Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more throwawayjava's commentslogin

> This is why I struggle with scenarios where people discuss pay and work without considering value.

Counter-point: firms exist.

If I'm the one figuring out how to create value, why the hell are the C suite, middle managers, and investors getting 99% of the profits?

So no, in the context of a large firm, it's definitely NOT an engineer's job to figure out how their skills align with market demand. And that's the whole damn point of a firm.

Now, this may be reasonable advice if I want to maximize by income. But maybe my goal is to maximize income under the constraint that "my excellent engineering" is the primary consideration in my performance evaluations. And there's nothing wrong with that; people trade income for all sorts of things. Telling someone not to make that trade-off is like chiding them for buying an expensive latte or sending their kids to an expensive private school. It's not your money, so it's none of your business.

edit: And, furthermore, the success of large firms and the high compensation available at those firms suggest that the author's advice might actually be actively harmful. As an engineer, you might actually be better off ignoring engineering-value alignment because you might be better off simply executing well within a well-oiled machine.


> getting 99% of the profits?

Profits by definition are calculated after labor costs are deducted, so employees get 0% of the profits in salary.

However, take a look at your company's accounts and see how much of the gross revenue is paid out as wages and salary. It'll be a big chunk. There's your share.


Sorry, but I think that this view is both obviously wrong and actively harmful. It's an example of where going with textbook definitions actually obfuscates reality.

Highly compensated managers are taking a share of profit, often quite literally (look at how VP and above positions are compensated). But always indirectly -- you can't tell me a 7-8 figure salary "isn't a share of profit". That's obvious BS. And if my own compensation is a share of profit in the same sense (which, a port of it literally is), then my observation that non-engineers get 99% of that share is still accurate.

Anyways, and much more importantly, this is pretty tangential to my original point. The point is that if I'm an engineer at a large firm, it is NOT my job to do the MBA thing. The entire premise of a firm is that the author of this post is wrong.


The money paid to employees is deducted from the profits (or more precisely, profits are what is left after expenses and labor costs are paid).

So your salary is your share of the profits in any pragmatic sense.

This isn't MBA level stuff, any basic accounting course will explain it. In fact, I recommend anyone who cares about this sort of thing to learn basic accounting principles - it is simple, and highly useful knowledge. You'll be able to then read a business's Income Statement and Balance Sheet, and see where the money comes from, where it goes, and where it is allocated.


> So your salary is your share of the profits in any pragmatic sense.

Okay, so I'm getting a tiny fraction compared to everyone else. Again, this is a fairly pedantic tangent and no matter how we define these things, my observation seems to be accurate.

Again, this sub-thread about the definition of profit is both tangential and unrelated to my original point. I think the standard accounting definition is pretty useless and silly in the context of modern large firms, but that seems like a discussion for another day.

> This isn't MBA level stuff

By MBA stuff I don't mean "useless econ 101 terms". What I mean is "aligning engineering talent with value creation", which AFAIK isn't taught is basic accounting courses...?

The author of the post suggested this alignment is an engineer's job. But the whole point of a firm is that the MBAs do that and the engineers focus on building things. That's my point -- that in the context of a large firm, the author is wrong.

Of course, joining a large firm means that your own compensation is disconnected from the value the firm creates. And that can mean less share of compensation, especially when the firm is doing well. But it also means you can make a good living without becoming a Monday morning economist.

I don't really care about defining profit "correctly" according to accounting terminologists because I think a well-meaning reader can completely understand the point that I'm making in my original comment without this aside.


> that in the context of a large firm, the author is wrong.

An accountant serves two roles in a company. One is to produce a correct set of books for the investors and the tax man. The other is to determine the value to the business of things the business is spending money on.

I.e. to determine the value produced by the engineers.

They may get it wrong, as at some level it is indeterminate, but the more correct they calculate it, the more efficiently and effectively the business can allocate its resources.

This calculated value determines, for example, what they're willing to offer you in salary. If they overvalue you, you're likely to get laid off, or more likely, no raises. If they undervalue you, they're likely to give you a raise to keep you from leaving.

In my experience, individual engineers tend to have a large disconnect in their opinions on what value they deliver vs reality. If you believe your compensation is way under your opinion of your contribution, it is worth taking a good hard look at it, and deciding if you are better off getting another job.


P.S. if it isn't obvious, companies who tend to be way off in determining the value of their engineers tend to go out of business.


> This calculated value determines, for example, what they're willing to offer you in salary.

It doesn't. This is mostly a binary thing of whether the company can afford to pay an employee a bit above his market value or not, if we are talking about engineers of course. Such employee cannot actually get paid proportionally to the value he brings to the company.


If they can't afford to pay your market value, you should leave and go work for a company that can. That's how you set your "market value" - go out on the market and see what price you get. If you can't get a higher offer, than your current salary is your market value.

How much value the engineer brings in (to a given employer) is basically the ceiling on bids that employer will make. It's completely economically rational for you to find the employer that values your work the most when you're searching for a job, because they'll be willing to pay the most.


I would add that job market is only a market when employers are bidding on candidates and people are looking for jobs. The rest of the time it is not a market anymore, as bids are not open and not visible to anyone. So during this time employees slowly undervalue themselves by not participating in a market and employers benefit by not paying the market value and trying to keep employees as long as possible in this situation, essentially always underpaying even that.

EDIT: This was all about short term and mid term behavior. I would like to mention that long term employers and investors can influence job market and increase competition among workers, pushing wages even further down.


This isn't quite right. Engineers are normally more valuable the longer they've worked in a job, because codebases take longer to understand, business domains need familiarizing, etc. Engineers aren't normally a commodity; the best offer you'll get on the open market will normally underestimate your value to your current company by some distance.

Getting a competing offer is still the way to get leverage for better compensation, although the downsides of accepting a counter-offer are fairly well documented.

On the topic further up the thread about profit: engineers are paid based approximately on replacement cost, but profits are created based on market opportunity and scarcity. A company can create an offering that's hard to reproduce (a monopoly) - harder than most individual engineers' skills are to reproduce - and the excess profits are effectively windfall profits until the market corrects and competition sprouts up. Thus a company can charge closer to the value it adds to the customer, rather than closer to its cost base. Ideally an engineer would try to do the same thing: charge based on the value he or she adds, rather than how much he or she can make elsewhere.

And bringing it back around, companies can eventually get a windfall cost saving / profit from long-serving engineers. Because of accumulated knowledge, they can become such a good fit for the company that the company can pay them substantially more than the market rate, but nowhere near how much value they add, simply because they know that they're the only customer: monopsony, the inverse of the monopoly situation. To extract more value in this situation, you need to bring non-monetary aspects to the negotiating table. My preferred one is ownership: not autonomy, but actual capital interest in my output.


I am very late here, but...

Can you elaborate your last point? Namely how do you extract more value in the monopsony situation?



Really? I think the theories that I'm drawing on here -- about the role of the firm and so on -- are much more neo-classical than Marxist.

Maybe you're confused by the second paragraph of my post. That wasn't intended to be read with any sort of moral indignation or as a suggestion that engineers ought to capture more of that value. Rather, it was a sincere question and the answer was "you've traded your ability to capture that value for the ability to work in an environment where you don't have to think strategically about the business and can focus on your engineering work".


I think his point is engineers typically no longer get profit sharing bonuses while managers typically do. The author was suggesting to get paid more, find more value to create. This isn't even close to linear like it is with managers because of the lack of profit sharing to engineers.

I would argue that in most organizations, the culmination of engineering talent creates way more value than the manager, with rare exceptions. Most of the time, the manager can get wrecked by a train, and the engineers will continue to create value. If the manager built that team, he should get some credit, but most of the time, the manager is just a plugin resulting in more of a hinderance than a benefit. "Respect my authorit-a," type people.

Of course, if engineers would unionize, they'd get the profit sharing bonuses they used to get, but society? has convinced engineers that they get paid based on merit and the value they create, which they kinda do, but the ratio of compensation to value approaches nil and gets worse the more value they create.

For example, if I create $1M of value and get paid $100K in year one, then I create $3M of value in year two, do you think the company would compensate me $300K that year? Hell no they wouldn't, but the execs sure would get compensated for my value creation. Again, based on what the author is selling: if you want more compensation, create more value, well that's a load of horse shit for most engineer employees.

Some companies still consider top level engineers management level and will give them profit sharing accordingly. Small companies might give some sort of equity. I'd steer clear of companies that don't.


They most likely would not want you to leave the company on that salary to value creation ratio.

Can you create 3M value on 100k salary at any company or just this one though?

If you can demonstrate that return others would be willing to pay more for your services.


There are multiple steps in the determination of profit ("earnings"), which I think is the cause of the confusion.

Folk tend to fixate on gross profit, because that's the pointy end of their direct market relationships. I buy a banana and it has an x% markup over the price paid to the distributor. That percentage may be quite high and if I'm aware of it I may think someone is taking the piss.

But of course gross profit is just the beginning: you need to deduct SG&A (which is where the senior managers live), R&D (the engineers) and other bits and bobs before arriving at EBIT.


so employees get 0% of the profits in salary.

Bonuses, profit sharing and raises are all things that exist. So while technically correct, you are actually completely wrong.


All the money the company disburses, whether it be bonuses, profit sharing, or salary, all comes from the same checking account.

Trying to infer an injustice by the what the check is called has no point.

The purpose of accounting is to organize and understand where the money comes from and where it is going and where it is allocated, and to compute the tribute owed to the government. But a check written to someone is a check is a check, since money is fungible.


Trying to infer an injustice by the what the check is called has no point.

Sure it does. Ever seen a contract that promises a bonus of “up to” some percentage? That should be read as “no matter how well we do your upside is capped and management trouser the rest”. It's a calculated, deliberate strategy to exploit naivety.


Again, it's the amount on the check that matters, not what the check is called.

Seriously, if you believe you're delivering far more value than what your checks represent, it's time to have a chat with the boss and go over it. If there's still no agreement, find another job.


> Trying to infer an injustice by the what the check is called has no point.

Oh, I might now see why you're being so pedantic about the definition of profit.

When I asked "If I'm the one figuring out how to create value, why the hell are the C suite, middle managers, and investors getting 99% of the profits?", I wasn't trying to make a moral point. It's not intended to be read with an indignant tone, but with a curious tone.

In fact, at the end of the post, I answer this question: because the engineer in a large firm has (perhaps) traded a bit of the value they create in order to be insulated from business decisions, allowing them to focus on engineering instead of on running the business.


Who drives the better cars, has better vacations, and better real-estate?


sales and c-suite


In a services company a salesperson will generate around 10x to the bottom line compared to an equivalent level fully utilised engineer, so this is more than fair.


Many words have several definitions. Some more specific and some more general as used by the public. You are right in an accounting sense, but not in the complete definitional sense.


If he did conflate "profit" with "gross revenue", I was explaining that indeed he was getting a share of it. And frankly it is impossible to have any sensible discussion about business and be confused about what profits are - the only definition that has meaning is the accounting definition.

It's like discussing newtonian mechanics and confusing momentum with energy.


People routinely use a more loose definition of the word productively, for instance the term "profit sharing" is commonly understood. But as you point out, unless it is through dividends from stock grants/options, whatever is shared with the employee no longer is profit.


That's just objectively false.

Other fields use the words profit, not just accountants. Economists and philosophers, at the very least, have a claim to it too, and they do not in any way conflate the meaning with the accounting definition. Indeed, we would argue that the accounting definition is the one that is conflated with the thing we actually care about (which is why the phrase "paper profits" even exists).

And its also quite clear he didn't "conflate" the meaning, but used it exactly as intended.

Most people, I'm assuming, can quite clearly see that he captures the idea that surplus value/revenue, of which the resulting wages are a non-deterministic and variable part to some degree. That upper management of the firm take a percentage of this slice of the pie, whilst lower down labour also gets a slice, and that the notional "social justification" for why upper-management gets a greater slice is being white-anted away as the lower downs are supposed to take on their responsibilities without commensurate compensation.


> Other fields use the words profit, not just accountants.

Sure, but we're talking about accounting here when discussing business profits. People are free to make up their own definitions of things, but that makes sensible discussion impossible.


It really doesn't. The majority of commenters here understood my original meaning, and this entire thread about the definition of profit isn't even relevant to the point I was actually making.

Being so fickle about definitions that you miss the broader message, however, does make sensible discussion impossible.


Let me try another way. P = profits, R = revenue, S = salary, E = expenses:

    P = R - S - E
Every dollar you get in salary is a 1:1 drop in profits. Any bonus B you get,

    P = R - (S + B) - E
is the same. You might expect from this, then, that if you're offered a S+B package, the S would be lower than what you'd get with a pure S offer, by the expected amount of B. And you'd be right. I've been on both sides of the negotiating table, and this is how it works.


> Let me try another way

Please... I understand your pedantry, and I don't care. This is a silly conversation.

Do you have any thoughts about the role of engineers in a firm and how the existence of firms relates to the article's thesis? That's a much more interesting and relevant topic for discussion than the fact that words sometimes have more than one definition.

So if not, let's kill this thread. I used the word "profit" in a way different from how it's used in Accounting 101. For that I am profoundly and eternally sorry, but not sorry enough to continue an off-topic and unenlightening conversation :-)


You'll want to consider the main point of the article then ask yourself how much of revenue is paid out is agency costs. It's a big chunk in most companies.


But, to continue your analogy - if you're asking me advice on how to make ends meet, then it absolutely is my business to chide you for the expensive lattes you buy daily.

The point discussed in the article is very valid: you need to be perceived as "delivering value" - otherwise, your compensation will suffer. That's the whole reason why you earn well working in finance - not because "only the smartest make it there", but because you're very close to the money. The money a quant brings in can be connected to him with a very short line.


I encourage you to read the original question that the author of this post is ranting about, where the question asker who's being chided in this post makes literally exactly the observation you make in your second paragraph: https://www.reddit.com/r/cscareerquestions/comments/7mgp1m/h...

The author of that post does understand these trade-offs and is asking the best way to maximize wrt his constraints. So this article just misses the mark.


No, the author of that post mimics an understanding of tradeoffs (proof[1]). As such, it is perfectly reasonable to chide him/her for it. Also he/she does not make the same observation that I made, "theoretically technical excellence directly translates into profits" is not even close to what I claimed.

[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/cscareerquestions/comments/7mgp1m/h...


> As an engineer, you might actually be better off ignoring engineering-value alignment because you might be better off simply executing well within a well-oiled machine.

This is generally the approach for maximizing cash compensation, in lieu of being a highly sought after programmer by Google et al. That and jumping from jobs every 2 years for 20-40% pay increase.

By Value, I think OP is talking about value in the context of an engineers role.

For an engineering, you can create linear value with your amazing code, but as you contribute more broadly (architecture design, mentoring, code-reviews, etc), you multiply the value you provide.

> If I'm the one figuring out how to create value, why the hell are the C suite, middle managers, and investors getting 99% of the profits?

That sentiment reminds me of this scene from The Wire: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1e10ZPVafUA (NSFW - Language)


How mant times can you get the 20-40% salary increases ? Very soon you will hit the band ceiling


> How mant times can you get the 20-40% salary increases ? Very soon you will hit the band ceiling

It would require taking on more responsibility, and moving up in roles.

Two points of clarification:

* This is in high demand markets.

* Pay = salary and bonus.

I'm not advocating job hopping, but if you purely want to maximize your income, you'll get a bigger increase taking a promotion at a new company (where you have more leverage to negotiate) then you will at your current company.

Me personally--I live by the cheat-code from WC2 -- All that glitters is not gold.


Yes, the original statement is totally reasonable:

Ultimately, I want a profitable product to be a byproduct of my excellent engineering, not have my engineering be just a means to an end, of getting to a profitable product.

In other words, “I want to work for a company that values engineering excellence.” And the reply is something like, “you don’t understand how business works”? It’s true that an understanding of the concepts in the article will help you recognize a good business so that you don’t go to work for a company started by engineers with no understanding of business themselves, but you don’t want to work for someone that has a knee-jerk reaction to bringing up engineering quality as something important, either.


Depends on whether you want to be a fungible cog in a race to the bottom on compensation. If yes, then you should make yourself a commodity. But if you want to move up the value chain, you should find out where those links are and start climbing.


> If I'm the one figuring out how to create value, why the hell are the C suite, middle managers, and investors getting 99% of the profits?

Because you're guaranteed compensation as an employee. You will get your salary even in the firm loses money - you're not taking any financial risks.


Unless you want to be micromanaged you need to keep the big picture in mind and think about how your work is providing value and how you can help maximize that.


I understand what you're saying, but I think you're wrong, for two reasons.

1. There's a reason that foxconn wants to manufacture in the USA, and there's a reason they're courting states in the great lakes region. Resolving the Prisoner's dilemma becomes much easier when there are ~3 states with viable sites as opposed to 50.

2. See guelo's comment.

Your point is well-taken in general, but in this particular case, IMO, it really is a stupid giveaway.


> Why would people not invest (or spend for that matter)?

People will still invest, but risk tolerance goes way down and ROI expectations go way up.

Concretely, your business plan has to compete with "I can get an x% return by putting my money under my pillow", and x becomes very large in a highly deflationary economy. Place yourself in the shoes of a person seeking investment in a productive business, and the problems with a deflationary economy become obvious. Being good isn't enough. You have to be better than "sit on my ass and get rich doing nothing".

In other words, the primary concern in a deflationary economy is discouraging value-producing economic activity.

Also, all of this is wrt deflation in general. Notice that a fiat currency can easily be deflationary. The deflationary nature of gold standards is a major component of the criticism of gold standards, but there are also other reasons that people oppose gold standards.

> Same can also be said about spending. As a contemporary example why would anyone buy a computer today when they know that in the near future they can get a better model for less? The whole computer industry thrives in a price deflationary sector of the economy.

People still buy computers because having a computer today helps capture value that you can't capture by having a better computer tomorrow. For consumers, entertainment tonight. For businesses, automating processes today.

> Whenever someone is trying to push one economic theory over another the key question you need to ask is cui bono.

That's not quite fair. There are people motivated by truth and there are also people motivated by ideology.


> That's not quite fair. There are people motivated by truth and there are also people motivated by ideology.

I wasn't singling out anyone in particular just the whole 'deflation is the debil' theory.


Wouldn't the deflationary economy only discourage investment in the least value-producing economic activity?


> completely uncorrelated with economic activity

It's always surprising to me when (not-already-on-the-top-f-the-world) software types see virtue in gold standards. The fact that our work -- moving bits around -- produces so much economic value is an epitome of everything that's wrong with a gold standard.


The major ISPs have a ridiculous amount of resources and are free to publish datasets answering this question at any moment. In fact, I'd be astounded if they don't already have this data, both for themselves and for their competitors. So until ISPs share that data, I'm terminally unsympathetic to any sort of bias in the public record on this particular topic.

Also, the selection of left-leaning people doing publicly accessible research is, AFAICT, a self-selection. The problem isn't that our institutions are biased, but that conservatives (in general) choose not to pursue scientific careers in the same numbers as liberals. This suggests a fundamental limit to your proposed solution because there aren't enough "heterodox" collaborators to ensure viewpoint diversity. One of the studies published on the website you mentioned even suggests this underlying cause.

Also, I'll note that in the vast majority of academia, internal politics (what research methodologies, maths, etc. someone likes to use) are far more of a problem than external politics (of the sort you'd typically call "politics" in general conversation). E.g. I'm not at all worried about "liberal bias" in physics or chemistry or CS; if it's a problem at all, then it's a minor one compared to other problems.


Very frequently people call up a broadband provider, get told there is broadband at their address, then they get told later that in fact it is not. Thus it's not clear that providers have a real handle on this at an operational level, never mind a synoptic level.

As for left v right, it's true that adjunct faculty who teach English are rabid leftists because they are working four jobs that are 60 miles apart, have no health insurance, qualify for food stamps, etc.

One reason you see so few rightists in conventional academia is that they can go work for places like the Manhattan Institute, Hoover Institution, etc. and get paid much more, not have to teach, not deal with the rat race. There is a continuous drumbeat of reports on how there is no broadband problem in the U.S. that is funded by the industry -- these don't get much attention outside the trade press because normal people know that students camp outside the school some nights because they don't have broadband at home.


> ...people call up a broadband provider, get told there is broadband at their address, then they get told later that in fact it is not. Thus it's not clear that providers have a real handle on this at an operational level, never mind a synoptic level.

The provider (or the provider's CSR) is being lazy. They absolutely do have the data.

In AT&T's case, they have a Java software interface ("CPSOS") into which you can plug in an address and get back the distance in thousands of feet from the address to the nearest RT or CO (major network interconnection). The distance between those points gives you an estimate for the maximum DSL speed that can likely be supported; you can guarantee up to 6mpbs down at up to 5k feet if I remember right, and it tapers off from there to 10k feet, at which point you start saying, "we might be able to get you 512kbps but we're not sure, we'd have to try installing it and see what happens."

The sense you get, both as a consumer and as a service provider that gets a little more of an inside view into these companies, is that they absolutely do have the data and the capability, but that isn't where their priorities are. They just want to make a buck with as little capital investment as possible, and everything that they do reflects that.


Whether or not the ISPs have this information is a fundamentally separate issue from whether ideological homogeneity biases science. There is no dichotomy here.

The degree to which self selection plays a role is an interesting question. Firstly, there is a certain amount of overt harassment--for example, professors in the humanities and social sciences openly admit that they would be inclined to reject a candidate if they knew he or she was conservative. Also there are lots of other data, anecdotal or quantitative. Much more is needed, however.

Importantly, the proportion of conservatives to liberals has been falling since the 90s, so something is driving the trend. It's also possible that conservatives are selecting out of a career that they (evidently correctly) perceive to be hostile to them or otherwise corrupt (more interested in furthering an agenda than seeking truth). The point is that even if it is self-selection, we may be able to improve the ratio enough to improve the science. And it's not like the ratio needs to be 50:50--probably 30:70 would suffice. Right now many fields are less than 10:90, and intuition suggests that the effect is nonlinear. If only 10% of faculty are conservative, intimidation causes them to suppress their already marginal voice, but 30% might be enough to allow them to feel secure in providing the sort of criticism those fields seem to desperately need. Of course, I'm picking on the academy, but the same probably holds true for journalism.

Again, the point isn't to assign blame, but to improve the science.


> Whether or not the ISPs have this information is a fundamentally separate issue from whether ideological homogeneity biases science. There is no dichotomy here.

I'm sort of making two only vaguely related claims here.

Claim 1: In this particular case, I don't think bias is even a problem, because we shouldn't even be doing this leg work on behalf of ISPs in the first place.

My point is that ISPs choose not to contribute to the quality of publicly available information. When entire industries (or governments) willfully hide data that's necessary for a populace to make an informed decision, I default to a worst-case assumption on that data. Not because I think that's most likely, but out of contempt for the lack of transparency and as a forcing function for greater transparency.

In other words, these "biased" researchers are already a hell of a lot more charitable toward the ISPs' position than I think we ought to be. If ISPs aren't willing to share granular data on network accessibility, then assume it's a major problem until they muster up the will to share that data.

>... the humanities and social sciences...

Claim 2: On this issue, I think it's helpful to discuss "critical studies" and related departments separately from the rest of "academia" and separately from the natural and mathematical sciences in particular. I don't think that the liberal bias in natural/math sciences has the same underlying causes OR the same long-term effects.

I.e., I don't think that chemistry departments are hiring based upon political beliefs, and I also don't think that political homogeneity effects the quality of chemistry research.

You also have to explain why political diversity is even important in the face of other forms of homogeneity. E.g., I'd rather a very liberal, very theoretical physics department hire a flaming liberal experimentalist than yet another theorist who happens to be conservative. The importance of political diversity in humanities and social sciences is obvious, but I don't see why science would suffer if all algebraists were libertarians...

My assertion is that if you want a politically diverse chemistry department, you have to 1) justify why that diversity is even necessary / more significant than other major problems; and then 2) probably also solve different underlying causes.

> Of course, I'm picking on the academy, but the same probably holds true for journalism.

And also literally every other profession, from clergy to CEOs to career criminals. There's even a trite quote about it.


> Claim 1

I respect that your opinion is that ISPs have a social responsibility to disclose this information so think tanks and academies don't have to find it. I'm curious if anyone thought to ask them, but that's neither here nor there. I don't generally expect businesses to provide data apart beyond that which is required by law, but I'll concede the point since it's unrelated to my claims.

> Claim 2: On this issue, I think it's helpful to discuss "critical studies" and related departments separately from the rest of "academia" and separately from the natural and mathematical sciences in particular. I don't think that the liberal bias in natural/math sciences has the same underlying causes OR the same long-term effects.

I agree, and I intended to. I should have done better, but I quickly authored that comment from my phone in the waiting room at the vet clinic.

> You also have to explain why political diversity is even important in the face of other forms of homogeneity. E.g., I'd rather a very liberal, very theoretical physics department hire a flaming liberal experimentalist than yet another theorist who happens to be conservative. The importance of political diversity in humanities and social sciences is obvious, but I don't see why science would suffer if all algebraists were libertarians...

Again, I don't mean to apply my "political diversity" quip to apolitical fields.

> My assertion is that if you want a politically diverse chemistry department, you have to 1) justify why that diversity is even necessary / more significant than other major problems; and then 2) probably also solve different underlying causes.

I agree, and I don't think political diversity is important in chemistry, since few chemistry topics are politically polarized.

> "Of course, I'm picking on the academy, but the same probably holds true for journalism." And also literally every other profession, from clergy to CEOs to career criminals. There's even a trite quote about it.

Probably some degree of political diversity is good for all fields, but it's uniquely critical for politically polarized epistemological fields.


Out of curiosity, what's the quote you mentioned?


This methodology would completely miss the point of the 538 story, which was to report on access.


It makes a reasonable assumption that everyone with access has similar usage profile, at the level of country averages


That assumption isn't helpful, and even if it were, isn't necessarily reasonable. But I'll just fwd you to pmyteh's post instead of rehashing those claims here.


Wait, is that true?

From the article, it does seem that the training and test sets were both generating from a dubious data collection process: scraping URLs they knew were fake/satire/real and then applying a label based upon the domain.

But, they had more features than just "source" in their model. so while it's possible their data collection method means that their model is way over-fit and basically just tests of proxies of "source", it's not prime facie obvious that this is the case...? Or am I missing something?


The website lists domain name as a model feature: https://machinebox.io/docs/fakebox

> Domain name - Some domains are known for hosting certain types of content, Fakebox knows about the most popular sites

Fake news sites typically register bespoke domains, though.


Oh, I misinterpreted the article.

If the test data was collected in the same way that the training data was collected, this was a rather ridiculously round-about way of writing what should've been a 5 line perl script, and I'm really curious where the 5% error could've possibly even come from :-\


Yes, I think this is one case where both sides of the issue can agree the real problem is that our civil justice system seems to care more about the depth of your pockets than the veracity of your position.

That needs to change, and you can find your way to this conclusion via sympathy with Hogan or with Gawker, but perhaps not via sympathy with Thiel (for the obvious reason).


Anti-SLAPP laws have the same problem as "regulation via judiciary" -- by the time the law becomes useful, the damage is already done. If you go bankrupt defending yourself, suing under a SLAPP law doesn't help. Also, the barrier for proving you shouldn't be SLAPPed is far lower than the already low barrier for civil damages, so there's some question as to whether this even solves the problem.

Our civil justice system needs to be cheaper and more accessible. It shouldn't be possible to wage economic war on a company or individual via the judiciary.


Attorneys can take your case pro bono and then sue for wages later with anti-SLAPP, iirc. And it's much cheaper to file the anti-SLAPP than to defend against the suit.


Well, sure, and a billionaire can donate billions of dollars to help defend you. Or you could crowd-fund $5 million. Or...

But designing a justice system around "maybe you'll find a charitable person willing to help" seems like a bad idea.


Sounds like the Nirvana fallacy in action. Unless you have a better proposal, complaining about how some improvement isn't perfect doesn't do anything.


> Sounds like the Nirvana fallacy in action. Unless you have a better proposal

Pointing out problems with the current system is not a logical fallacy, and having a working solution in-hand is not a pre-requisite to observing the existence of problems.

Also, accusing me of using the Nirvana fallacy while also accusing me of not providing an alternative policy is literally a contradiction...


You're critiquing my proposal for a new federal law.


I haven't claimed there's a perfect solution. I haven't even claimed there is a solution. I'm just pointing out that your proposal is not a solution.


> I also don't see why how a single billionaire funding a lawsuit is that different than thousands of us funding a lawsuit by the EFF. If money = speech than those are both protected by the 1st amendment.

There is a difference. It's a microcosm of the difference between a god-king and an elected president.


That analogy doesn't fit because the money doesn't give someone direct power but instead allows them to tip the scales in their favor. It is the same as Citizens United. The money allows influencing other people's votes but the money isn't directly choosing the president.

I am also not speaking about a moral difference, I am speaking about a legal difference. How can you allow someone to spend $X on something with the logic that money equals speech but not allow someone to spend $X multiplied by a million on the same thing?


Sure.

Citizens United is also terrible.


I agree, but that is a clear result of the 1st Amendment. And you get lots of people angry if you start to question whether the 1st Amendment is a great idea.


No, it isn't. It's a result of a surprising and non-obvious legal doctrine established in a case regarding the 14th Amendment.

Citizens United itself was a 5-4 decision, so it's fair to say that CU was also a far-from-clear result.


I am not sure what you are really arguing here. The 14th Amendment portion of Citizens United is not the part of the case that has relevancy to this discussion. Overturning that portion would still allow Thiel's actions since he was acting as an individual. It would have a greater chance of effecting the EFF's action in that regard.


> The 14th Amendment portion of Citizens United is not the part of the case that has relevancy to this discussion

The Citizens United decision rests on Corporate Personhood. Corporate Personhood was established in a case testing the limits of the 14th amendment.


Citizens United was a case that addressed two issues. There was the 14th Amendment issue of corporate personhood and the 1st Amendment issue of whether money equals speech. Both of those had been applied separately before but this decision unified the two. You are focusing on the 14th Amendment portion while I was referencing the 1st Amendment portion, which is also likely the less controversial portion.


“Corporate personhood" is the whole point of the corporate form, and predates the US.


As does "freedom of speech", I guess. But both of those things mean something more specific in the context of US constitutional law, of course. It's that more specific meaning to which I'm referring. Sorry for the lack of precision.

Anyways, my only point was that Citizens United was not exactly a clear or obvious application of the First Amendment, and offering up the integral role of cases involving the Fourteenth Amendment as examples.

I guess merely mentioning that the decision was 5-4 would've been enough and prevented this now rather long thread.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: