Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more throwawayjava's commentslogin

> adjusted for living expenses

I've done the math on this and I've never been able to figure a way that $100k in <generic midwestern city> gets me to retirement quicker than $200k in Seattle or even SF.

I just don't buy it.

As far as I'm concerned, it's a bullshit excuse midwestern companies use to under-pay their engineers.


At the same living arrangement? And the marginal tax rate is higher. I would say it works out dollar-to-dollar. What you have to include is weather, cultural opportunities, etc.


> At the same living arrangement?

No, but you answer the question of what that's still a fair comparison yourself:

> What you have to include is weather, cultural opportunities, etc.

Turns out that a small apartment feels a lot less like a jail when the weather's bearable almost the entire year and there's world-class hiking 30 minutes away.

> And the marginal tax rate is higher.

1. Which I include. In the worst case, this merely wipes out the delta between the real bonuses you get on the coast and the (conspicuously tiny) bonuses you get in the mid-west. The difference in tax is gone before you even start comparing salaries!

2. And that's not even fair to the coasts, because higher taxes do, in fact, buy some differences in quality of life.


But only if you're willing to take the "Jr." title and earn a measly $50k a year. Or in some cases less.

Which is the general problem with the midwest tech scene.

"Woe are we, we can't attract talent". Well, when Google's annual bonus is larger than your entire compensation offer... yeah, no shit.


While your under 30 take the money if you can get it. After that when "your not a cultural fit for the company" anymore. They're plenty of jobs in the midwest. And you can buy 4 bedroom house 250-350k and be at work in 30 minutes.


Or get to management level


Senior Full Stack Developer - Rails - Angular - Django Stafford Technology - Cleveland, OH $100,000 - $125,000 a year


While there are certainly jobs in Ohio paying more than $100k/year they tend to be clustered among only half a dozen companies. That leaves very little mobility for people. This also doesn't address the fact that salary is only a portion of total compensation.


Anecdata, but I'm at a startup and making $100k+ in Indianapolis.


Hm. I grew up in the midwest and I have the exact opposite opinion.

Where did you grow up? I wonder if this is that thing where we see the ugly under-belly of our homes with a clear eye, but see new places with rose-tinted glasses.


Same. There's a facade of niceness in the Midwest that doesn't go very deep. In a lot of more-rural areas, newcomers are viewed as outsiders and kept at arms-length for years at a minimum. This is not to say mid-westerners are unusually angry creatures, they're just not as benevolent as the stereotype implies. Southern hospitality is an even more extreme version in my experience.


Totally agree. Just because someone acknowledges you, doesn't mean anything.

The phrase that gets to my nerves is "bless his/her heart", which I translate to "I <insert long string of expletives> you, but I'm going to pretend to be nice because I have to keep up this stupid facade that society has created"


East Coast, actually; and people are pretty insular over there too, in the Northern parts.

There are assholes everywhere, but in the Midwest at least you could tell the difference fairly quickly; people sort of wore their hearts on their sleeves, I guess.


It might help if mid-western companies paid equivalent salaries as on the coasts.

There seems to be this attitude in the Midwest that lower CoL justifies lower salaries, as if there's no need to compensate for lower QoL with money.

Given equal salary, hordes of people will choose Midwestern winters over SF rent. But this attitude of "I don't have to pay you as much because land is dirt cheap, never mind that it's on a flat prairie in -20F weather" needs to be reversed. Especially since most of that land isn't ever appreciating, so I'm just paying rent to the bank instead of to a landlord anyways.

Midwestern companies: don't do CoL adjustments if you aren't also willing to do QoL adjustments.


> There seems to be this attitude in the Midwest that lower CoL justifies lower salaries, as if there's no need to compensate for lower QoL with money.

As a local Midwesterner, they don't do this because many people here don't want to think their QoL is lower and some will even feign offense that you implied their QoL is any lower than anywhere else.

Ironically, this bites them in the ass in wages.

Companies don't pay people fairly out here because they don't have to. Most of the locals have convinced themselves that their QoL isn't any lower. Their own employees proudly display their own below-market wages as evidence of why their home is a great place to live, they are essentially negotiating their own wages downward. It's a pure win-win for most companies, why would they want to disrupt that process?


I explain it to people this way when they ask why I left the Midwest: the Midwest is the Walmart of America. It's large, cheap, and the quality of most aspects of life is relatively low (weather, food, social life, career growth, etc.). But if it's all you can afford, it's a better place to be than somewhere expensive.


You guys are doing all this theorizing, but I live in the Midwest because that is where my family is. That's part of QoL.


I address some of your specific concerns below, but here's a tip: be loud and be involved. At a lot of districts, especially in Texas, sports facilities receive a ton of resources because the sports-obsessed parents are loud and make it clear that they vote.

But this requires civic-mindedness. You have to care a decade before your kid is in school, and continue caring a decade after, if anything's going to change. That's why sports get so many resources at some districts -- the sports -obsessed parents stay involved long before and long after their kids are out of school.

I'm not sure what to say except "welcome to democracy". (e: you might expect things would be better if education were privatized, but in reality the private schools seem even more obsessed with sports, and have their own high school version of the university amenities wars. So I'm skeptical that market mechanisms wouldn't end up behaving similarly to democratic mechanisms.)

> They spent over 2 million dollars on my sons high school this summer to replace the grass on the football field with artificial turf.

Artificial turf can be cheaper in the long run for primary use athletic fields, which get a lot of abuse and therefore require a lot of ongoing maintenance. You're trading a ~30+ year amortized cost for a single fixed cost, so the number can get pretty high while still working out in the black.

$2 million is high for a single field, though. Did it include e.g. upgrades to the stadium seating?

And I don't see why a middle school would need turf.

I tend to think the sports component of American high schools is stupid. But if it's going to exist, turf can be a cost-efficient choice. WRT the other stuff, again, see "get involved" and "be loud".

> The ignorant fools in my district just passed a Bond Election for like 300 million dollars for God only knows what

This is generally public information. 300 million sounds like district-wide significant building upgrades. These things usually mix "invisible but important" stuff (routers, HVAC upgrades, etc.) with "visible, high impact" stuff. I'd be surprised if those science and computer labs aren't included?

> It now almost costs the same amount to send one kid to High School as it does to send the other kid to UoT (Dallas).

Frankly, if you step back for a second, you'd expect K12 education to be more expensive than college. In one case you're lecturing to huge rooms of adults, in the other you're teaching small classes. But that's a whole different conversation...


This is the most odd post I've read in quite a while.

I was going to reply defending the subject of the article -- a middle-class person with hobbies and a home who fell on some temporary bad luck and was pounded into the ground by an objectively bad confluence of policies. But then I realized you think blue and red pigments are symbols of extravagance, and even in 1905 I'd be pretty lost on how to reply to that...?


No, I don't. I wonder why one person is made to look like she's living an extravagant lifestyle, and the other just this side of privation. I'm not a professional photographer, just an amateur - and if I did that, I wouldn't have done it by accident. I see no reason to imagine a professional would do it by accident, either. You don't take just one photo and call it good, after all. You take a lot of them, and then you sort through them to choose the ones you publish. The question I'm asking is: why choose these?

I think I'm seeing a deliberate attempt to manipulate the reader's sympathies, is what I'm saying. I don't understand what purpose that would serve, but I think it must have been done to serve some purpose, and so I wonder what purpose that was.


I see.

I think you're reading too much into it.


That's not at all what your link says.

The link is talking about formal vs play-based learning, which is a methodological question that, in the case of reading skills, is mostly orthogonal to what's being learned.


The link mentions learning through play, not "deliberate" play-based learning as I read it. Play is available at any daycare, at home, with grandparents etc.

The assertion was kindergarten was valuable because it taught reading. I was pointing out that if reading was premature, then kindergarten had no educational value.


No, the link never claims that "[learning to read] was pre-mature". In the developmental literature, "play" is a collection of pedagogical approaches and is not synonymous with what we'd call play time at a typical child care.

You fundamentally misunderstand the article. The article isn't advocating not teaching reading. It's advocating a play-based pedagogy for teaching reading.

> Play is available at any daycare, at home, with grandparents etc.

While this is true, that's not the "play" that the article is referring to. Not all "play" has equal educational value; playing pong all day is different from constructing silly stories based on books with Grandma during reading time.

So while this is in principle true, the reality is that educational play is a lot less accessible than your characterization implies.

"An extended period of high quality, play-based pre-school education was of particular advantage to children from disadvantaged households" doesn't describe the typical daycare.

Again, the approach is not "no education". The approach is "play-based pre-school education"

> then kindergarten had no educational value.

Similarly, the article never claims that pre-school/Kindergarten has negative educational value. It claims that formal educational settings focused on instruction sometimes have negative educational value. (Which, BTW, can be found in the involved parent's home as easily as in the typical public classroom.)

The idea that this study implies we should just have kids play "kick the can" all day until first grade is a serious and dangerous mis-reading.

Kids should be learning to read during the Kindergarten age, and prior. This study does not refute that assertion. Rather, it makes a point about which pedagogical approaches are most effective at achieving that goal. Those approaches -- both good and bad -- could be implemented in a day care, but a grandparent, or in a Kindergarten classroom.


The first (couple of) year(s) children enter formal education is primarily an assessment period to determine where they're at developmentally, behaviorally, and educationally.

In theory the sooner that happens the better.


Because owners are never allowed to become employees?


Good point. Owners can become employees, but there are much more benefits to being an owner that employees never really have access to, so unless the owner doesnt have the skill or capital, I don't see why an owner would want to be an employee. Sometimes employees can't even fathom making 1MM+ on a business deal because employees think in terms of their salaries.

Owners become employees when they accept too much outside investment. They become employees of investors...and investors buy ownership.

I think the balance of power is primarily affected by two things: 1) Barrier of entry into starting a business, such as laws that inhibit/regulate small businesses, or independent workers (owners) 2) Regulation that gives bigger businesses an inherent advantage over smaller businesses, such as limited liability, indemnification, bnakruptcy, mandated group health insurance plans, etc.

Sure, an owner can make 1MM per year and only pay the employee 100K.

But I think the question we really need to understand is, what's stopping the employee from quitting and starting his own company? I don't know the answer.


You are living in a bubble if you think that the balance of power between employers and employees is mostly determined by how easy it is to start a business.


Well, I think both sides of this conversation talk past each other a bit.

What you're saying is true.

But it's also the case that some those homogenous, snow white communities worry about jihad, even though there aren't any Muslims within a hundred mile radius of their house.

And it's especially true that when these small, homogenous communities diversify -- due to refugee placement or just economic growth and sprawl -- the latent racism becomes not-so-latent.


And the point that was originally being made was that it wasn't racism so much as just normal xenophobia, a sense of somebody from an external culture popping in. See also city-slickers, carpetbaggers, etc.


Yeah, translations need to take into account changes in writing style over the centuries in addition to changes in language.

Here's the joke in "modern English":

Instead of joining the state's church, I propose instead the following. I will buy a flag, a uniform, a gun, and one of those battery-powered toy jeeps that little kids drive around their yards. Then, with grave seriousness, I will declare my faith in God's protection, furl out my flag, and call for the members of the state's church to follow me into battle. I will then hop in my toy jeep and begin driving toward the battle field.


Maybe I'm slow, but I still don't get it. Is he saying that members of the state's church will follow him blindly (making them out to be dumb / sheeple)? Or is he saying that even such a ridiculous sight is less ridiculous than the church? Maybe he's satirizing the state's enthusiasm for war? I feel like I'm missing context here. Or maybe this is why people say his humor is weird...


It's funny to think of a grown man on a little toy jeep/horse all dressed up for war and taking seriously his trip to the front line and into the battlefield. That's the "funny" part of the joke. And it's not weird funny, it's just normal funny.

The deeper point being made isn't possible to ascertain from just this snippet; you'd have to put the joke back into its context and find the larger point being made in the text around the joke. (edit: but, see racer-v's explanation)


I see, thank you, so he's making fun of how silly swearing fidelity is and taking it seriously is.


Yes; there's a certain unwholesome smugness in a person who conflates civic duty (e.g. fighting for his country) with religious purpose, which Kierkegaard mocks here.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: