Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more throwawayjava's commentslogin

Yeah, but unlike Mother Jones, most political bloggers don't have millions of dollars to wage a multi-year war.

The general concern is that money provides one the ability to silence other people's speech.


I agree this is an issue, but just because some people can't afford to defend themselves doesn't make what Thiel did wrong. You'll note Gawker was fully able to fund their defense.

If Thiel had did this against a smaller site that gave up without having its day in court that would be a different matter.


untog ended their up-thread comment with a pre-emptive answer to exactly this sentiment:

>> Personally, I'm concerned that the individual factors of this case (i.e. Gawker being Gawker) will overshadow the principle at stake, which feels a lot more important than a gossip site.

Thiel isn't on trial in this thread, but our justice system perhaps is.


What principle are they defending?


Free speech. And, in particular, the chilling effect that's possible due to how our civil justice system is defined.


I assume you don't mean the free speech of Thiel to fund any lawsuit he wants to?


No, he's one of the few people whose free speech I'm not terribly concerned about. (Don't be confused: I think he should have the right to express his opinion, I just don't think that right is in any jeopardy).

I mean the free speech of anyone who doesn't have $N million needed to fend off a civil suit. If cases like this and the MJ one become common-place, there's a very real risk of chilling effect.

Incidentally, I think it's probably possible to allow Thiel the ability to sue Gawker into the ground without also having a system where genuinely legal free speech is reserved for people who can afford massive financial risk. So there's absolutely no reason for you to disagree with me just because you think Thiel in on the right side of the Gawker issue...


I think that's important as well, but both the Gawker and MJ cases are entirely irrelevant because they both were able to defend themselves.


By the same argument, patent trolls are NBD. Except, of course, we know for a fact that lots of people are extorted into paying BS fees because they can't afford to go to court.


If you tried to make the case that patent trolls are a big problem because they extort large fees from people, it would be appropriate to talk about cases where people settled and paid "BS fees". If you cite one case where the plaintiff won, and another where they lost in court, you aren't making that case very well because you haven't discussed any actual cases of the alleged harm.


Sorry, in one thread you're suggesting anti-SLAPP laws and in another (this thread) you're apparently claiming that SLAPP doesn't happen.

I'm confused.


I'm not claiming that at all - if you look above I said I acknowledge this is an issue. It's just not relevant to the cases in the OP comment.


Yes, and as I already pointed out, the root comment states:

>>>>>> Personally, I'm concerned that the individual factors of this case (i.e. Gawker being Gawker) will overshadow the principle at stake, which feels a lot more important than a gossip site.

We are discussing principles and problems that are larger than just these two cases. That's the entire thesis of the comment that started this thread.


It cited another case as representative of the real issue, which wasn't.


MJ was offered as an example of a suit that was filed despite the fact that the speech was clearly legally protected, and where the cost of the suit was rather outrageous despite this fact. It establishes a) that people sue maliciously even when they know their suit is baseless; and b) that these suits are none-the-less expensive to defend.

It's fairly obvious that (b) is concerning, and also fairly obvious that it takes an actual suit to put a price tag on this problem. That's why the MJ case was presented.

But all of this is obvious and explained in the comments above, so this is getting very pedantic, and I don't see a) what point you're trying to make, or b) how that point is at all relevant to the overall thesis of the root comment.


Ask yourself: would this argument make sense and remain consistent with AEI's overall ideological commitments if Democrats controlled Congress and the presidency?

If the answer is "no" -- and, seriously, the answer is most definitely "no" -- then your "AEI isn't partisan" claim goes out the window.


> Why is it hilarious?

Because the internet is a global network and China/Canada/etc. aren't under the auspices of the FCC.


If by "a century ago" you also mean "less than 2 years ago", then sure.


> If by "a century ago" you also mean "less than 2 years ago", then sure.

I probably shouldn't bother engaging with such a low-effort comment, but: no, there's plenty of precedent throughout the last 50-75 years for ideological conservatives leveraging and supporting this interpretation of the Commerce Clause.


> low-effort

Well, I'll happily admit that I'm not guilty of doing ornate argmentative gymnastics to justify my position... I consider that a feature, not a bug, though ;-)

AEI and other conservative think tanks were throwing fits about over-reaching interpretations of the commerce clause throughout Obama's entire presidency.

AEI's current position on the commerce clause is motivated by their partisan preferences.


> First, AEI is not a partisan think-tank. They're ideologically conservative, but they are non-partisan... If anything, the current interpretation of the Commerce Clause is the antithesis of conservative ideology

And yet, AEI is advocating for the current interpretation of the Commerce Clause because it empowers deregulation. You can bet your last horse that they'd be making the opposite argument and rambling about King George and unelected regulators if Democrats controlled the federal government.

I can't help but feel that you've reinforced awinder's point... AEI reasons backwards from what it wants on a case-by-case basis to justify its policy preferences, which change depending on which party is in power. If that's not the definition of partisan, then your definition of partisanship is broken.

> If anything, they're smart, by framing a Republican-sponsored policy within the context of case law that Democrats have consistently supported for a century.

1. Yes, exactly, their constitutional justification is an insincere post-facto justification for policy they like, and their policy preferences when it comes to the commerce clause largely depend on which political part is in control of the federal government.

2. But they're totally non-partisan, right? ;-)


Might makes right.


The article is a poorly argued response to a strawman.

The NYC and federal advisory councils would be tasked with providing lawmakers with impartial advice on A.I. writ large. That's reasonable. Bias in algorithmic credit decisions and bias in algorithmic sentencing are different problems, but share a lot of the same underlying technological realities/problems. These areas do have cross-cutting concerns, so a legislative brain trust dedicated to disseminating knowledge about these cross-cutting concerns is a wise use of resources.

No one is suggesting "regulating" general AI, so the author's red herring question about "what is AI anyways?" is completely off-topic. Even "alarmists" like Musk and Hawking are proposing much more concrete legislation, such as banning algorithmically generated kill orders in weapons. And to the extent that those people are interested in safe general AI, they're currently trying to achieve that goal by throwing research money at it (rather than proposing concrete legislation regulating general AI). Which is hardly a reasonable thing to criticize!

Furthermore, the proposed approaches in NYC and at the federal level aren't incongruent with the author's proposed sector-by-sector approach toward regulation! These are, after all, simply proposing advisory councils.

Therefore, the author does not provide a compelling reason to oppose any of the concrete legislation mentioned at the beginning of the article. And the arguments that the author does make betray, IMO, a superficial understanding of the proposed legislation.


Also, general economic growth due to underlying fundamentals in the demographics -- fundamentals that western societies don't enjoy today.


> However, people tend to move towards communities of their same 'status'

This makes no sense. A smart but poor kid does not have the option to move to a rich suburb with excellent schools.

> so if you have a really smart kid you aren't nearly as likely to find that kid still in the trailer park when they are 30 as one of their more average peers.

1. But, you're just as likely to encounter that extra bright kid smoking pot in a trailer home in 20 years. Poverty is a hell of a burden and barrier. Intelligence can help you stay out of poverty, but it's far less powerful when you want to get out of poverty. And can even function as a disadvantage.

2. Furthermore, lots of dumb but rich kids will go on to six figure incomes for the rest of their lives.

Intelligence isn't as strong a determinant as you claim, in either direction.


> Intelligence isn't as strong a determinant as you claim, in either direction.

Your claim is incorrect.

http://www.emilkirkegaard.dk/en/wp-content/uploads/Intellige...

EDIT: over the course of one generation, higher intelligence leads to a dramatically higher income. In the long run, if this effect continues, this will be compounded as higher intelligence parents are also higher income parents (by hypothesis).


From the abstract:

"The results demonstrate that intelligence is a powerful predictor of success but, on the whole, not an overwhelmingly better predictor than parental SES"

I.e., intelligence is about as likely to explain success (or lack thereof) as parental income. This is exactly what I was saying -- if you want to guess whether a 5 year old is going to succeed, take a look at their parents.

In short, I don't think this paper is the home-run for your case that you think it is. If what you're claiming is true, we'd expect intelligence to be radically better as a predictor than SES. But it isn't.

The paper also notes some important criticisms that cut that right to the core of your use of this paper in the context of the "nature vs nurture" debate.

Edit: the second component of your edit (" In the long run...") is absolutely NOT justified by the paper you cite, and is wild conjecture at best.


I didn't advocate neutering the poor, and I strongly disagree with your suggestion that we murder rich people and take their stuff.


Fair enough. I've stricken that sentence.


The linked IPPR report is worth reading. For this crowd, the section on "partial automation" is probably most important. Web dev is... up there... in terms of potential for partial automation.

There are a few important observations that the article and the IPPR report don't stress enough.

1. The jobs most likely to be automated, will be automated using technology that's inaccessible to the employees whose jobs are being destroyed.

This point is often optimistically papered over using observations like "coal miners can go to coding bootcamps!" I know a few truckers and I have no doubt that each of them could go through a relatively short coding academy for web development work if it became a "do or starve" situation. But I doubt that most of them could become much more specialized autonomous vehicle software engineers, either due to raw intellectual ability or -- more often -- due to an inability to make a substantial half-decade investment in retraining (most of these folks would need to (re-)learn a lot of high school algebra).

So just because we're replacing truck drivers with programmers, doesn't mean that the folks displaced by self-driving are somehow getting jobs that were created via the destruction of their prior employment opportunities.

2. "Partial Automation" could mean less hours worked, but is more likely to mean lower pay and more hours worked, and not all "partial automation" is equal. I.e., to destroy trucking as a middle-class profession, you don't need a self-driving truck. You just need to automate enough of the hard stuff so that anyone can learn to drive truck in a week.

I think it's useful to separate the partial automation that de-skills work (level 4 autonomy for trucks) from the partial automation that simply means less equally-skilled work (web dev). The former creates more job opportunities, but turns a middle-class job into a low-class job. The latter just eliminates from middle-class jobs altogether.


I agree that there won't always be new jobs for those that are lost. There is some hope that the truck drivers can become mechanics and robot repair persons even if they can't learn coding. There is also a hugely underfunded part of our society that a lot of jobs will have to become in the future (imo) around elder care. Basically, low skilled people whose job it is to help other people, likely paid for by the government.


But truck drivers are paid substantially more than the lowest educational rung in the nursing hierarchy.


You also have to consider jobs that will exist which don’t exist now. For example, driving for Uber wasn’t a thing until recently.


Driving a taxi was, since pre-1635.


Are you serious? Do you not see the difference between driving for uber and driving a taxi?

Let’s start with state-imposed bureaucracy and artificial limitation on supply.


Yes, and no. For definitions relevant to the comment I was replying to, none of your points make Uber a new type of labor.


My reply was about you equating uber and taxis.

It may not be a new “type” of labor in the sense that driving jobs already existed, but what kind of refutation is that?

Uber (and other similar companies) created new job opportunities, which is undeniable simply because a few years ago these companies didn’t exist.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: