Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more throwawayjava's commentslogin

What is the typical demographic of your cohorts? How do you compare to college programs that have similar cohort demographics?

I think all educational outcomes should be measured with respect to the answers to these two questions.

K12 schools in extremely wealthy areas can compare themselves to like peers, but comparing themselves to high-poverty areas is a useless comparison. Neither institution would do well under the other's constraints.

For-profit higher ed is definitely the same way.


We're very spread out, general lower income, more black/latinx than white, so it's not a case of us just grabbing the rich kids.


> And what if this had been a startup in Bangalore or Mumbai, would they be getting crap from the FCC for launching the very same satellites?

Oh yes, it's a whole big thing! See: https://www.fcc.gov/international


All of those things for white men, at least since 2008.

Which you can read either way (oy, I must have karma to burn?). On the one hand, the anti-capitalist left in the US has historically had a contingent with racial undertones. On the other hand, literally every other group's station was improved at least in part through government mechanisms (equal protection under law, civil rights, etc.) rather than market mechanisms.


As a pasty white man myself, life has been improving steadily since 2008. My income I think has doubled since then, I’ve lost about 20lbs of fat and I’ve picked up some cool new hobbies!

True, I did have to get a relevant degree and not be an idiot at work to advance, but life is pretty good overall.

Now if you mean that being a White Man by itself isn’t enough anymore to get you a cushy life style, then yes, it’s not. Welcome to the place everyone else has been in since forever.


There's a lot of people who weren't invited to the party.

The "able bodied, but aren't working number is close to an all time high. I believe it's higher than when women stayed at home while hubby worked?

I have never seen this amount of homelessness. I see daily. Im becoming too hardened to the suffering.

People used to have the privilege of having two shitty jobs. Now--those jobs are coveted, as careers, by hard working immigrants--that see nothing wrong with fitting six people in a 10 x 12 foot room.

Look at the jobs on Craigslist. Work with us for three hours a day, or on call? So many are just rediculious. Buy a four door, late model car, we approve of, and go into a slow debt death. Or, the amount of thieving bastards who know they can get away with terrible work conditions, and pay that makes showing up debatable.

Crime is down. Cameras are everywhere. People/business don't use cash like they used too. Surveillance is everywhere. And like always, the rich seem to get treated better by the justice system? Fees/fines have never been so high. Only the wealthy can afford to commit crimes? Oh, and they do run afoul of so many laws.

Look at all the young scholars who are living at home. Many living at a family home that will probally not be passed down because mom and dad will be forced into a reverse mortgage.

In tech--yes, the party is fierce. I do notice the new cars. I notice the carefree attitude. There's a liberal air of "Hay--it's just hard work? I'm just more clever than that guy?".

I hope it all lasts.

I guarantee so many of you will be right here wondering what the hell happened, on a old device? I think a new version of the punk movement will pop up. The hippie movement won't be the joke it currently is. Hell--the denial might protect a lot of you when the money dries up?


2008 is a decade, not five.

But more importantly, what statistics do you actually have for this?


By the way, it turns out people have been fucking all along and that there actually aren't any black or white people. Never were. Someone made the whole thing up and it got a wee bit out of hand. Thought you might like to know, as it might save you an awful lot of time and worry.


What is the claim you are trying to make? I don't see any sarcastic "/s" present so I assume you are being serious.

Are you saying that there are none to little genetic/biological differences between different races?


I think he's saying that "races" are a made up category and theres just people. I happen to agree, there is nothing special about some gene pool with an evocative label.


Sure, but I don't think anyone has claimed otherwise? Obviously there's very little genetic basis for the concept of race as a big important thing, but social constructs are absolutely real even if they're a product of our collective imagination.


I'm having a little discussion on a parallel thread where someone absolutely is advocating for some sort of racial determinism and thats the context for the comment. [0]

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16517930


To believe that you would have to ignore the current scientific evidence which is becoming stronger and stronger with the acceleration in our understanding of the human genome.

Even without any of that evidence though, we still have books like the bell curve which people have tried hard to debunk but so far the key points made in the book about the genetic existence of race have not even come close to being debunked.


> current scientific evidence

there is no evidence for the existence of a race that does not rely on referencing the idea of a race. the idea is self-referential. to understand this, you must understand philosophy.

another way of saying this is that assigning a person to a race doesn't give us any more information than the information we used to classify him in the first place.

> so far the key points made in the book about the genetic existence of race have not even come close to being debunked.

ok, I'll bite: what defines a race? what test do I apply to a specimen in order to sort him/her into a race category?


> there is no evidence for the existence of a race that does not rely on referencing the idea of a race. the idea is self-referential. to understand this, you must understand philosophy.

Huh? Race is defined by a combination of genetics in the form of phenotypes and culture. I don't see the circular paradox here.

> another way of saying this is that assigning a person to a race doesn't give us any more information than the information we used to classify him in the first place.

But we can? We can say that Chinese are more likely to be shorter than africans. That asians are more likely to have black hair than blonde hair or that africans are more likely to have higher testosterone than european whites or indians.

Ask any doctor or pharmacist and they can list you a few ways they are taught about how to treat people of different races differently because of biological differences.

We can even go further and say for instance that ashkenazi jews have a higher average IQ compared to Africans due to a large part their genetic differences and not purely environmental reasons.

The bell curve which was published a few decades ago proves many of these kind of claims so I don't know where you get this idea that we cannot determine anything useful from race.

> ok, I'll bite: what defines a race? what test do I apply to a specimen in order to sort him/her into a race category?

I gave a definition previously which is pretty accepted, for how you test for a race the answer is that's pretty easy, 99% of the time you can just ask someone and they will tell you.

We can prove this through cluster analysis, where you take a sample set of people and first ask them what race they are from a set number of selections. They then can read SNPs from each of the participants and hand that to a computer without the self reported data the people provided.

What you see is that even with 100 random SNP's you have a near perfect correlation between what people say their race is and the computer correctly grouping them into the race they chose.

If you want to see some sources, here is an article that links off and summarizes the studies I am referencing http://thealternativehypothesis.org/index.php/2016/04/15/329...


> We can say that Chinese are more likely to be shorter than africans.

whats a chinese? whats an african? and what is it about those categories that makes it necessary for you to speak in probabilities and not certainties? if those categories accurately described features of reality, and were not mere artifacts that stem from your worldview, you would be able to rigorously tell me a relationship between gene(s) and features.

> Race is defined by a combination of genetics in the form of phenotypes and culture.

> for how you test for a race the answer is that's pretty easy, 99% of the time you can just ask someone and they will tell you.

exactly, its a made up category, i.e. not a real thing.

> We can prove this through cluster analysis, where you take a sample set of people and first ask them what race they are from a set number of selections. They then can read SNPs from each of the participants and hand that to a computer without the self reported data the people provided.

you can do the same thing for things like "hippie", "biker", "nerd" etc. it doesn't make those categories leave the intersubjective realm.


> necessary for you to speak in probabilities and not certainties?

You're replying to a person who is specifically referencing group stats and not in a deterministic way.

Here's one extreme statement:

- There is no such thing as race, in that E(X | race) = E(X) for all X that we care about

Here's another extreme statement:

- Race biologically determines your fate, e.g. E(X | race + C) = E(X | race) for any 'other information' C

Both statements as wrong. As usual, the truth is somewhere in between.

Even if you don't think that 'race' is the most salient metric, it doesn't help that our culture sometimes seems to willfully conflate culture, religion, ethnicity, and race in the most uncharitable possible way.

Eg. if you say something bad about Islam itself as a religion, one often finds themselves accused of implicit racism—and this is accusation is determined by seeing that one group of people of a certain 'race' seems to follow that religion more, so if you criticize a religion, you must be intending to attack that group of people.


> do the same thing for things like "hippie", "biker", "nerd"

while race is not the correct term to use there, breeding two nerds or two biker isn't likely to produce another nerd or biker, while the result of breeding two people of a common ancestry has a likely outcome.

> exactly, its a made up category, i.e. not a real thing.

race is a made up category, but you can't just hand wave all of it:

> what is it about those categories that makes it necessary for you to speak in probabilities [..] you would be able to rigorously tell me a relationship between gene(s) and features.

only because something hasn't been explored in its entirety doesn't make it less convincing of an argument. beside, genetic is rooted in statistics, because of recessive/dominant expressions of traits, so you have to talk in probabilities.


> breeding two nerds or two biker isn't likely to produce another nerd or biker, while the result of breeding two people of a common ancestry has a likely outcome.

this is preposterous on many levels. 1. the outcome of any breeding project can be described in terms of species, individuals, and traits. race is an unnecessary and poorly defined category. 2. the offspring of nerds and bikers have a non-trivial likelihood of turning out to be nerds and bikers. 3. the person I replied to wants culture to be a component of race.

> you can't just hand wave all of it:

It's well within the bounds of proper discourse for me to be a racial noncognitivist because I believe the concept to be incoherent, and protest its usage by requiring my interlocutor to tell me what exactly they mean by this particular nonsense term.

>beside, genetic is rooted in statistics, because of recessive/dominant expressions of traits, so you have to talk in probabilities.

look, theres a value to studying the interaction of genes and their expression in an organism. there isn't value in delineating a gene pool into "races" because the category is net harmful to understanding.


> whats a chinese? whats an african? and what is it about those categories that makes it necessary for you to speak in probabilities and not certainties?

I already answered that race is generally defined as a combination of genetics and culture. I don't see what your argument is, some kind of no true scotsman where because the definition of race isn't some set in stone definition that you can perfect attain with a genetic test it's completely useless as a grouping mechanic without something else to replace it.

The reason i'm speaking in probabilities is because that is what the facts are, that we have more variance within races than between. Which is to say there is no reason you can't have an african who is the shortest person in the world, or a chinese man could be the tallest just because the mean bears out the opposite.

> if those categories accurately described features of reality, and were not mere artifacts that stem from your worldview, you would be able to rigorously tell me a relationship between gene(s) and features.

You are demanding a standard of evidence that is beyond reason, do you not believe in evolution because there are gaps in the fossil knowledge? There is no reason you require to know every specific gene that influences height to determine that africans are genetically predisposed to be taller.

Not only can we deduce that genes play a predictive role in attributes like height and IQ through twin studies, but we have already begun to find genes that can predict physical attributes like height.

> exactly, its a made up category, i.e. not a real thing.

Category theory is made up, does that make it not real? Something that has no value whatsoever?

I really don't understand the argument, because you seem to believe race is subjective (even though we can prove it isn't based on what i previously said regarding cluster analysis) to the point it has 0 predictive value. Is that your argument?

> you can do the same thing for things like "hippie", "biker", "nerd" etc. it doesn't make those categories leave the intersubjective realm.

And guess what, we can make predictions based on this knowledge. We can say that a self proclaimed hippie is more likely to smoke weed than a self proclaimed Muslim or Christian. Do you believe we cannot do this?

Because if you believe we can do this with subjective social groups, I would say again based on the cluster analysis work i linked to previously, we can say that what people see as race almost perfectly corresponds to what a computer would sort them into based on purely genetics.

Race isn't some wavy concept where you have asians thinking of themselves as africans, or japanese thinking they are chinese. Sure you can point to exceptions but they are just that, not even 1% of the people in these studies when using more than just a dozen SNPs


The average "African" is not "predisposed to be taller" that is just a stereotype. Mainland Chinese people tend to be taller actually than the average West African.

Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_average_human_height_w...

African Americans on average are taller, but that is probably due to environmental differences and selection bias (slavery etc).

I would suspect mainland Chinese people are much taller than they used to be due to improvements to nutrition.


What are you talking about? Why is it then we can see that african americans are taller than asian americans? I would be pretty shocked if it turned out asian americans were more malnutrinted than african americans.

> African Americans on average are taller, but that is probably due to environmental differences and selection bias (slavery etc).

The papers I have seen don't really bear this out at all. Here is what the NHS says about it https://ghr.nlm.nih.gov/primer/traits/height

Right on the first line

> Scientists estimate that about 80 percent of an individual’s height is determined by the DNA sequence variants they have inherited,

That seems to back up what I'm saying.


I said African Americans are taller and that might be due to selection pressure (DNA) as well as environment (better diet, etc). My comment was not about Asian Americans at all. I was talking about Mainland Chinese in China, comparing Mainland Chinese to Africans in Africa given height data.

The comment I was responding to was that Africans are predisposed to being tall genetically, and my response to that is we do not have evidence of that given the data we have about these populations.


> The reason i'm speaking in probabilities is because that is what the facts are, that we have more variance within races than between.

thank you, exactly.

> africans are genetically predisposed to be taller.

"african" is not a category that has any meaningful genetic definition.

> genes play a predictive role in attributes like height and IQ through twin studies, but we have already begun to find genes that can predict physical attributes like height.

none of which means that "race" has any meaningful existence.

>Category theory is made up, does that make it not real? Something that has no value whatsoever?

it has value in organizing information. another system of organizing information might be harmful. suppose you had a system of organizing information that weighted irrelevant data and disregarded relevant data. would it have positive value or negative value?

> you seem to believe race is subjective

race is intersubjective, as is language and culture.

> to the point it has 0 predictive value

what are you trying to predict? either the trait that you select for when you delineate a sub-population is connected to the variable you predict, in that case you define the category by the specific trait, not some giant bag the size of a continent; or the trait you select for when you delineate the sub-population IS NOT connected to the variable you predict, so you're spouting nonsense. there is no third option.

> we can say that what people see as race almost perfectly corresponds to what a computer would sort them into based on purely genetics.

the computer is just doing what the programmer told it to do based on a bunch of genetic categories that are artificially constructed. you get a guy's genes. what makes you say that guy is asian? oh thats right, a hand wavy mix of phenotypes and culture. thats entirely objective, dont know what I was thinking.

> We can say that a self proclaimed hippie is more likely to smoke weed than a self proclaimed Muslim or Christian. Do you believe we cannot do this?

you're going to classify him as a hippie because he smokes weed and predict that he smokes weed based on the fact that he is a hippie. and you dont see the circularity?

> Race isn't some wavy concept where you have asians thinking of themselves as africans

actually it is much more fluid than you seem to think. parts of africa and asia are geographically close, and have mingled for millennia.

> Sure you can point to exceptions but they are just that, not even 1% of the people in these studies when using more than just a dozen SNPs

thats more an artifact of the limitations of your studies, if you know anything at all about this subject you should know just how genetically diverse the human species is.


> "african" is not a category that has any meaningful genetic definition.

If you want me to be specific, the negroid, is that specific enough for you? I assume not.

> it has value in organizing information. another system of organizing information might be harmful. suppose you had a system of organizing information that weighted irrelevant data and disregarded relevant data. would it have positive value or negative value?

Again, you haven't proved that race can't predict. You haven't even tried to disprove what im saying, you just keep banging on about this stupid aragument that "well what is the color orange? Is it red or is it yellow? or gold even?".

Should we throw away colors because someone might see a yellow and another sees gold? Are colors useless now?

> the computer is just doing what the programmer told it to do based on a bunch of genetic categories that are artificially constructed. you get a guy's genes. what makes you say that guy is asian? oh thats right, a hand wavy mix of phenotypes and culture. thats entirely objective, dont know what I was thinking.

So you agree that cluster analysis proves race can be objectively measured? Thanks.

> you're going to classify him as a hippie because he smokes weed and predict that he smokes weed based on the fact that he is a hippie. and you dont see the circularity?

No see you are just strawmanning, you know damn well I said self reported hippie and i was making a point about self reporting vs actions.

> actually it is much more fluid than you seem to think. parts of africa and asia are geographically close, and have mingled for millennia.

Ok but you agreed with the cluster analysis work i linked to that shows we can still put them into nice little groups with around 99% correctness so I don't see what legs you have left to stand on here.

> thats more an artifact of the limitations of your studies, if you know anything at all about this subject you should know just how genetically diverse the human species is.

The more SNP's the studies add the more clear the race picture is, how on earth could you get the opposite picture from the studies?

Are you even reading the studies or do you just assume they say what you believe? Because at this point your just strawmanning over and over and it's just not a productive conversation.


> the negroid

also lacking a meaningful definitinion.

> Again, you haven't proved that race can't predict.

actually I demonstrated that you are either using the trait you select for to predict itself (circular) or you use a trait to predict something its not related to (nonsense). there is no third option.

> So you agree that cluster analysis proves race can be objectively measured? Thanks.

you don't understand how that is impossible?

> self reported hippie

exactly, not a feature of objective reality.

> The more SNP's the studies add the more clear the race picture is, how on earth could you get the opposite picture from the studies?

because I understand the a priori nature of the modeling process.


> but so far the key points made in the book about the genetic existence of race have not even come close to being debunked.

Some would strongly disagree: https://www.theguardian.com/news/2018/mar/02/the-unwelcome-r...


I started reading that article a couple days ago and it's part of the reason why this subject as sparked with me. His article does a pretty pathetic job of trying to actually disprove anything about the science.

The way he smears Charles murray as if hes some closet white supremacists is just absurd if you actually have heard him speak or read his works.

Charles is one of the best example of someone who end up stumbling into the question on race and gets put on a fiery cross simply for not towing the line that race is purely a social construct.

It's a long read so I don't think you expect anyone to try and debunk it on the spot, so all i would suggest is people interested listen to the episode of Sam Harris's podcast with Charles and determine for yourself if Charles is just some shifty white supremacist neo nazi posing as a liberal or a scientist just trying to get to the bottom of uncomfortable truths.

https://samharris.org/podcasts/forbidden-knowledge/

If you really want a point by point rebut though, I know someone who did a video a couple days ago on the article https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IxCKQupwZQM


I listened to the audio for a bit but gave up after coming across multiple logical fallacies.

The fundamental point, though, is that given the large variability of both genetics and IQ (or most other traits, really) within those groups commonly called "races", and big overlap between them, the group label itself is almost always of little use.


I'm saying I can invent races on the fly, then find genetic differences that would appear to back me up. Is like playing numerology with a large enough book, you can always find patterns. Finding patterns however doesn't mean that black and white as racial qualifiers are anything other than a highly inaccurate classification system that is used to align skin colour with social class, and which doesn't even fall within the gamut of actual skin tone. Is patently obvious where black and white came from as concepts, if you look through history rather than biology.

While I do not expect to win this argument on nomenclature within the next fifty years, I do hold out some hope over the next century.

edit - Also, am British, the use of a sarcasm tag is offensive to our people. Probably for genetic reasons.


I think you need to read up on some the cluster analysis work that has been done over the last decade. Your statement about inventing races and assigning them to people isn't true.

I linked this in another comment but ill mention it again, this article makes a comprehensive argument for race while linking off to the supporting papers instead of just me shotgunning a bunch of papers at you.

http://thealternativehypothesis.org/index.php/2016/04/15/329...

Look under the heading "Genetic Clusteredness" and you find a summary of papers such as Bamshad 2003 which explain how they can conclude a strong correlation between self reported races and objective measured genetics via SNPs.


I hereby invent the race classifier of tongue-dexterity. Society consists of those who can and cannot roll their tongue and there is a high priesthood of the folks who can bend their tongue into a 'W'. It is just as arbitrary and capricious, but has at least one benefit I can think of over classifying people by latitude adaptation.


> Are you saying that there are none to little genetic/biological differences between different races?

That's pretty much what any geneticist says.


Unless you go to china, and suddenly we find pretty much 0 geneticists who would claim that races are just some arbitrary construct with no predictive value.

To roll it back to the west though, I have seen surveys like this of anthropologists which show no con:

https://sci-hub.hk/10.1111/j.1548-1433.2009.01076.x

Or this paper, in particular page 313 which show biologists with a 70% agreement with the question of “There are Biological Races Within the Species Homo Sapiens;”.

http://sci-hub.hk/10.1002/tea.3660290308



I linked these papers to someone else but it seems like you could use them. Both show absolutely no consensus by anthropologists on race and even a general acceptance of race among biologists:

https://sci-hub.hk/10.1111/j.1548-1433.2009.01076.x

http://sci-hub.hk/10.1002/tea.3660290308


The statement on race by that group was adopted in 1998, and is based on work from 1996-1997. That's at least 20 years of possible advancement in the field, unaccounted for.

'The paper above was adopted by the AAA Executive Board on May 17, 1998, as an official statement of AAA's position on "race."'


> Unless Uber itself is working on autonomous driving technology

https://www.uber.com/info/atg/


Uber will exhaust their runway prior to reaching a level of autonomy sufficient to replace drivers. Quote me in 3 years.


Don't look at me if you're expecting an argument :)


Uber's autonomous driving technology was at the core of the Waymo/Uber lawsuit/scandal. I'm a little surprised by how easily Google/Waymo gave up and accepted a settlement.


For me, the answer would be that in the midwest I have to work for 5-10 extra years. Marginal QoL improvement while doing my 40/wk is less important than accumulating enough to quit the grind.

I'd not do SFBA, but other coastal cities with less severe CoL differences pay substantially better than the midwest. You won't be house rich, but you'll be actually rich. And that equals retirement.


> the belt connecting UICU, Purdue, CMU, etc.

Look at the first destinations reports for those CS programs and you'll see what happens. People leave the region after getting the degree. In droves.


> According to the article, that is no longer the case

I think this thread is confusing "degree or equivalent knowledge" with "no really honest to god you don't need a degree".

Mid-tech is the latter. Consider the examples given in the article: "...computer systems analyst, computer network architects, and support specialist..."

The Midwest is not replete with jobs held by self-taught software engineers. It's replete with jobs (dubbed mid-tech) that don't require the self-teaching in the first place.


> It's replete with jobs (dubbed mid-tech) that don't require the self-teaching in the first place.

I worked in a job that seems to match the description of computer network architect in high school. It certainly required a fair amount of self-teaching (in my case; I suppose one could replace that with college or on-the-job instruction). Knowledge provided by a source of some kind was necessary. One is typically not born knowing how to do that type of work.

Does a job that does not require teaching (self or otherwise) even exist? I have family in the manufacturing business that I occasionally help out with when they are short-staffed as a favor. From the outside the job looks about as menial as it gets, but actually stepping in and helping leaves me appreciating what those people are capable of doing with the knowledge they have. There is no way, with my limited knowledge and ability in that industry, I'd be hired to work for them if they weren't desperate.

I farm on the side and that is the most intense ramp-up of knowledge requirements I have ever experienced. That experience has been like learning CS and software engineering, forgetting everything you learned, and repeating several more times. And still feeling like you don't know what you are doing. I've been farming for 10 years now and I still feel like a newbie. After 10 years of software development, while I recognized that there is still more to learn, I at least felt pretty confident in having progressed in my knowledge and abilities to a more advanced level. I don't know that anyone who claims farming requires a degree.

If degree here simply means requires an education of some kind, not specifically a degree from an accredited institution, then I'm not sure that there is a job out there that doesn't match that description in SV, the mid-west, or anywhere else. The only explanation here seems to be the expectations of employers, who trend towards setting more arbitrary expectations as the competition for the work increases. If you only have one applicant, you simply can't be choosy about who you hire.


> I worked in a job that seems to match the description of computer network architect in high school.

I worked a job like this in high school. Pretty sure I could've done it earlier, and learning the job was pretty easy. In contrast, I did some software work in high school as well and was out of my depth (thankfully it worked out).

> Does a job that does not require teaching (self or otherwise) even exist?

I guess it's a matter of degree.


> I guess it's a matter of degree.

Literally! But, jokes aside, how is that amount measured? Software development (which I also had a job doing during my time in high school) seemed quite approachable. I've certainly become a better developer over time (along with everything I've continued with), but I'm still proud of what I accomplished back then. I don't feel that it was out of my depth. I was able to deliver real business value and the employer was happy.

Honestly, I find software development has been one of the easier jobs (in terms of knowledge and ability required) that I have had. Granted, I haven't had jobs in every industry out there. I expect there are easier jobs. But software development does not strike me as one that meets the necessary degree here. If someone in high school can walk into the job and deliver real business value, it does not feel like a "degree required" job to me.

In my opinion, the defining factor here seems to be how desperate employers are. On the farm, we are often quite desperate for help. Timing is critical. Leave the crop out for an extra week and you won't have a crop at all. As such, farm work is considered low-skilled work since employers have no room to be choosy. You take what you can get and deal with what comes from it. It is still better than losing the crop.

Contrast that with software developers, where there is no real pressure to hire people. Who really cares if a feature sits in the backlog for a year? It will still be there next year. That allows employers to be more picky. Don't like your current applicants? Just wait longer. As such, this industry is labeled high-skilled work. If there is any pressure to get the job done, it comes from the competition trying to do the same as you, and they are just as likely to have hiring problems in those circumstances. In reality, the amount of actual skill necessary between these two examples is probably quite comparable.


> Software development seemed quite approachable... software development does not strike me as one that meets the necessary degree here

The job title "software developer" is almost meaningless in the context of this conversation given the extraordinarily high variance in what that job title actually entails.

The software development job I had in high school required knowing what for loops are and knowing how to google web shit. The technical content was almost non-existent. The difficult part of that type of job is managing relationships with customers, knowing how to estimate deadlines and working in a team. I would consider most web development a mid-tech job.

At my last software job, I used graduate-level mathematics almost every day. The "at my desk" hours of the day were 60% reading mathematics papers and 40% implementing that stuff. Along with all the soft skills, of course. 100% of the technical problems I faced were not a Google search away, because I was the first person solving those problems.

As far as BLS is concerned, those are the same jobs. Clearly, they are at two extremes of the "skills" spectrum. And the compensation is wildly different. And the availability of talent for these jobs is radically different. But BLS doesn't see that because the job title is the same. Hmph.

> where there is no real pressure to hire people

Again, a HUGE "it depends"!


> The "at my desk" hours of the day were 60% reading mathematics papers

Are you even appropriately labeled a software developer if that is how you spend the bulk of your time? I'm not convinced you are. The 40% definitely sounds like software development, but there are plenty of jobs where development is part of a larger job that are not given the software developer label. The farm, for instance, involves writing some software as a minor part of the job. It still gets the farming title, not software development.

And can we really classify a job where you literally spend most of your time learning how to do the job a "degree required" job? Degree required to me at least implies that you need to already know how to do the job before you are hired. The BLS provides this information to indicate what is needed to get a job. Anyone can read up on how to do something while they are already on the job.

> Again, a HUGE "it depends"!

There are always outliers. We have to be observing the typical or average case for this discussion to have any meaning.


> I'm not convinced you are.

We totally agree here -- these are two different jobs.

My point is that you can't tell that from the job title.

> And can we really classify a job where you literally spend most of your time learning how to do a job a "degree required" job?

Yes. There's a quantum leap between jobs where you're "learning on the job" trivial perturbations to things that hundreds of millions of other people already know and jobs where you're "learning on the job" stuff that no one / 10 other people know.

ALL jobs require learning on the job. Some jobs require you to learn stuff that's not possible to learn without already having a degree or two's worth of background knowledge. Some jobs require you to learn stuff any high schooler can learn. That is the difference between mid-tech and high-tech!

> There are always outliers. We have to be observing the typical or average case for this discussion to have any meaning.

Yes. And I'm pointing out that understanding that typical/average case is difficult for "Software Development" because the job title encompasses so many different types of jobs.


> My point is that you can't tell that from the job title.

Considering that you are not (primarily) a software developer, if you are being classified as a software developer in BLS data, the entire dataset is suspect. How many others are misclassified? What should we take from a dataset that is full of known inconsistencies?

> Some jobs require you to learn stuff that's not possible to learn without already having a degree or two's worth of background knowledge.

For instance? I'm honestly just curious about what you think is especially challenging. Everyone seems to have a different opinion about what this means.

> Some jobs require you to learn stuff any high schooler can learn. That is the difference between mid-tech and high-tech!

So do we agree that software development is, on average, mid-tech? And if so, why do we say it requires a degree? The software I was building in that after-school job in high school isn't a whole lot different to the dominant types of projects I see out there today. In my adult career, I've been involved with Silicon Valley startups to Fortune 500s and this seems to be the type of tech work that is most prevalent for software developers.

I'll agree that a small segment of the industry is working on the fringes, doing things that only 10 other people will encounter in their lifetimes. But this is not the typical case that the BLS is drawing their conclusions from. They are looking at the entire industry as a whole.


> For instance? I'm honestly just curious about what you think is especially challenging

Well, just look up active research labs at any top-tier university. Or peruse the work that's happening in top industry labs. And then realize that there are lots of groups within companies working on similar types of problems.

And then a lot of stuff that's not "research" but still demands lots of background in some field of science/engineering in order to avoid Bad Things. Designing the control software for a new power plant, for example.

> So do we agree that software development is, on average, mid-tech?

I'm not sure the question is even well-formed. It's like asking if "health-care" is mid-tech. Well, certain nurses certainly are. Neurosurgeons certainly aren't.

> The software I was building in that after-school job in high school isn't a whole lot different to the dominant types of projects I see out there today

TBF maybe you shouldn't have been building that software without a lot more training? Maybe the lack of seriousness in the software industry is fundamentally unethical. See Equifax.

As a high schooler I built software that interfaced with a database containing a shitload of social security numbers/dobs/names/addresses. I should not have been allowed to build public-facing interfaces to that database without oversight from a practiced software engineer.

> But this is not the typical case that the BLS is drawing their conclusions from. They are looking at the entire industry as a whole.

Well, yes, that's been exactly my point since the first post...


This is very true. Even after CoL adjustments, high-tech jobs in the midwest don't typically pay as well as the coasts. Especially in senior roles. Notice that this is especially true for the vast number of coastal-state cities that aren't SFBA [1].

However, this apt observation is not what the article is actually about. Mid-tech jobs are things like "...computer systems analyst, computer network architects, and support specialist...", which are very different jobs from software engineering.

[1] As an aside, CoL adjustments between the Midwest and coastal-state cities are extremely favorable to the Midwest in cases where you can actually afford to buy a house (read: not SFBA). If you buy a house in the midwest, you usually have to be okay with treating it as "not an investment". Whereas a house in Portland, Seattle etc. function as both a place to live as well as an investment likely to appreciate handsomely. Personally, I'm OK treating CoL as a sunk cost and not engaging in real estate speculation during my non-work hours. But from an objective perspective, the CoL pay cut suffered in MW cities is often unjustified given the opportunity cost of not living in an area with more and more predictable real estate appreciation. Selfishly, I wish folks in the Midwest had more success convincing their employers that "cheap land" is not a good justification for severely underpaying their labor force.


Have you taken a look at the real estate markets in Austin, Pittsburgh, or Raleigh?

"Buy low, sell high" is the adage of any savvy investor -- the markets in SF have been stagnant for years now.


> Austin, Pittsburgh, or Raleigh

My post was about the Midwest [1]. None of these are in the Midwest [2]. Except maybe Pittsburgh. Pittsburgh is technically not Midwestern because it's slightly more than a commute away from Ohio. But it's also actually not Midwestern because it's not a good prototype for a typical Midwestern city.

"The Midwest" does not mean "not the coast".

Also, all three of these are in the "coastal states" I'm contrasting with the Midwest.

> the markets in SF have been stagnant for years now.

Yes, I repeated some rendition of "except SF, which is uniquely terrible even among coastal places" many times in my post. And the problem with SF isn't lack of predictable appreciation. The problem with SF is that you can't afford to make the investment in the first place.

[1] https://ces4thgradewiki.wikispaces.com/Midwest+Region+of+the...

[2] PA and NC are mid-Atlantic and Texas is most certainly in the South.


This is the first time I have heard that SF housing market has been stagnant for years. I made 200k profit on my 600k house in East Bay in 2 years (sold in 2016). That house is up another 100k. So not sure what you are referring to here.


What? The median San Francisco house is up 6.8% between 2016 and 2017.


> the main argument for project-based learning is ability to make learning interesting

James already addresses this assertion in the very first sentence of the blog post. And the second sentence.


Which first sentence? The first sentence doesn’t have anything to do with that argument. Neither does the second.


The first two sentences EXPLICITLY state the type of arguments that James is responding to. Click on the links in those first two sentences and read the arguments.

The "main argument" of those posts -- i.e., the posts James is responding to, is not that "project-based learning... make[s] learning interesting".

That may be your main argument, but it's not the argument that the people who James is responding to are (mainly) making.


> they insist that the school you graduate from plays a crucial role and there is numerous benefits which out-do the benefits of attending a low-tier school

In the case of Berkeley and a few others, they are absolutely correct.

I've seen both sides of the unknown school / huge name brand divide.

It matters. A lot. It shouldn't, it's a shame, but it does.

In CS, you will turn out just fine either way. But it does matter.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: