ to Frankenstein is a bit of a dis-service to the time spent developing this language.

There's some bad innards from C compatibility, but that's only a small sliver of the overall language. The language overall is very big, but has a high level of consistency and.... dare I say orthogonality.

The open-ness of the language at the outset, especially around the breadth of available overloading, means that future improvements can work in an extremely wide space. It's one of the few languages that stays true to the "every type is a class, no type is special" philosophy.

It's powerful stuff and gives you more control than you can find almost anywhere else, especially with the more modern improvements that pull in a lot of goodies from other languages.

I'd say the biggest wart is the compiler-linking process... the fact that the preprocessor is still a thing is rough.


C++ is configurable in all the wrong ways. Its orthogonality is only with respect to a C-oriented perspective on the world; it doesn't have a philosophy, so much as "like C but let me customize most of the underlying operations". That it is usable at all is mostly down to enormous amounts of effort and careful selection of idioms. Writing C++ reminds me a bit of playing chess: if you're deep in the idiom, there are only a handful of moves to consider, but if you're out of it, there are so many mistakes you can make.

I like the "pit of success" analogy. In design (whether it's API or language, or even physical mechanisms), doing the right thing should be the easiest way to go. C++ has a narrow ridge of success, with cliffs not far from either side.

A more orthogonal, more powerful and even more controllable language, to me, would be some variant of Scheme or Lisp that let you produce fully typed ASTs or even target code for the places where you need absolute control over performance, but high level enough to focus on the business domain problems most of the time. C++ demonstrably simply can't climb very far in the abstraction stack; people don't write web apps in C++. That's the metric that matters in the end.


> Comparing C++ to Frankenstein is a bit of a dis-service to the time spent developing this language.

Bolting more bits onto Frankenstein wouldn't make him less of a monster.


Hm. I tend to think more in terms of how using the language makes me feel than in terms of what the language design reminds me of.

I see what you mean, though.


Whether or not you intended this as a joke: As a matter of fact, I actually do!


You'd need a damn broad definition of Marxism for that to make much sense.

Economy and class are so central the Marx's philosophy that saying "Just s/<insert anything here>/class" doesn't make any sense. You can't just go into Capital and s/<insert anything here>/class and end up with anything that makes any sense. The entire analysis needs restructuring.

At some point, if Marxism is defined that way, you might as well just call any materialist philosophy "basically Marxist". Which is silly.

Tangentially, I've seen a lot of "so basically (cultural) Marxism" type comments lately about anything and everything left-leaning in the US. Something memetic is going on there.


You'd need a damn broad definition of Marxism for that to make much sense.

You have groups vying for power, with one group systemically oppressing another, and the morality of the situation adjudicated at that granulatiry. How does that not work? Can you reply with a specific?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VjNJX64cBOE

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YGRVhsNX5Ao

Tangentially, I've seen a lot of "so basically (cultural) Marxism" type comments lately about anything and everything left-leaning in the US. Something memetic is going on there.

The memes (in the academic Richard Dawkins sense) which stick around are often the ones which have the strength of truth behind them.


> You have groups vying for power, with one group systemically oppressing another, and the morality of the situation adjudicated at that granulatiry

You've just described thousands of years of history prior to Marx and hundreds of years of history after Marx across every single axis of the political spectrum.

This is more a description of "effective political messaging" than a description of "Marxism".

Has there ever been a great politician -- good or evil -- who didn't believe they had the weight of morality on their side? Who didn't tap into feelings of oppression, real or perceived?

Even Hitler cast his politics in terms of an oppressed people with a moral right to rise up. And if Mein Kampf is Marxist then you've got one hell of a definition of Marxism.

> The memes (in the academic Richard Dawkins sense) which stick around are often the ones which have the strength of truth behind them.

Well, anything popular taps into some truth, usually about the audience with whom the popular thing resonates.

But tapping into some truth and actually being true are two very different things.

Interpreted any other way, your claim is silly. Mutually exclusive ideas achieve this sort of memetic status (with different subpopulations) all the time.


You've just described thousands of years of history prior to Marx and hundreds of years of history after Marx across every single axis of the political spectrum.

Which is precisely what Marx claims to do, with essentially the model which Marx claims does so.

Well, anything popular taps into some truth

It's pretty obvious that Postmodernism is homomorphic to Marxism. It's also well documented that Postmodernism has intellectual roots in Marxism. Marxism is also outwardly and openly claimed by many in the current day political left in the US, in particular, the part which originates and most vigorously promotes Intersectionality.


> Which is precisely what Marx claims to do, with essentially the model which Marx claims does so.

Again, no. Marx's characterization is much more concrete than that, and really cannot be separated from notions of class and capital and commodity-form without rendering the term "Marxist" nearly meaningless. Or at least synonymous with much less politically-charged ideas like "materialism" or even just "politics". Separating Marx from those things is like separating Jesus from Christianity.

The next two criticism are more tangential and obvious, but hopefully more illustrative of the problem with the way you're trying to re-define Marxism

1. A capitalist operating as Marx would predict is not himself a Marxist, so your statement is especially confusing for more than one reason.

2. Plenty of non-Marxist -- even conservative economists -- tap into various Marxist ideas. And even more tap into the same ideas that Marx was himself building on (e.g., the effectiveness of providing moral justifications on the basis of oppression... not a Marxist innovation!). So drawing any tangential connection to Marx and labeling anything connected by that tangent as "Marxist" implicates 100% of economists. Which, again, makes the label "Marxist" kind of silly and pointless.

If you strip Marxism of Marx's actual core ideas, then "Marxism" ceases to mean anything. And class is a central component of those ideas.

At some point referring to something as "Just Marxism s/.../class" begins to occupy the "you are an idiot" box in on the PG argument hierarchy.

> It's pretty obvious that Postmodernism is homomorphic to Marxism

This seems mostly off-topic... you'll have to draw out the connection for me. (edit: Obviously, plenty of postmodernists critique closeparen's post and plenty of non-postmodernists would agree with closeparent's post. Are you sure you mean postmodernism?)


really cannot be separated from notions of class and capital and commodity-form without rendering the term "Marxist" nearly meaningless.

The Intersectional claim is basically that inherent markers like race have become a functionally like a marker of class.

Separating Marx from those things is like separating Jesus from Christianity.

You just keep on asserting this without specifying why -- probably because you find it particularly embarrassing. So you're saying there's something magically special about the very specific formulation? Many atheists have noted that Jesus has many similarities to many other religious/mythical figures. The principles are usefully generalized. As is the with religion, the fact that there are these patterns is significant in itself.

"Marxism" in such broad-brush terms is certainly not meaningless in any case. Use "collectivist" if you like. Anyone who throws individual rights under the bus in favor of the interests of the group and says phrases like "By any means necessary" or "all power comes from the end of a gun" is a party to ideologies which have played out in the deaths of tens of thousands to tens of millions of people, across different cultures, in different times, again and again throughout history.


> The Intersectional claim is basically that inherent markers like race have become a functionally like a marker of class.

Hm. Unless closeparen edited their comment, I've very confused, because that's not at all the claim that closeparen made.

In fact, the "all racism is really just a form of classism" is more common in conservative circles than leftist circles.

> So you're saying there's something magically special about the very specific formulation?

No, not at all. It's just one more idea. And it has a name. That name is Marxism. Use each name for the thing that it refers to, and nothing else.

> "Marxism" in such broad-brush terms is certainly not meaningless in any case.

Not really. Marxism refers to the political philosophy laid out in Capital and popularized in texts like the Manifesto. It refers to Marx's synthesis of a bunch of specific ideas -- Hegel's dialectics, materialism, the labor theory of value, commodity form, class warfare, markets, etc. -- some of which were unique to Marx and some of which pre-dated him by centuries. Marxism refers to, you know, Marx's system of thought.

I submit that whatever alternative definition you're proposing is silly and confusing.

> Anyone who throws individual rights under the bus in favor of the interests of the group

It's all fine and well that you're a traditional liberal, but calling everything that's "not you" a Marxist is pretty lazy.


Hm. Unless closeparen edited their comment, I've very confused

I wasn't specifically referring to closeparen's comment at that point. What are you trying to pull?

And it has a name. That name is Marxism.

Sounds like your intoning some kind of quasi-religious exceptionalism.

Marxism refers to, you know, Marx's system of thought.

Which historically results in one group of people violently seizing stuff from another group of people using some collectivist morality because individual rights means nothing to them. Nothing confusing about that.

calling everything that's "not you" a Marxist is pretty lazy.

I'm calling everything collectivist that has resulted in the above Marxist. Historically, most everything collectivist that has gained control of a society has resulted in the above and has called itself "Marxist."


> I'm calling everything collectivist that has resulted in the above Marxist.

Which is silly and does not comport how anyone serious about political economy would use the term "Marxist".

You're free to use whatever words you want, but don't expect productive dialog if you dream up crazy definitions that no one else uses.


Because frankly Marx was not broadly concerned with discussions of morality and oppression of 'groups' in a general sense as you seem to be implying. He was quite strictly concerned with an economic analysis of capitalist exploitation, and not necessarily exploitation in our contemporary moral sense (as in child explotation) but more in the sense that we talk about exploiting nature, or a tool. Marx's analysis was almost purely an economic one, where he pointed out that the economic model of capitalism and our modern notion of private property created a class division based around the extraction of profits ('surplus value') from labour through the ownership and control of the tools of production. All 3 volumes of Capital are about this, and he spends little time discussing power or domination in a general way and basically almost none on racism, sexism, or colonialism except as they tie into capitalist exploitation.

The phrase 'cultural Marxism' only betrays how little right wing pundits who use this phrase actually understand of Marxian theory and postmodern cultural studies generally, since frankly the vaguely left wing strains of academic cultural theory spent the last 50 years _critiquing_ Marxism from the vantage point that it did not pay enough attention or have a meaningful theory to talk about these issues. Postmodernism and Marxism generally have been somewhat 'at war' within academia, though generally you'll find that the 'founding fathers' of cultural studies and postmodernism (say, Adorno, or Derrida, Foucault) themselves express admiration or sympathy for Marx himself though they rarely considered themselves Marxists per se. "Cultural Marxism" is kind of a misnomer -- they'd be better off saying "left wing postmodernists" or "liberal cultural relativists" or something, but those don't sound as boogeyman, do they?


Because frankly Marx was not broadly concerned with discussions of morality and oppression of 'groups' in a general sense as you seem to be implying...Marx's analysis was almost purely an economic one

Your point ascribes to me a sense of morality to me as a sneaky way of putting words in my mouth. "as you seem to be implying." In reality, I need no more than the Marx's subsumed sense of morality/justice in Marx's analysis for my point to stand.

"Cultural Marxism" is kind of a misnomer -- they'd be better off saying "left wing postmodernists" or "liberal cultural relativists" or something

Not a misnomer at all. Many who fall under the banner openly proclaim themselves Marxist, or subscribe to those ideas in their writings. For those who don't, there's still the matter of the homomorphisms between Marxism and Social Construction.


Look you're free to use language (and downvotes) however you want, but I and others are merely pointing out that you are applying a very broad brush which basically amounts to "I can see similarities here, so I'll just call them the same thing" -- Marx may have had a 'subsume[d] sense of morality' in his analysis of capitalism but that doesn't mean anybody who has a similar sense of morality about another topic is now a Marxist.

Socrates is a man, all men are mortal, not all mortals are Socrates.


Look you're free to use language (and downvotes) however you want

I've not downvoted you, at least in this thread. HN doesn't let you downvote in threads you participate in.

"I can see similarities here, so I'll just call them the same thing"

Isn't that how it works, especially with ideologies and models?

Socrates is a man, all men are mortal, not all mortals are Socrates.

Yes, but I'm talking about specific principles, not just species membership. Socrates spoke greek. He lived in Athens. Not all mortals are Athenian, but Socrates surely was an Athenian. There is a specific problem when one deals with people as groups, as in race and class, in that one tends to throw individuals under the bus for not towing the line of the group. Historically, this can number in the tens of thousands or the tens of millions.


> Isn't that how it works, especially with ideologies and models?

No. Ideologies are labels that have meanings, sometimes very specific meanings. And even though there are overlaps between some ideologies and others, conflating terms is still disingenuous and unhelpful.

Marx believed in profit-motive, to be sure. That doesn't make Marx a Capitalist. Calling all "collectivists" Marxists is similarly silly.

> Yes, but...

Your parent was making a comment about the flawed logic in your argument justifying your misuse of the term "Marxism", not your overall opinion on identity politics.

Your response is totally irrelevant to that criticism.

See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Syllogism


(It's worth noting that, while this sort of thing comes up a lot in the context of the midwest, the midwest isn't special in this regard.)

> I think that communities in the Midwest have tighter cultural restrictions on what it means to be "one of us."

The genetic basis for delineating "races" is sketchy at best. The cultural aspects are as important as skin color to the definition of race, which is why either the first or second definition of "race" in any reasonable dictionary refers to all these things aside from "melanin content".

So at some point, segregating oneself from people who worship differently, go to different schools, play different sports, ... -- especially in communities where many of these divisions are inspired by geography distributions that were intentionally created along racial lines less than a century ago -- is more than just "unhappy coincidence".

But let's set that aside for a moment and take your assertion as fact.

> This puts the Midwest in a really hard place because just about any white person can claim (truthfully) they are not being racist. Yet, the outcome of the collective actions of all of them end up with a pretty strong divide that is mostly along racial lines.

Indeed. Sometimes, the consequences of aggregate social behavior are more important than individual intent. (Actually, I'd argue almost always.)

A community in which wealth is disproportionately divided along racial lines is a racist community, even if no one in that community harbors individual and purely racially motivated prejudice.

> Does anyone have suggestions on how to fix this?

Teach people how to think dispassionately about systems.

I'm not sure that there is a way to fix this without switching from a "nominally typed" definition of racism to a "structurally typed" definition of racism.

Such a definition already exists. And by happy coincidence, the programming analogy works especially well because this notion is already called "structural racism".

> So it seems like it is an impossible situation.

At least for the current generation, for whom anything short of direct and violent prejudice on the basis of a few phenotypes is the only thinkable definition of racism, and for whom "racist" is a stinging moral and personal indict rather than a statement of fact about an emergent phenomenon that may or may not have anything to do with the content of any particular individual's character.


> At least for the current generation, for whom anything short of direct and violent prejudice on the basis of a few phenotypes is the only thinkable definition of racism, and for whom "racist" is a stinging moral and personal indict rather than a statement of fact about an emergent phenomenon that may or may not have anything to do with the content of any particular individual's character.

This is so well said, I think it deserves to be singled out

So many people get personally offended when one is discussing these matters.


All human communities like to define themselves in terms of in-groups and out-groups. All of them, including this one.

In the Midwest, you have to make the decisions finer since most people around really are indistinguishable on the usual terms.


I think the truth of that statement largely depends upon which "midwest" you're talking about.

It's certainly not true in the suburbs around the mid-sized cities in the midwest. Or the smaller manufacturing towns in the rust belt.

It may be true in the more rural areas of Minnesota or Kansas, though.


This is an excellent analysis. The author hints at something similar in the article: "['flyover country' is] a stereotype about other people’s stereotypes". Which I thought was also really an excellent description turn of phrase


I wouldn't read too much into that. I bet the pass rates on other professional exams are similarly skewed.

Lots of hopeless pre law students will take the exam. Very few unmotivated math students will find themselves taking the lsats, however.


I see what you're saying, and agree, but the description you give reminds me of this:

http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_QNmG5af9rFs/R3ypiFV0XaI/AAAAAAAAAu...

Or, to be a bit less flippant about it:

  * flip phones
  * phones with slideout keyboards
  * blackberries
  * palm pilot stylus
The featureless slab beat all of those for a few important reasons, but probably the most important is aesthetic. Even the iPad Pro, which has a stylus, is much more aesthetic, and so less nerdy, than the old palm stylus.

So I also understand the ambivalence toward deviating from the featureless slab.


Isn't kind of weird that what is considered good aesthetic is removal of (visual) features? Why is that considered good looking?

If you take it to its extreme conclusion, the best environment to live in from an aesthetic perspective would be a big white box with each side being made up of a material that changes its hardness based on what you want to do (lie down to sleep and becomes soft, walk on it, becomes hard, sit on a corner and becomes slightly soft on the floor with very soft walls) and all your communication and entertainment is done via floating images that materialize at a comfortable distance from your face so you can talk with your peers, watch videos, holograms and whatever else. Getting outside would have a part of the wall disintegrate (we'd call that a door, for historical reasons), although "outside" would now just be an aesthetically pleasing sea of white featureless cubes.


The removal of visual features may make some things more aesthetically appealing, but it also allows the objects to be more easily fit into your particular preferences.

As an example, I have a digital photo frame. It has a large bezel that's silver/grey with black trim. It does not fit well on my desk. I have a minimalist style in my home. Removing that bezel would allow the object to sit on my desk and actually look like it belonged.

On the other hand, my girlfriend's home has a beach/Caribbean thing going on. Most of her photos and art are in wood frames (with an unfinished look). The bezel on this digital frame makes putting it inside a wooden frame of that sort difficult (it would need to be too large, or strategically positioned so you didn't realize it was just a façade).

Reducing the bezel, for her, would allow the frame to be placed inside of a wooden frame that fit her styling much better. The object would not stand out, it would blend into the environment.

My view: A minimalist aesthetic for objects is not desirable because the minimalist aesthetic is desirable. It is desirable because objects of this form are more easily placed inside any environment. An object with an opinionated appearance will stand out unless it fits the rest of your possessions. This may or may not be desirable. But it should be up to the owner of the object whether attention is drawn to it, not up to the creators of the object.

EDIT: Fixed a word or two. This was my 3rd write-up of this because they kept disappearing so I wrote it rather hastily.


I would live in that (Ikea?) house in a heartbeat, though not your white-featureless-cube dystopian horror outside. My ideal house has almost nothing in it.

For some, aesthetic is certainly greeblies[0], but I think minimalism is widely accepted as one aesthetic ideal. Why? Why does anyone prefer anything? I'm not sure we exactly know yet, from an art/design/aesthetic perspective.

Edit: OTOH, I am pretty sure my dad's mother preferred a mass of junk and clutter and mess in her house, to make it feel alive.

[0]https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=greeblies


There are a lot of cliches in design about this. "Take things away until you cry." "Perfection is achieved when there is nothing left to take away."

The point is not minimalism for the sake of minimalism, and not always to be aesthetically pleasing (although with cell phones, it is). The point is to find where form meets function, to make something with no superfluous elements.


What you're speaking about may not be a question of aesthetic, but rather a question of functionality (hidden keyboard - clean, no-accidental-presses keyboard) and size.


There were a lot of factors, but I think aesthetics was a major component. The iPhone was a lot more than one more addition to the smart phone wars. IMO it created a product class for a bunch of consumers who probably never would've bought a blackberry or palm pilot. For a lot of reasons, some related to timing and others related to design. But a big component was the marketing, and aesthetics was a big reason for the success of the marketing.


Sadly, I've got to disagree with your point of view, and you do seem to have a hugely engineer-y viewpoint on what is "aesthetic".

There's a functional aspect going together with the novelty factor in introducing a new, touchable screen that does not require physical buttons to be controlled - but it is just a matter of driving the wave of what is fashionable today (or well, tomorrow).

The lack of detail _can_ be aesthetic, but it does not mean that something with a huge amount of detail could not be as aesthetic.

Depending on when and where you're introducing your product:

  - single-button switch supporting voice control for your lights? Works for me.

  - voice-controlled power drill? Not so much (unless it's actually a hired human handling the power drill with his own hands and listening to my commands).


> but it does not mean that something with a huge amount of detail could not be as aesthetic

Yes, that's why my initial comment indicated I agree with jmull.


Or maybe the slab just had a big pretty screen and all of the potential of soft keys. Screen took up as much space as possible, ergo it was a slab.


No. As noted elsewhere, no education is provided through 90% of these courses. They meet zero times per week and have no real instructor. They are a book keeping exercise so that PhD students are still technically students while working in the lab, not an actual tangible educational course.

This is a just a significant decrease in research funding that is, by default at least, implemented as a substantial tax increase on grad students (those bastards...?), who now pay tax on 40k/year of tuition for literally imaginary courses.

I agree the situation is awkward and stupid, but the material effect is what matters. Without a corresponding increase in science and education funding this is basically an enormous cut to science funding and undergraduate education funding. And it's one that is by default shouldered exclusively by people making 20k / year.


If it has no value, then there is no value to waive. If there is no value to waive, there is no value transfer. Either they should pay taxes on it, or the university should stop 'waiving' tuition and simply make it 'free'. What absolutely should not happen is a special entry in our tax policy for this perverted case.

If it is indeed simply a 'book keeping' exercise, then what it really is is an attempt to subvert some other policy. I'm not sure what that policy might be (student loan terms, perhaps?) But whatever it is, it's that policy that should change. Not tax policy.


> If it is indeed simply a 'book keeping' exercise, then what it really is is an attempt to subvert some other policy. I'm not sure what that policy might be (student loan terms, perhaps?) But whatever it is, it's that policy that should change. Not tax policy.

It's an attempt to recognize the problem of needing students to be fully enrolled to be defined as students often by law.

It's far easier to put in a tax waiver to take care of the consequences of that than it is to change that policy, at a state level, and figure out all the downstream issues of that - which will also probably impact the tax code.


Exactly. And why do they need to be defined as students by law?


For one thing, so they can be eligible for student services like health care. So student loan repayments don't trigger while they're still in school. Any international student on a student visa. Accurate tracking of which professors go to which graduate students, and the means to record their progress.

And that's just off the top of my head.


If you want to reduce research funding to pay for a tax cut, then do that directly! Don't add 7k to the tax burden of people making 30k a year.


No, paying for things directly is how they ought to be paid for. Paying for them through tax cuts is why we have a perverse tax policy. If you want to subsidize something, subsidize it. Or, if it's so important, maybe the universities should be paying for it. They have plenty of money. That being said, I don't mind the government subsidizing research. What I do mind is them subsidizing it through tax policy.


This. What it actually is is a tax cut funded by a stealthy cut to the NIH/NSF/DoE/CDC etc. research budgets.

It's eating the seed corn. Quietly, but it's there.


No, what was stealthy was funding it this way in the first place. If you want to fund something, fund it. Don't fund it through tax policy. Tax policy should be about revenue collection, not funding research.


But it's not funding anything!

There is no actual income being made. This is imposing a tax on something that no one actually gets! It's an accounting procedure used by Universities so they can meet the requirements of you being a student by law.

I am a PhD student. My tuition of $30,000/year is waived by the University of California since I take no classes and am purely doing research. I need to be a student for various tax purposes for both the University and myself. If the money from my waiver was taxed, I would somehow have to come up with an extra $10,000 out of nowhere! Where do I find that money? My PhD is my job. The government is not funding anything, and I feel you're using that terminology purely to muddy the issue.

To be clear, I don't much care for your argument here. Regardless of your ideological concerns about the ideal way to tax stuff, this policy clearly hurts people who are already in a precarious financial position. It will have remarkably negative effects for students like me. I will simply have to drop out, and all of the domestic PhD students I know in STEM will as well. We can't afford to take out loans for taxes...

This policy has a clear goal. It's impact is what matters. Simply demanding that the tax code be simplified is in this case ludicrous. You're really missing the forest for the trees here - this effectively kills all STEM PhDs in the United States. It's impact would be devastating.


The fact that a policy hurts particular individuals is not a reason not to do it. To argue otherwise is to argue non-seriously. To argue otherwise on your own behalf, doubly-so.

> I need to be a student for various tax purposes for both the University and myself.

That sounds rather...Rube Goldbergian, doesn't it? Why do you think that is? That the university has to charge you a fee, and then waive it? Could it be that they are avoiding some other law, or regulation that is there, and that actually that law is the one that ought to be changed? Does it make sense to simply layer bureaucratic workarounds on top of each other? I'd say no, but some people like spaghetti code, I guess.

> This policy has a clear goal. It's impact is what matters. Simply demanding that the tax code be simplified is in this case ludicrous. You're really missing the forest for the trees here - this effectively kills all STEM PhDs in the United States. It's impact would be devastating.

No it wouldn't. Literally the only thing that would happen is universities would either:

a) Change the absurd "we charge you tuition and then waive it" system.

or

b) Offset the cost delta via a stipend of some kind.

It would not kill STEM, or any other kind of PhD program in the US, and it definitely wouldn't simply be passed on to students. If it did anything, it'd shift the balance more in favor of STEM PhDs and away from other, less remunerative degrees. But I doubt it'd even have that effect at the margin.

And finally, any time the government gives a tax credit, they are funding something. Tax credits are identical to government checks. Understanding this is absolutely essential to thinking about politics. When you donate money to a charity and receive a tax deduction for doing so, the federal government is effectively matching some 30% of your contribution. The reason the government chooses to fund things in this way is that it is more palatable to people. Just as you are doing now, they don't see 'tax credits' as an expenditure. But the truth is that taking money out of revenue collection is the exact same thing as writing a check. And this confusion among the general republic is a prime contributor to government waste and economic inefficiency generally.

EDIT: I should add, to be clear, that I don't think you or any PhD student should actually bear the burden of this tax. I'm saying that the tax policy being the way that it is is a bureaucratic workaround for a problem that is better solved another way, and it ought to be solved in that way, rather than addressed through tax policy.


> But the truth is that taking money out of revenue collection is the exact same thing as writing a check.

Pot, meet kettle. If this is the case, and if it's true that there's lots of "Rube Golderbian" infrastructure at play, why not implemented this policy -- in the short term with a long-term phase out -- as a direct budget cut to the NSF? As opposed to a 20% tax hike on people making 30k? The end effect on the national budget would be the same, without introducing lots a huge budgetary refactoring project.

> a) Change the absurd "we charge you tuition and then waive it" system.

But as a software person (?), you must understand that "ok make this big change to this complex system" isn't always a reasonable request given a 1 year timeframe.

In particular, I'm going to go out on a limb and conjecture that your edit is probably the only thing people actually care about. Everything else is missing the forest for the trees.


> Pot, meet kettle. If this is the case, and if it's true that there's lots of "Rube Golderbian" infrastructure at play, why not implemented this policy -- in the short term with a long-term phase out -- as a direct budget cut to the NSF? As opposed to a 20% tax hike on people making 30k? The end effect on the national budget would be the same, without introducing lots a huge budgetary refactoring project.

Because I don't think we should increase taxes on people making 30k 20%. I think we should eliminate cruft from the tax code. This is cruft.

> But as a software person (?), you must understand that "ok make this big change to this complex system" isn't always a reasonable request given a 1 year timeframe. > In particular, I'm going to go out on a limb and conjecture that your edit is probably the only thing people actually care about. Everything else is missing the forest for the trees.

Sure, it's certainly possible that making the change immediately is the wrong move. I'm not sure I see the evidence for that in this particular case, but yes, sometimes that is so.

When thinking about tax policy, it's important to consider now how something makes you feel, and not the first-order consequences of the change, but the equilibrium consequences of the change. If you eliminate this loophole would grad students actually pay more? I very much doubt it. The university would find a way to equalize the price, either by modifying the silly tuition policy (a simple fix is make tuition $1 and then waive that), paying it for you, or by some other means.

My guess is that the change will also have no net effect on revenue collection, which makes it fairly worthless from the perspective of its authors, who are trying to justify tax cuts in other areas. But I still think it's a good idea, because anything that eliminates cruft from the tax code is a good idea, provided it doesn't cause undue harm elsewhere, which I think it is highly unlikely to in this case.


No, not even close. We're taking about mid four figures decrease in take home pay for people making 30k. It's a double digit tax hike on grad students.


As far as I can tell, parent's use of "effective tax rate" is correct (the tuition waiver is not income in any meaningful sense -- especially for phd students who aren't even taking courses). So I'm not really sure what your point is?


Assuming his numbers were accurate, that tax rate is on each additional dollar of income, not on the total.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: