Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more throwawayjava's commentslogin

I suppose if you consider The Onion fake news...


One of the sites I love to visit every few months is http://literallyunbelievable.org/ which has screen caps of people that don't know what The Onion is.


> Is expert opinion valuable even if it is right no more often than coin flipping?

Most coins are 50/50, not 75/25.

Also, the answer entirely depends upon whether there's anyone out there who can do better than 50/50.


Right. When "Enterprise" says "blockchain", what they mean is some combination of cryptography, an immutable database, and data/control/access/ownership flow logging. Sometimes also a financial product.

I think this word is now like "hacker" or "AI". It's not completely meaningless -- it does have a kinda-sorta fuzzy meaning. But that meaning is different from what techincal experts mean when using the term and is very much audience dependent.


It's not just scaling, but also speed.

If you sequentially attack a subpopulation (e.g., employees at a company, senior citizens) the eventually news about your attack will spread throughout that network (internal security alert, evening news+daily newspapers+AARP+...). If you attack the entire subpopulation in rapid succession over the course of days or even hours, educational countermeasures become much less effective.


> That's "wrongthink"--a view that seems obviously true to a certain set, only because they're not willing to think too hard about the situation.

That's extremely uncharitable. It's possible for people who disagree with you to have well-justified opinions. E.g., this comment:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17021747


> That's why the general internet ideal was no censorship until fairly recently.

I disagree.

To point out the obvious, the Santa Clara Principles are being published now. Not 20 years ago.

Going all the way back to BBSs, it was common for there to exist many forums with varying levels of moderator involvement. I never, ever saw the EFF complain about BBSs or web forums that moderated user content. Can you provide one example of EFF complaining about censorship on a private discussion website from the pre-Google/Facebook era? They were much more focused on the freedom to host one's own forum/BBS, and preventing the government from compelling a BBS/forum to go offline. They never took explicit issue with a forum owner's choice to censor.

So, actually, I think it's the other way around. Network effects in the eternal September have caused EFF et al. to adopt a new stance on censorship in very large communities. Actually, this is kind of obvious; otherwise, why weren't the Santa Clara Principles published 20 years ago and applied to BBS/forums/newgroups?

> It feels like a betrayal of the core principles of the US in particular and the hopes we had for the internet in general.

Again, I disagree. It was the eternal September that killed many hopes for the internet in general. Many were hopelessly optimistic about what it would mean to have "everyone" online. Everything else is just the natural progression from that initial disappointment.


> two Bayesian agents with a common prior can ensure that they agree to within ±ε about the value of a [0,1]-valued random variable, with probability at least 1-δ over their shared prior, by exchanging only O(1/(δε2)) bits of information—completely independent of how much knowledge the agents have. My conclusion was that, if Aumann’s Nobel-prizewinning theorem fails to demonstrate the irrationality of real-life disagreements, then it’s not for reasons of computational or communication efficiency

Under the gracious assumption that your agents are implementing a reasonable protocol for information exchange :)


You have to extend the Bayesian thought experiment to include agents not behaving rationally and cases of bounded information. And then go to multivariate models.

Combined, these give robust decision making methods. However, none of the above concerns actual hypothesis making which is biased from the get go.

Bayesian statistics cannot answer the question of how to build hypotheses, only maybe how to value them. Sometimes.

If we solve the question of how to make hypotheses reliably, then we might have some angle of attack on the strong AI problem.

Related problem is deciding ways to falsify statements - inverse Bayesian reasoning. That is, given posterior probability, figure out potential priors.


> If you can prove why x > y means y > z

...let x=2,y=1,z=1. Gotta be more specific on those quantifiers ;-)

More seriously, the issue is that "transitive causality", or whatever we want to call it, is sometimes not universally a good model of reality.

It's not really a fallacy. It's just a method of reasoning for which there exist errant applications, and therefore you should "use with caution".


> can you get sued and fined?

Generally not.

I found this blog post pretty helpful: https://takecareblog.com/blog/neo-nazis-wedding-cakes-and-co...

(Nit: anyone can be sued/fined for anything. The question is whether the plaintiff/gov't will win the resulting lawsuit.)


> YouTube can ban all homosexual videos from its platform so long as it doesn’t ban unrelated videos from homosexual people?

Yes (at least in states where sexual orientation is a protected class).

> Further are you saying the baker could refuse to sell them the cake they wanted because it had some gay theme ( two girl names I think) so long as they offered to sell them a Superman cake at the same time?

AFAIK this is not a settled issue.

I imagine a reasonable test might boil down to "If you have a policy that you never put names on cakes then you can refuse to write 'Jane and Jill'. But if you will write 'Jack and Jill' when asked, then you also need to write 'Jane and Jill' when asked."

In other words, the store may not have a policy that is functionally indistinguishable from refusing service to a protected class.

Notice that Google banning videos about homosexuality would definitely not be equivalent to banning homosexuals from using its public service.

This gets hairy; e.g., religion is a protected class. Could a Satanist cult compel a cake-making business owner to write down a disavowal of his God (in frosting)? Evaluating hairy edge-cases on a case-by-case basis are why human judges exist.

IANAL.


Every time I see that IANAL acronym, it's like this: iMac, iOS, iPhone, iAnal

TMI?


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: