We need a college education to be accessible to anyone who is qualified. That's different from universal higher education. Those signals get crossed a lot.
We need a college education to be accessible to anyone who is qualified
You should read the article:
The labor market doesn’t pay you for the useless subjects you master; it pays you for the preexisting traits you signal by mastering them. This is not a fringe idea. Michael Spence, Kenneth Arrow, and Joseph Stiglitz—all Nobel laureates in economics—made seminal contributions to the theory of educational signaling. Every college student who does the least work required to get good grades silently endorses the theory. But signaling plays almost no role in public discourse or policy making. As a society, we continue to push ever larger numbers of students into ever higher levels of education. The main effect is not better jobs or greater skill levels, but a credentialist arms race.
If college is mostly about signaling, then it's an arms race, and the faster the herd, the more the individual most race in order to keep up.
Accessibility to higher education is important, but much more of that education should be vocational in nature. Right now we have a lot of access to college, but that access has led to ballooning problems with student loans, along with Girard-style mimetic crises ( https://jakeseliger.com/2017/06/27/violence-and-the-sacred-o... ).
If college is part of a signaling arms race, if we conceive of education purely as a labor market good, why are we asking the laborers to stand down from that race and not the employers?
Indeed, if everybody knows that a college education is empty signaling, then how is it possibly still effective?
The best and biggest employers should have the best information on the value of college education (in whole and in terms of its parts, such as humanities courses). They could expand their potential labor pool and make better or cheaper hires by adopting different hiring standards. If there's an information arbitrage going on here, somebody should be able to make money from it.
In my view the elephant in the room is that maybe a college education is valuable after all, but we haven't put our finger on the precise reason.
>The best and biggest employers should have the best information on the value of college education (in whole and in terms of its parts, such as humanities courses).
Depends how one defines "best"; though this is debatable, because one could say that these are the most beholden to the signaling arms race despite the data they may have to the contrary (i.e alphabet, amazon, et al).
>In my view the elephant in the room is that maybe a college education is valuable after all, but we haven't put our finger on the precise reason.
I don't think this is the elephant in the room at all, people routinely say that some parts of a college education can be valuable for various reasons, while others (as judged by value by the marketability of the graduates) are not valuable at all.
In my view, the "best" and biggest employers like it because it signals some default level of competence (which is growing weaker as the incentives are to push everyone through to get some kind of degree) as well as relative malleability and conformance to institutionalized authority (those who opted out, or didn't go might not conform to the corporate identity or end up making it expensive for the employer to employ them, compared to their counter parts; after all, hiring based on objective measurements/metrics without any human involvement isn't something that happens today). Also these companies are largely affected by the turnover rates compared to smaller ones, so it's easier to target colleges graduates as a cohort.
>If there's an information arbitrage going on here, somebody should be able to make money from it.
I do think some employers take advantage of this environment, though I doubt it's alphabets, amazons, and apples…
Who is we? Certainly not the author of the article we're discussing. He specifically talks about recommending going in to higher education to the individual.
And on the flip side, in the states that use lottery funds to provide college for all graduates with a specific GPA.....we are seeing a tremendous number of students losing their scholarships for poor grades or simply delaying entering the workforce to have a semester or more of playing at college.
Accessible to anyone qualified does not equal a good choice for anyone.
> But then the corollary is, sometimes the data is good.
Yes. but in my limited experience with ML, "the data is good" usually isn't the
>> most likely
explanation :-)
> This is what happens with loan or crime data sets, and it made plenty of noise in the news recently - but only the kind of noise in which people say it's obviously the algorithm that's broken, because it doesn't fit the "polite fiction" they'd like to believe.
People say the algorithm is broken because it's illegal to discriminate on the basis of race, and these algorithms were sneaking "discriminate by race" "in through the back door".
Calling the law a polite fiction won't get you very far when the judge issues an injunction against using your product because it's racially biased.
And the judge doesn't care how machine learning researchers define bias. He cares how the law defines bias.
So, if you're diddling around on your computer in your own time, then I guess the algorithm isn't broken. But if you're building a product you want to sell to courts or insurance companies, the algorithm very much is broken.
That is, unless you think "the law is a polite fiction and bias means only what ML researchers say it means" would be a winning argument to lift an injunction against your product. If you're going to make those arguments in front of a real judge, let me know; I want to see the bulge in that judge's forehead :-)
No. People say the algorithm is broken because it obviously is broken.
> So you're basically saying the algorithm is broken because it discovers illegal correlations, even though they may be true.
No. Discovering those correlations is completely legal. Making certain decisions based upon those correlations is illegal. Mostly because by making a decision, you make a tacit assumption about causation that's borderline impossible to prove and can have a huge impact on people's lives.
Like I said, if it's just you in your home office having fun, go at it. But if you then bake that model into certain products, you have a very serious bug.
> Well, that's precisely "polite fiction".
Except in this case, it's not even that!!!
The observation that certain crime statistics are highly correlated with race, and that race is correlated with zip code, are not new observations. ML did not usher in some brave new world here. Just because we call it "AI in 2018" instead of "John from the Actuarial dept. in 1960" doesn't change the moral, ethical, or legal landscape. (the article literally makes exactly this point.)
And despite your characterization, this particular truth (race correlates to crime correlates to zip) isn't even a politically incorrect observation!!! It's something everyone already knows, and I've never seen someone attacked for pointing out this correlation. In fact, it's a favorite talking point of social justice types! Pointing out this correlation is not impolite.
The impolite assertion is that there's a causative link between race and crime. That's an assertion that models (tacitly) make when their users shift from truth-seeking to decision-making. See the "question you thought you asked vs. question you actually asked" portion of the essay.
Now, if ML algorithms discovered some genetic, racial, causal theory of crime, then you might have a point about ML exposing polite fictions in this case. But they didn't, so you don't. COMPAS isn't being censored from sharing a politically incorrect truth. It's being prevented from ruining people's lives with a really, really lazy application of statistics.
I often joke that racial discrimination laws are one of the few examples where "being bad at math" is not just criminal, but unconstitutional.
> ...laws are not designed as truth-seeking tools
Again, in cases where bias becomes illegal, these models are NOT just being used to seek truth. They're being used to make decisions.
You seem to have misconstrued the fundamental thesis of the article. The author isn't calling for death to polite fictions. And there's a concrete example in the article of this point of departure between your perspective and his. Namely, his response to people-as-gorillas was not "fuck you, the math is right". And the crescendo of the piece is "AI is just a tool, not a divine oracle, and there's nothing new under the sun".
Scrape PDFs on the services you support for email addresses. If a domain name occurs in enough author email addresses and isn't on a "known generic" list (gmail et al), consider it "safe".
Your philosophy towards mathematics education is interesting. If you don't mind me asking a direct question: what's the point?
Here's my take on the purpose of math courses in college: any college graduate should be able to teach themselves something "like" calculus or linear algebra upon graduation. So you should teach calculus and especially linear algebra in such a way that a student who has never seen e.g. graph theory can pick that up a bit of graph theory their own using the thinking skills they acquired by studying linear algebra or calculus. Ditto for dynamic programming or combinatorics or basic probability or...
So if you're not teaching proofs, wth are you teaching all semester? A few conceptual underpinnings that take about a week to explain, and then a whole bunch of crap Mathematica can do for you anyways.
> computational mathematics like calculus and (linear) algebra.. move proof-based mathematics into a targeted graduate degree
Memorizing symbolic calculations and/or understanding (how to use) numerical algorithms do not endow students with the skills required to learn new mathematics. Proof-based calculus and algebra courses do teach those skills.
The recent post on HN about PID control comes to mind. I'd expect someone with a bit of practice at writing proofs to be able to teach themselves why PID controllers work and avoid pitfalls. But I would not expect your average human-meat-based-derivative-and-integral-calculator to be able to understand the same.
To put it in terms of a folk saying about fishing: if you teach a man to calculate, he can perform a specific calculation. If you teach a man how to write proofs, he can learn any calculation he might need throughout his lifetime.
I think you and I mean different things by computational mathematics. Calculus isn't analysis, but it still has substantial rigor to it. You might not be able to develop calculus from scratch after studying it, like you could by working through real analysis, but that doesn't mean studying calculus has to be hollow and rote. For example, I find Spivak's Calculus to be a good compromise between full on analysis and the kind of formula memorization you're talking about.
Ideally computational mathematics teaches more than just the simple "what" - it should address at least one of the "how" or "why", but it doesn't necessarily need to address all three. I also disagree that the point of the education should be for students to be capable of teaching themselves novel mathematics (and to be honest, I'm pessimistic most graduating math undergrads could do that simply because they made it through something like Rudin).
The first sentence of the fourth paragraph is not even necessary given the first sentence of the post. That's not a criticism, and I'm not heartless. It's just true :)
More seriously, what you're supposed to do is undermine yourself. Support efforts to substantially decrease the market rate of housing.
As a very, VERY purposeful non-landlord who has never missed a rent check or mortgage payment, I don't have any sympathy for land lords. I understand your financial and moral viewpoint, but I don't find it redeemable.
So. That's the analog of your viewpoint. Not deadbeats, but your financial equals who don't see anything redeemable about lordship.
The difference is, I’ve been on both sides. I’ve never owned my own residence, always rented. If you had bills to pay for rental properties that you bought, you might understand my side a little more. But maybe not. It kind of sounds like you’re just upset about rent being too high (me too!) and think individual market sellers should charge well below market rates to “do something”.
Sometimes I do that, actually. I have a tenant who has lived in my building since I bought it and I’ve never raised his rent. It’s substantially below market rate but he’s older and a model tenant so I just leave him be.
But your approach doesn’t make sense at a broad level. The cost of tech labor is too high for many startups. Do you negotiate a lower salary to try and do your part to lower the market rate?
But again, I’m irredeemable so not sure why I’m bothering to respond :)
Arguably, no. With a salary you are negotiating the value of your productivity against the profit margin of the business.
The stake of the business owner is closer to that of the landlord, who is involved in arbitrage in a system where 'liquidity' (in this case finding another job or home) is difficult, expensive and rare. Prime conditions for rent-seeking behaviour (which is bad).
Now, you as a person may be redeemable ;) but in general, the actions of landlords as a whole use the actual roof over people's heads as bargaining chips to further their un-productive wealth. Which is not to say that landlords cannot be productive in their provision of housing. Just that in general in places like the US, or AU (where I am), this is not the case.
And the thing is, I would surely do the same thing if I had the opportunity to buy up a few rental properties and squeeze the tenants for a few bucks. I would like to think I would at least have the decency to feel a little bad about it.
Which is not to say that landlords cannot be productive in their provision of housing. Just that in general in places like the US, or AU (where I am), this is not the case.
Can you expand upon this? What would that look like, and what are the indications that US and AU landlords aren’t productive?
Well in the UK for instance they have housing coops which exist solely for the purpose of their tenants. Also tenants have greater protections like right of abode, which encourage a longer term view for both tenants and landlords. Basically for a landlord to be productive and not rent-seeking, there has to be some level of symbiosis to the arrangement.
I think this is easier to understand with commercial rents. In my local street a half-dozen or so shops have been closed in the past two months, and sit empty due to excessive rent increases. The landlords have forced an un-productive arrangement due to their rent-seeking.
You can apply this same idea to housing, but instead of a business closing, a tenant is strained to the point they make un-productive life decisions, or to the point they cannot pay rent (or cannot see the point of paying rent).
But in this case there is a much greater supply of new tenants than new businesses to fill the void, so you never see the issue illustrated as graphically.
I believe the parent means "productive" in the sense that the higher rents charged are justified by capital improvements and/or the rising costs of being a landlord. That's not the case for the markets cited; landlords are charging more simply because they can.
This is "unproductive" in the sense that it causes negative economic activity. A person becoming homeless usually ends up not contributing to the economy. A person who has to move to a smaller home in a more remote area has less money to spend, and likely has a longer commute, which wastes money.
> Sometimes I do that, actually. I have a tenant who has lived in my building since I bought it and I’ve never raised his rent. It’s substantially below market rate but he’s older and a model tenant so I just leave him be.
That's super great, and I absolutely agree with and love that sort of behavior on the part of landlords.
> Do you negotiate a lower salary to try and do your part to lower the market rate?
This doesn't make much sense from a power imbalance perspective. Both a landlord and an employer have an outsized portion of the power here: the landlord gets to decide whether or not a tenant has a home or is homeless, and the employer gets to decide whether or not an employee has a job. The renter & employee in these situations are the ones who stand to lose the most, and don't have much power or recourse to fix the situation.
It doesn't make sense to me to ask a potential employee to negotiate a lower salary; they're hurting themselves pretty heavily by doing so (and, hilariously, making it so they can't afford their rent and can't pay you, the landlord, what you feel you're due), and asking for a modestly higher salary does not hurt the company that much. On the other hand, a landlord deciding not to raise rent doesn't hurt the landlord much at all[0], and it means a ton to the tenant.
> It kind of sounds like you’re just upset about rent being too high (me too!) and think individual market sellers should charge well below market rates to “do something”.
At the end of the day I will always vote for tenants not being homeless over landlords being able to increase their (already positive) profit margins. Property ownership is not some no-strings-attached right that lets you do whatever you want; it's ownership of a scarce public resource, and it's in the public interest to keep people in homes and not out on the streets, and to have a healthy, functioning economy that everyone has the spare cash to participate in.
[0] This is assuming a market where the costs of being a landlord aren't going up much (at least nowhere near at the same rate as rents are/had been), which is the case we're talking about here. The potential rent increase is driven solely by demand, not by any increase in intrinsic value that the landlord or property is providing.
Ah, but I’d argue that you are playing that game, because it’s just incredibly basic supply and demand. So whether you have a job or provide jobs or own or rent or buy things at the store or sell things online, you’re playing this game too. And you only get to play your side because someone else plays the other side. Seems pretty morally incongruent to call them irredeemable for voluntarily selling or buying from you, doesn’t it?
Edit: for example, if you’ve rented or bought, you’ve contributed to the demand that makes the market price go up. If you were a landlord, at least you’d be helping provide supply that keeps the price in check :)
Not all markets are as susceptible to rent seeking as the... rental... market.
Distinguishing between rental markets and less pathological applications of market mechanisms is not exactly novel economic doctrine. And in fact, you'll have a hard time finding a tradition of economics without its own giant calling out landlords.
If there were no landlords to buy and then lease those properties, the rental market would not exist. Just like Ford builds cars, but they don’t create the car rental supply. Enterprise, Hertz, etc do. The cars are the capital asset being rented, not the supply side of the rental market.
I didn't say that. I said they supply rental housing, which is a distinction. And that's 100% true. Landlords 100% supply rental housing. To claim otherwise is absurd.
This data isn't up-to-date and the list is for opiates, not opioids But this still gives you a good sense for which countries to look up. IMO opiates are closer to marijuana or cocaine than to heroin -- i.e., an otherwise healthy, happy, intelligent, and drug-educated person using in a purely recreational context is unlikely to die or even become severely addicted. Different from opioids in that respect.