Because that's the way the law is written. The law was written that way because at one point, we, as a society, decided that we value accessible education and thought that this was a good way to provide that access.
The US actually does reasonably well in certain sectors -- many non-flagship state schools provide a decent undergraduate education at approximately the same cost as German universities.
The in-state tuition at Missouri State University is $7,306 (yearly!), which is actually cheaper than the typical German education. Portland State is $9,030. I choose those because Missouri and Oregon subsidize less than other states, so tuition is closer to true spend, and I'm too lazy to calculate true spend.
Germany's excellent mid-range public transit and relatively dense population makes a big difference in terms of total cost (including room and board), since many more Germans can live at home during university. But those things are more attributable to infrastructure and especially geography than cost disease.
(The case of elite private universities is pathological. Call it whatever you want, they're just charging what they know they're worth. But they're also extremely atypical -- the US has A LOT of universities, and they have different sets of problems. Central Western Flyover State University does not suffer from the same problems as the Ivy League)
"the average cost of an undergraduate degree in Germany is $32,000, PAID FOR BY THE STATE" [1] (emphasis mine)
7306 x 4 = $29,224 < $32,000.
Math!
Notice I put some caveats in my original post -- US states do spend some money per pupil in high ed, but those numbers are relatively small and rapidly shrinking. Tracking state cash to specific schools is pretty hard, I wasn't able to do it, so instead I just chose states known for relatively low per pupil higher ed spending.
It is possible that the schools I mentioned are more expensive than universities in Germany. But not by much.
Also. Parent claimed that education in the US is expensive in absolute terms, insinuating waste. No one is disputing that students in the US have to pay a lot for their education. But I am disputing the common myth that all colleges in the US are absurdly expensive -- in absolute terms -- compared to universities in other countries.
$7k per student per year is definitely not outrageous cost -- when adjusted by purchasing power parity, it seems on par with the costs of European schools.
What is outrageous though is that unlike in most of the Europe, students actually have to pay for it themselves. There are around 20 million university students in the US. If every school charged less than $10k tuition per year (which is totally doable in principle, which can be seen by comparing European schools cost), it would require $200B to cover that. US government is already providing $80B to support students pursuing higher education, and remaining $120B is only 20% of military budget.
If you take a typical course load (5 courses per semester, each of which meets for 3 hrs/week for 15 weeks), that works out to about $15.55 per hour of actual class time. This isn't including ancillary benefits like access to experts in a variety of fields (e.g., through office hours), access to the library, and student activities.
> In reality, they should "award" grad students $0 in tuition and pay them like what they are - employees (and deeply exploited employees at that!).
Here's the rub.
If universities do this, then the current tax bill is basically a cut to federal funding for science and undergraduate education.
If universities do not do this, then the current tax bill places even more of the social cost of science onto graduate students.
IMO the way out of the quagmire is two-fold.
(1) Place a strict limit of 20% on overhead -- the sum of all expenses that aren't either researcher/educator salary or research/teaching equipment should not exceed 20% within certain revenue streams. This should be required for revenues from undergraduate tuition, non-taxed endowment earnings that aren't reinvested into the endowment, and revenues from research grants.
(Why not $0? Because some amount of administration is necessary, and buildings need to be cleaned/maintained/secured. "Overhead" can mean waste, but it can also mean "literally keeping the lights on". 20% is negotiable, and perhaps this is something that varies from campus to campus, but "a lowish non-zero number" seems right.)
(2) Only after doing (1), increase funding for science and public higher education.
>If universities do this, then the current tax bill is basically a cut to federal funding for science and undergraduate education.
It isn't, though. If there is 100 million allocated by the federal government for science and undergraduate education, that number gets spent whether or not universities charge tuition. It just gets distributed differently, it isn't cut.
The universities aren't being taxed on their Federal grants, are they? I thought this whole thing was about how Graduate students were reimbursed - if that's the case, there are solutions that don't involve a 40% tax rate, which nobody would pay anyway.
Plus, if they simply paid the graduate students more, then sure - the students would pay income tax, but again, not 40%, and the student would have more choice about how to use their income. I don't have a huge amount of sympathy for a system that is built off of bleeding funding from grants to support other university programs. Sure, more might go back to the government in the form of a tax, but that's more reasonable to me than the university taxing the government for the privilege of paying them to do research.
> Sure, more might go back to the government in the form of a tax
Right, so we agree that this effectively reduces the amount of money the USFG spends on research; 5-2 < 5-0.
> but that's more reasonable to me than the university taxing the government for the privilege of paying them to do research.
We can debate about the extent to which the federal government should support education and research, but let's stop bullshitting for one damn second. Removing tax incentives for government-funded research is exactly equivalent to reducing NSF/NIH funding. This is literally a basic arithmetic fact.
>Right, so we agree that this effectively reduces the amount of money the USFG spends on research; 5-2 < 5-0.
No, we don't. If the funding actually went to research, maybe, but it doesn't, and even then it's pretty convoluted. In any other program, if I get a grant from the government and use it to pay staff, they pay income tax on what I pay them, even though the money comes from a grant. That doesn't really mean the government spends less to fund grant programs.
>Removing tax incentives for government-funded research is exactly equivalent to reducing NSF/NIH funding.
No, it isn't. It's related, but not exactly equivalent. The money still goes to fund NSF/NIH projects, even if there is tax on that income the people were paid to do the research.
Not to mention, these languages actually work for many, many domains. A shit-load of C# could just as well be F#. In fact, lots and lots of people do use F#/Scala/OCaml/etc. to build real systems.
Just because something isn't "the most popular" doesn't mean that thing doesn't work.
Yes, when the working conditions in other countries are worse to the point of cruelty. The justification is not nationalism, but rather directing consumption toward production that is labor-friendly. So not so much "Made in the USA" as much as "made by workers who feel good about their current situation".
But then one could ask whether certain parts of Europe enjoy the same moral prerogative wrt the US?
How does that help them? Pretty sure those working under "cruel" conditions would rather keep their jobs.
Also, European regulations are the strictest and labor unions the loudest in the world, so it's unlikely any meaningful quantity of goods produced under cruel conditions make their way into the European market. At least we believe that.
The new global standard for the conditions a factory worker may expect is that they'll work 12 hour days, live in a barracks, get paid every three months and suffer routine exposure to dangerous amounts of Benzene---to say nothing of the wages. And if you can't or won't work under these conditions then you're non-employable.
So American worker gets thrown out because he's suddenly insufficiently downtrodden to be a competitive worker in his former line of work.
And maybe the Benzene is worth it to the average Chinese worker. I can't speak for him. But I can say that if it's not, he'll lose his job like the American did and they'll find someone even cheaper somewhere else.
PS: I guarantee you that there are no separate factories in China for export into the EU where workers receive EU-level protections. Don't be daft. The European markets are full of goods produced in horrible conditions.
The assertion that all such labor is a voluntary choice on the part of laborers is... depressingly naive, to say the least.
And even in cases where it's true, ignores the fact that many may have preferred not to have had the choice imposed in the first place. E.g. subsistence farmers forced off their land and into cities, either by mandate or through unchecked externalities (aka the polluting plant next door). And purchasing from these manufacturing operations helps spread that misery.
I'm not saying it's an easy calculus, but your characterization is surely reductive.
> [...] ignores the fact that many may have preferred not to have had the choice imposed in the first place. E.g. subsistence farmers forced off their land and into cities, either by mandate or through unchecked externalities.
Look at Oklahoma if you want to see the US version of a petro state. If we're going to do the petro state thing anyways, might was well run an interesting social experiment instead of just enriching a few huge corporations while shuttering our schools.
This idea is basically UBI couched in capitalist terms. If every American gets a share of GDP, and GDP is concentrated, then that means that either 1) the share of GDP that each person gets is tiny and inconsequential (see: GOP-style tax cuts) or else 2) you need progressive taxation.
Another difference, aside from wording/marketing, is that the UBI is implemented as a progressive redistribution of future wealth generation as opposed to a tax on existing wealth ("as the economy grows...")
> This idea is basically UBI couched in capitalist terms
"Universal Basic Income" is already a radically capitalist idea. It's often discussed using terminology borrowed from Marxism and socialism, but it couldn't be any more capitalist of a construct. We're just not used to hearing it discussed with that language.
Could you clarify what you mean? a UBI seems like pretty straight forward wealth re-distribution which I generally don't see described in most capitalist philosophies.
Everyone gets $10k. Obviously not everyone is going to pay $10k in taxes otherwise the system would be pointless and we could instead just eliminate taxes altogether. Those at the bottom would benefit, those at the top would pay more in taxes, and somewhere between is a break even point.
Each act of homesteading is an act of force against everyone else, who previously enjoyed free access to that land/resource. A UBI is a payment for the lost access.
While I don't disagree with this, I don't think that Georgism can justify a large enough payment to have the effects that people expect of UBI. The value of land (meaning all natural resources in their natural state) is ultimately pretty low compared to all the other value in the world. Per wikipedia, all US land is worth less than two times GDP.
It’s fundamentally Capitalist because its intent is to prevent workers from abandoning the authoritarian hierarchy of modern day corporate structures (which have served many quite poorly) and moving towards worker ownership through unions or other means. It’s paying off the poor and disenfranchised to prevent revolt against Capitalist ordering principles.
There's only a limited amount of stuff at any one time. Rarity and usage can make its worth different than other things. So it makes sense to track these things. Ideally, recycling allows recoup of most or all the material, which returning should provide the credits back.
It really then matters how much credits people get and thus how much resources and where. But then again, socialism and communism never talked about personal effects - but instead it talked of the machinery to create.
What the UBI enables is a migration that everyone gets the spoils of the machines of creation. The Story of Manna by Marshall Brain discusses more of how this might be possible.
This would address one (but not all) of my fundamental complaints about UBI though: What do you do when due to some disaster, you must pull back your UBI payments? Consider significant war losses, for instance. In this case the answer is that GDP would go down and so would the payment. (Though maybe we can't tie it to GDP per se, since in a war situation you can't afford to see your GDP rise due to forced construction and then also have to pay your populace more.)
That said, it addresses it structurally, but I still think the result would still be a disastrous political explosion if that ever did happen. UBI seems to be fundamentally predicated on the idea that growth and improvement are inevitable, the only possible way that things will develop going into the future, including any structural or societal changes that may develop as a result of UBI or GDP-sharing itself, and therefore there's no need to ask who starts swinging from trees the first time that UBI or GDP-sharing has to be cut back, and what disastrous decisions will be made on the basis of not wanting to be the one swinging from trees.
If the situation lasts long enough, the standard of living falls.
Money exists to move goods around. If all the money is in one place, goods cannot move.
Money is not limited. It is an information measure of, variously, debts, or bidding rights to production. What it can bid on is limited, and how currency-denominated asset valuations change as money supply and circulation do, can also change.
But the problem in the case of a national disaster isn't that money cannot be produced. It's that those who would rely on money to address immediate needs (water, food, shelter, medical care, transport) have no bidding rights (currency, credit, grants) to transact purchases. You're balancing the interests of those outside the disaster zone (assuming there is an outside) with those in it. (Though this generally is the case.)
If the disaster is big enough, and rescue or infrastructure needs sufficiently high, those may affect national accounts and economic activity for a time, but it would take an absolutely massive shock for the impairment of raw productive capacity alone to impact the economy. Far more likely that buying power is lacking amongst a segment of the population.
That's not even remotely a sensible argument, since we didn't have UBI then.
You are either not arguing in anything remotely resembling good faith or are not tall enough for this ride. You may have the reply to this unopposed; I'm done here.
UBI is usually proposed as a replacement for welfare, so you’d have one or the other. The potential for running out of money one day did not prevent us from having welfare so it shouldn’t exclude the possibility of UBI.
The ad hominem shot is surprising, given the straightforwardness of my position. I don’t understand why you are cross. Ah well.
well like many other attempts to inject more government control into our lives; usually to "get back" at someone who is "unfairly benefiting/abusing/etc/etc"; those with the proposal wrap it up in a grand egalitarian wording and market only the promises that sound good but are too good to be true. to sell it they sneak in seemingly related facts that are not debatable.
the one common response they all have when their plans are revealed for what they are and comparisons made to what others have done is always the same , we will do it right this time.
it is easy to prey on the greed of anyone by simply remaking it into the person having their stuff taken as being the real greedy one.
Germany was rebuilt from that, first through a brutal dictatorship and then, after that, with enormous assistance from the largest and strongest economies in the world, powered by a demographic boom in the richest parts of the world.
And no matter how much progress has been made between 1950 and 2017, there's so little comfort in drawing a parallel between our present situation and the trajectory Germany from 1910 to 1945.
If you compare Clojure and PHP, it doesn't mean that you think Clojure is like PHP. Germany is just a reference, many countries have rebuilt themselves after disasters.