> which basically means that the actions of the private sector can be coerced to give a "right to receive."
No, that does not follow from the article's analysis.
What does follow is that, if the forum the gov't is using does not protect this right to receive, then the gov't can be forced to use a different forum.
Which is how it should be. Malls shouldn't be allowed to shut down public debate on local tax policy just because the city council chooses to hold their public meetings in the food court.
Of course, the mall is free to perform that censorship. But then the council needs to find a different place to meet.
> By this logic, cable providers and ISPs can't charge you money to see government communications because now these forms of communication are a guaranteed right
Those "volumes of case law" already deal with this question in a multitude of ways.
> No, that does not follow from the article's analysis.
Because the article is very clearly biased. Making it a legal requirement for tweets to be treated as though they are protected speech means that Twitter cannot shut people up (or else they have broken it as a platform for free speech).
> But then the council needs to find a different place to meet.
The difference here is that in the mall scenario, it is the mall that is shutting people up. In your argument, it's the government. As a better example, I would say you have a private establishment like a hotel where the meeting is happening. You have a conference room reserved and the public is welcome to come in to observe. If it is illegal for the council to eject a Nazi from the hotel for their views, then surely it is illegal for the hotel to do the same (otherwise, the hotel could say that Republicans are not allowed). In this case, the meeting would either have to be moved or the hotel would have to change their policy. So in this way, the hotel is threatened with the loss of business if they do not adhere to the policy of allowing all speech. The issue here, is that the EFF is asserting that if the President chooses to talk to someone in the hotel lobby (somewhere that anyone can listen, but not somewhere that is meant to be official government communications), then that has suddenly become protected.
> Making it a legal requirement for tweets to be treated as though they are protected speech means that Twitter cannot shut people up
This claim is prime facie absurd, since the lawsuit doesn't mention Twitter as a defendant, it's unthinkable to imagine that the result of THIS lawsuit would be an injunction against Twitter.
So unless you have a very compelling legal argument...
> The difference here is that in the mall scenario, it is the mall that is shutting people up. In your argument, it's the government
Right, exactly! In the case at hand, my point is even stronger. It's not just the mall security kicking people out, it's the city council asking the mall security to kick people out for expressing certain opinions. That's an even more obvious restriction on speech...
> If it is illegal for the council to eject a Nazi from the hotel for their views, then surely it is illegal for the hotel to do the same (otherwise, the hotel could say that Republicans are not allowed).
Wrong. It IS legal for the hotel to do the same! But it might not be legal for the city council to host their meeting in that hotel.
> In this case, the meeting would either have to be moved or the hotel would have to change their policy.
Yes.
> So in this way, the hotel is threatened with the loss of business if they do not adhere to the policy of allowing all speech.
And? Does the hotel have some sort of divine right to derive revenue from hosting city council meetings...? What if two different hotels want to make two different restrictions on speech?
More to the point, this provides a patently obvious and absolutely unacceptable back-door for censoring public meetings -- city councils can just insist on leases that restrict criticism of policy xyz or persons abc.
> only makes sense if twitter is neutral. Conservatives and Ajit Pai think twitter is not a neutral edge service.
Actually, this makes the analogy an exceptionally good one!
Malls and mall owners are about as far from politically neutral as you can get, especially at the local level. I've never seen a major mall be build/renovated without some squabbling about local/regional tax policy.
Politicians can't censor speech based on political content during open Q&A periods at city council meetings. And that doesn't change just because they choose to hold those meetings in the mall parking lot.
From the article: When elected officials choose to give speeches in a park, hold town hall meetings in a school stadium, stand on a street corner giving safety instructions to flood victims, or debate each other on Twitter, the public’s First Amendment rights to receive those messages are triggered.
> If the eff is correct, this will open the pandoras box of lawsuits from conservatives.
Both sides of the isle utilize the courts to protect their first amendment rights. This has always been true and will always be true.
> Significant advances shipped by the tech industry in the last 20 years include putting the majority of human knowledge in the hands of 40%++ of the world's population, available on-demand, for "coffee money" not "university money."
Oh, I didn't realize tech invented the library card.
As cool as libraries are, and they are cool, if you value your time at even minimum wage rates, they are not "coffee money". That's why you... yes, you, even you... whip out your phone to answer questions that you would never dream of running to the library to answer on the spot. This is a real effect, not an illusion. Friction matters, a lot.
Again, all these things people are saying are indeed true, but they also make the university comparison in the original quote something of a red herring.
I'm not sure you, or any other of the other commenters in this thread, quite understand what was meant by "university money". "University money" is what it costs to buy scientific journals; in theory anybody can do it, in practice only Universities have both the need and the funding to do it. It isn't that your phone is a university... it is that it has all this information accessible for so dirt cheap that African farmers can get at it, modulo the language barrier.
Libraries are not run with "Access to Information" as their main goal. They're run with service to patrons as their main goal. If you think I'm making a distinction without a difference, how many libraries have subscriptions to Playboy?
Universities can study porn under the heading of the humanities or social science. The fact they don't have an explicit "Department of Pornography" is both an accident of our culture and a reflection of the fact our "top-level categories" for academics are more abstract than that.
My point is, libraries maintain a very curated collection, and choose their holdings and resources based on very restrictive criteria, including funding and shelf space, making them relatively poor at keeping broad and deep holdings. Until you give the library an Internet connection, which brings us back to the origin of this sub-thread.
It would be interesting to determine how many people in the world have access to a library, how many people have internet access, and how much overlap there is between the two groups.
For far more employers, "ability to program" is something they have no idea how to filter for in a pile of resumes, but "CS degree" seems like it might be a usable proxy.
>Because for many employers "ability to program" is a minimum requirement, not the full job description
I think this was the author's point. You state it is a minimum requirement, implying a CS degree is a more challenging requirement. Yet it's not hard to find people with CS degrees who do not have the minimum requirement.
It's a big world out there; this has been an active area of research basically since Turing. Many of the "relationship between" questions you ask have their own conference or workshop series.
> formal provability
IMO the best way to start down this road is to just begin using some of the tools out there -- TLA+, Coq, whatever - and touch base with the community around your choice of tool (conferences, workshops, or even going back to school for a phd). The best way to learn about the strengths and limitations of current software practice is to sit down and churn out code, preferably with a strong mentor. The same is true for proof programming.
> ...universities preparing people for academia...
I don't think there are many university programs explicitly designed to prepare people for academia. Where it happens, it's mostly just a case of people teaching what they know.
> So therefore it makes sense that universities prepare people for a job at a company.
This, of course, ignores the possibility that "learn[ing] the scientific basis of a subject" is not useful in an industrial career.
> things that enable those currently in power to remain in power they do well
1. It's unclear to me how most of our military hardware is in any way even closely related to "enabling those currently in power to remain in power", perhaps aside from functioning as PC jobs programs. Super impressive engineering, but it's not really clear to me why most of it is particularly necessary.
2. Then I guess maybe we should vote for people who run effective services.
> Things that help the average citizen, most definitely not.
My local government has a system that allows you to reserve park space. I can also look up hours for rec centers on the city website. Those things are helpful to me, the average citizen, and definitely work well.
> its a weird wealth transfer especially with undergrads
You could say the same thing about coupons, or any other mechanism for differential pricing.
Also, most true scholarship money is not a differential pricing mechanism. Beyond a fixed discount rate offered to basically everyone (this is just the Kohl's "everything is always 60% off for everyone!" thing), most universities use (often endowed) scholarship and grants to maximize the quality of their undergraduate population, not for differential pricing.
Giving Student 4.0 with $0 in the bank a full scholarship and giving Student 2.5 with $300,000 in the bank $0 in scholarship is not wealth redistribution. It's merit-based aid. And that describes how a vast majority of scholarships work.
No, that does not follow from the article's analysis.
What does follow is that, if the forum the gov't is using does not protect this right to receive, then the gov't can be forced to use a different forum.
Which is how it should be. Malls shouldn't be allowed to shut down public debate on local tax policy just because the city council chooses to hold their public meetings in the food court.
Of course, the mall is free to perform that censorship. But then the council needs to find a different place to meet.
> By this logic, cable providers and ISPs can't charge you money to see government communications because now these forms of communication are a guaranteed right
Those "volumes of case law" already deal with this question in a multitude of ways.