Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more throwawayjava's commentslogin

Parent is referring to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hurry-up_offense

Another interesting thing: one major advantage of speed is actually slowing the game down.

E.g., if you move quickly between plays, you can catch the other team with too many men on the field during a substitution. in that case, you sometimes get a "free throw" (if the play works out, you decline the "too many players on field" penalty; but if the play doesn't work out or the other team intercepts the ball, you take the penalty and pretend like the failed play didn't even happen.

So you can actually increase the length of the game by moving quickly in-between plays...


> What a weird take this is. There's no need to look for monsters under the bed. The much simpler explanation is that arbitration interests are aligned between the State and businesses -- lower caseload for an already overworked court system, and lower costs for business. Since those are the groups with power in the situation, it is only logical that they would choose arbitration.

These two explanations aren't even contradictory unless the state is motivated by profit, which it clearly isn't, so your comment seems like a bit of a red herring.

Your comment makes an implicit assumption that the goal of the state ought to be maximizing its revenue to expenses ratio. Some (e.g., the writers of the US constitution and the bill of rights) believe the state's interests ought to be aligned with those of the underlying population.

When the goal of the state flips from "profit" to "maximize general welfare", it's no longer obvious that "decreasing court expenses" at the expense of "eroding consumer protections" is necessarily in the state's best interest.


The goal of the state doesn't have to be the profit of the state itself. It could be that those in charge of the government would have as their aim the profits of private companies, in which case lowering taxes on those companies would fall in line with that aim.


Internships work wonders here. No amount of coursework can substitute for doing the real thing. IMO internship placement, not coursework, will always be the best way to solve this problem.


Whenever it makes sense to ground research in practice, CMU professors generally do so by working with industry and govt collaborators. Many CMU CS professors also do some paid consulting on the side.

However, top tier PhD programs are not and never will be highly discounted consulting shops. At places like CMU grad students have perhaps more academic freedom than even their advisors. And good thing.

The day CMUs of the world become "Accenture with cheap student labor" is the day basic research dies.


What is evil about non-basic research?


Nothing. Why are you asking this here?


I've been a STEM field student and prof, and I've published some quite pure math research and also some AI research. My Ph.D. dissertation had its motivation from practice, e.g., from when I was Director of Operations Research at FedEx, and was an early case of what is now a major theme of the Department of Operations Research and Financial Engineering (ORFE) at Princeton. And since my Ph.D., I've made practical applications of math where the key was some relatively pure math research. Moreover, the crucial core of my intended to be fully practical startup is some applied math with some advanced pure math prerequisites.

So, my experience is that what I suggested is not a danger but motivation and stimulation of a lot in pure research.

Having some students do some work with people from outside academics is crucial for their professional development. Of course the work will have graduate student and faculty supervision and high quality. The students should welcome the business world contacts.

There is a lot of the very best pure medical research in labs not far from the wards with dying patients. In important senses, that there are real patients there with their lives literally depending on the results of the research helps both the patients and the research.

It is very much a fact of life in life, applications, and also pure research that a lot of good motivation is from good to excellent. In particular in research, for the younger researchers, finding good problems to work on is one of their most severe struggles. Well, in medicine, a young physician in a research-teaching hospital everyday can see, does see, patients dying in the wards, and that work can help the researcher find good problems to work on.

For your

> Whenever it makes sense to ground research in practice, CMU professors generally do so by working with industry and govt collaborators.

"Whenever", quite commonly and generally and no exceptions? Amazing. I'm thrilled. Good for CMU. Since one of my Ph.D. dissertation advisors was long President at CMU, maybe he was in part responsible for this amazing, thrilling situation?

Color me skeptical: My long experience in and around research tells me that pure research needs much more contact with and stimulation and motivation from practice. Yes, some pure researchers have found really good pure research problems and directions, and, then, they should continue on, but much more common is what I explained, using practical problems as motivation and stimulation, and justification, for research that might be, in my experience often can become, nicely general and pure. Or, if the research is all just routine, then pass the problem off to a ugrad for a class exercise, term paper, or senior honors paper. Else push forward for better results and encounter some real research problems.

Here is a big example: During WWII, G. Dantzig was working on military logistics, e.g., what to ship where, how, when to aid the war effort. After the war, at RAND for, IIRC, the USAF, he continued and as a first cut invented linear programming. About then a special case of that, for the transportation, problem, the "translocation of masses" resulted in a Nobel prize in economics for L. Kantorovich. So, linear programming was already making progress enough in pure research to yield a Nobel prize in economics. And there were some more Nobel prizes from linear programming and optimization.

To solve linear programming problems, Dantzig invented his simplex algorithm, basically a nice tweak on Gauss elimination for systems of linear equations. Cute. Not very pure but at one time rated as one of the most important pieces of work in engineering of the 20th century. In practice, nearly always it is shockingly fast, and it took some nice work decades later in some relatively pure math of computational geometry (K. Borgwardt) to show why it was so fast.

Continuing on, soon enough it was observed that, often in practice, it was required that the variables be restricted to whole number values. That is, the real, practical problems were often integer linear programming (ILP). IIRC, first cut, Dantzig expected that a tweak of his simplex algorithm would be able to handle that.

Work on ILP continued, for decades. There were lots of important practical problems for motivation, e.g., network design at Bell Labs. That problem has remained important, e.g., was the subject of an A. Goldman lecture at Johns Hopkins by MIT Dean of Science T. Magnanti. And there was progress on solutions.

ILP was taken seriously by, okay, Princeton grad R. Gomory.

By then computer science had discovered the problem of sorting, saw that simple bubble sort ran in O(n^2) but that heap sort ran in worst case and average case O(n ln(n)) and met the Gleason bound and, thus, was in the sense of big-O the fastest possible sorting algorithm for sorting just by comparing pairs of keys. So, this was progress in computational time complexity. Since heap sort is also in-place, it was also progress in computational space complexity.

So, with both the practical successes and the struggles of ILP and the practical success of the simplex algorithm and the specter of O( e^n ) for ILP, there was the serious research question of what would be the fastest algorithm in worst case for ILP. This question was asked and explored at Bell Labs and resulted in the now famous

Michael R. Garey and David S. Johnson, Computers and Intractability: A Guide to the Theory of NP-Completeness, ISBN 0-7167-1045-5, W. H. Freeman, San Francisco, 1979.

So, from there ILP is, yes, in NP-complete.

So, now we have at Clay Math in Boston a prize of $1 million for the first solution of the problem in computational time complexity of P versus NP, generally considered one of the most important problems in both pure and applied math and computer science.

Lesson: Practical problems, taken seriously, can result in some of the most important problems in pure research, and some of the progress in pure research can help get solutions to some practical problems. The motivation from pressing practical problems can help drive the research in both pure and applied research.

In particular, the OP was about CMU, CS, and AI. From what I've seen and heard about AI, a lot of what is of interest now, and likely a big part of the CMU AI ugrad program, is "modern regression analysis". Maybe CS and AI need modern here because otherwise they are open to accusations of reinventing and pushing out a lot of hype about some multivariate statistics quite mature as math 50+ years ago.

If CMU CS and AI are willing to take regression so seriously, also going for some of what I mentioned, e.g., convex programming, stochastic optimal control, should be regarded as much more worthy. Making stochastic optimal control more practical is one heck of a challenge but with some progress possible, e.g., as now at the ORFE Department at Princeton.

And we should note that much of the AI interest in regression is based on the work of L. Breiman in Classification and Regression Trees (CART). Breiman was, IIRC "an academic probabilist"; his text Probability (one of my favorites, e.g., for measurable selection) was all based heavily on measure theory; and his work on CART started by trying to get fits and predictive models starting with complicated data from clinical medicine. So, here again, some pressing practical problems in practical medicine led Breiman to CART which is now one of the main pillars of AI. Given that background, the CMU CS AI program should welcome the level of contact with real problems I described without your concern about the death of pure research.


> Lesson: Practical problems, taken seriously, can result in some of the most important problems in pure research, and some of the progress in pure research can help get solutions to some practical problems. The motivation from pressing practical problems can help drive the research in both pure and applied research.

I'm pretty sure I explicitly agreed that this is often the case in my original post, so we must be talking past one another :)

What I'm arguing for is basically just academic freedom: the freedom of faculty and students to make choices about where they should resarch agenda. As your extensive history demonstrates, THIS APPROACH WORKS! All of those people chose to engage with industrial because it made sense for their research agenda!

More importantly, we can come up with an equally lengthy wall of text detailing accomplishments that would not have been possible without the freedom to work on things that industry isn't all hot and bothered about. E.g., neural nets until about 5 years ago!

And an even lengthier wall of text describing silly research agendas that only existed because of industry hype (AOP anyone?)

Industry collaboration can be a tremendous impetus. However, it can also be a distraction from more important problems or even an impetus to focus on silly problems. Professors and students should be incentivized and encouraged to do good research; industrial collaboration can sometimes be a useful tool, but it is a means, not an end.

Finally, IMO, the central premise of your argument (that there's not enough collaboration) is not factually accurate in the current climate. Read the proceeds of any major AI conference. Filter out papers written at top universities. Count the number of papers with vs. without an industrial collaborator named in the acks or even in the author list. Failure to collaborate isn't a failing of modern mainstream AI research.


I never tried to constrain "freedom" in research. Freedom in research is crucial: With a good researcher, often only they have a good sense of the promise of their research direction. And, they are the one making a bet: If their research is soon good, then, modulo academic politics, they make progress in their academic career, e.g., maybe get to upgrade their 20 year old used Mazda to a 10 year old used Toyota and celebrate with a toast of tap water!!!

If current academic AI research is too close to non-academic problems, okay, I can believe that but see little downside since I have no respect for 90+% of current AI work anyway.

Net, contact with non-academic problems is crucial for STEM fields but with bad work can be abused. Of course it can be abused, special case of the general situation that nearly anything can be abused.

I spent a lot of time in STEM field academics: My considered, solid, well informed opinion is that there is far too little contact with important non-academic problems. E.g., when I went from Director of Operations Research at FedEx to graduate school in applied math, I brought with me a nice collection of important practical problems. In casual conversations, as I described some of those problems, even very pure research profs took detailed notes furiously. When I was an applied math prof in a B-school and MBA program, there were nearly no people from business in the halls with pressing problems looking for solutions, and that situation was really bad for the the business people, the students, the faculty, faculty research, and the B-school.

The suspicion has to be strong that if a research-teaching hospital were run like a B-school, then the physicians and researchers would be off studying the possibilities of silicon-based life on the planet Faraway, no one would know even how to dress a skinned knee, there would be no progress on any of the major, pressing medical problems, e.g., heart disease, cancer, and no one would want to go to a hospital no matter how badly they hurt.


> I never tried to constrain "freedom" in research. Freedom in research is crucial

Well then, I think we're violently agreeing. However, a couple of observations.

> e.g., maybe get to upgrade their 20 year old used Mazda to a 10 year old used Toyota and celebrate with a toast of tap water!!!

Here is CMU's dean on what happens to faculty with successful AI/ML research agendas: "How to retain people who are worth tens of millions of dollars to other organizations is causing my few remaining hairs to fall out".

I didn't realize how expensive used Toyotas have gotten...

>...applied math

I'll again reiterate that CS and especially AI have a completely different culture.

Also, this sentence seems to somehow undermine your entire thesis:

> If current academic AI research is too close to non-academic problems, okay, I can believe that but see little downside since I have no respect for 90+% of current AI work anyway.


> A tricky part of this would be how to balance letting the network have control over itself and letting the government have some special degree of input on ‘monetary policy’. It’s certainly ok for the government to have some, but I think the network needs to be mostly in charge (e.g., the government couldn’t be allowed to arbitrarily inflate the currency when it wanted to).

This is a partially direct democracy (for monetary policy) using digital voting with no paper trail! Unless there are crap load of formal methods backing this, it sounds like a recipe for disaster.

(Also, if this is the problem to be solved, why don't we just pass a constitutional amendment requiring a referendum for certain changes to monetary policy...)

> The government can likely create a lot of de novo wealth for its citizens in the process.

The thing that always confuses me: where is the fundamental value creation? I don't see much other than maybe saving on some inefficiencies in the current monetary/financial system. But that's not "de novo wealth"; that's "financial engineering".

How does a state-backed cryptocurrency generate "de novo wealth"?


I think parent's point is that by searching for a double-crux you might obfuscate high-level generators of disagreement, so the conversation might progress but won't actually change anyone's mind even if there is a purely factual answer to the double-crus.

I think parent's point is made later in the paragraph after the section on double-cruxing:

> High-level generators of disagreement are what remains when everyone understands exactly what’s being argued, and agrees on what all the evidence says, but have vague and hard-to-define reasons for disagreeing anyway. In retrospect, these are probably why the disagreement arose in the first place, with a lot of the more specific points being downstream of them and kind of made-up justifications. These are almost impossible to resolve even in principle.

I.e., many people who have strong opinions on gun control would never agree to this sort of double-crux. And even if they did agree to it in the context of one conversation, and then "lost" the argument on that basis, they wouldn't actually go on to change their mind. They would return to the "High-level generator" and everyone just wasted their time.


The way I understand it, double-cruxing is a technique to be used (probably multiple times) during the debate, and isn't the entire debate itself. It kind of reminds me of "divide and conquer" strategies.


I think it's useful to differentiate between "arguments" and "debates". An "argument" is a meeting of the minds, grounded in mutual respect, in which each side has an opposing a priori belief that they might be willing to change. A "debate" is a zero-sum game in which each person arguing is trying to change the mind of some third party^1. People often call interactions "arguments" when, in fact, they are actually "debates".

Doubele-cruxing can be useful in arguments, but the audience of a debate should approach any crux with incredulity. Anyone with half a mind toward "winning" a double-cruxed debate would choose an untenable position as their "crux". A practiced debater will find the scientific concensus and then work backwards to a crux. Not the other way around. Then they get the rhetorical benefits of acting "reasonable" without actually giving up anything useful to their opponent. In fact, if their opponent is clueless enough to accept the crux, they've just won the game. And if their opponent complains, well now the opponent is "meta-debating" which is apparently bad thing (and is a bad thing anyways because it makes you sound like an egghead).

So, double-cruxing is a great strategy for an argument between people who mutually respect one another. But audiences to a debate should be careful about whether they're being hood-winked by a rhetorical trick.

In short, a lot of this philosophizing about how to have a good argument really just boils down to "have the right argument with the right person". Two people who respect each other talking about something that both have fluid opinions on rarely devolves into a useless conversation.

--

^1: A debate in which there's no third party present might be called "a waste of time".


> So, double-cruxing is a great strategy for an argument between people who mutually respect one another.

That's a good point. The guide on double-cruxing[1] lists "epistemic humility" and "good faith" as pre-requisites for using the technique effectively.

[1] http://rationality.org/resources/updates/2016/double-crux


I dislike double cruxing along the lines of debating as a sport too, but I disagree that what you describe in the second half of your comment is a problem, in fact people should be encouraged to do what you describe.

The "double" part of double crux means that the crux you choose has to be a crux for both people, i.e. if it's established either way, that alone has to be sufficient to convince both people of the overall argument being true or false.

If you pick a crux that is a truly provably untenable position, and it turns out to also be a crux for the other person then they should happily change their mind on seeing the proof. If they don't it's not like they're committed to saying you've "won" against their will or anything, at worst it turns out that the crux they agreed on wasn't really a crux for them after all. At best, they discover that their belief rested on an untenable position.

By design it's pretty hard for a malicious actor to play double crux to win without also playing it to discover the truth, so long as they actually choose honest cruxes for themselves (and to some extent, even if they don't).


I'm unconvinced.

The rhetorical trick is to paint the opponent as unreasonable, pretentious, impractical, etc. if they don't agree with your double-crux. In this case, the resolution of the double-crux is not the strong argument (your opponent would never willinging agree to the double-crux)! The rhetorical characterization of your opponent is the strong argument. Again, it's just something you should watch out for as an audience member.

Also, inexperienced debaters will often agree to double-cruxes when they shouldn't because they don't understand the strategy that's being deployed agains them and the double-crux is presented in a "friendly" tone. And once it's deployed they realie that was a stupid thing to agree to. The truth we've discovered is that one of the debaters is inexperienced; we haven't learned anything about the underlying topic.

In practice, debates (acdaemic or out in the real world) are almost never searches for truth.

Again, as an audience member in an obviously zero-sum debate, I'm extremely skeptical of the double-crux. It's usually a steup for a rhetorical argument or a way of easily beating down an inexperienced person. It's rarely a geniune assertion that this one thing really is the fundamental point of contention.

In a friendly, respectful argument designed to search for truth, double-cruxes can be a great tool.


> Again, as an audience member in an obviously zero-sum debate, I'm extremely skeptical of the double-crux.

For some context, double-cruxing came out of the rationalist community (specifically CFAR), which commonly refers to persuasive rhetoric as the dark arts. They do not develop tools for use in the dark arts.


> The stream is LOSSLESS.

I think the word 'archival' is the key word in this sentence:

>> A losslessly-encoded stream is near-worthless compared to a lossless rip, which is actually useful as archival material.

GP isn't comparing on the basis of quality; rather, GP is pointing out that streaming services don't function as an "archive".

It's a reasonable point. Modulo reasonable backup procedure, owning a copy of the track is a more robust as an "archive" than a streaming service that might stop serving the track at any moment.

However, I'm confused by the rest of GP's post. First, I'm not sure why pirating is necessary to get a lossless rip. Second, and perhaps tangentially, I've never understood collectors (of cards, or of coins, or of music tracks).


> First, I'm not sure why pirating is necessary to get a lossless rip.

To rip an SACD, you either need a hacked PS3, or you need to download the rip through a torrent kindly provided by a pirate community member who does have a hacked PS3.

If you signed up for a pirate community to download those SACD rips, you might as well stick around and torrent lots of ordinary CD rips so that you don’t actually have to buy those CDs.

> Second, and perhaps tangentially, I've never understood collectors

I travel a lot, including in countries where mobile data is not cheap and wifi is thin on the ground. It’s nice to have my entire music collection with me on a small portable hard drive.

Secondly, film collectors are inclined to collect, not stream, because they have been bitten by films disappearing from release due to rights issues. Look at how many Criterion Collection releases are no longer available to purchase or stream, for instance, but it’s nice to have your own copy saved on a disk.


Artists upload lossless audio to the internet all the time. I don't understand how anybody can even be bothered to argue their opinion on this matter. A lot of you guys sound like jerks though.


> Artists upload lossless audio to the internet all the time.

It can, in fact, be quite difficult to obtain the 5.1 surround sound layer of an SACD as a digital download for many releases. That is why people are inclined to rip the SACD or torrent someone else’s rip.


>>If people use it to flake a lot, I could see businesses just not responding to the assistant.

>Then it sounds like incentives are aligned here. Google needs to not allow users to abuse this ability so that businesses will trust and not block them.

But then they can't take bookings through google assistant, which is going to lose non-trvial amounts of business.

Seems far more likely that they'd pay Google to automatically handle duplex calls for them.

The worse this technology turns out for businesses, the more pressure there is to pay google money.


>But then they can't take bookings through google assistant, which is going to lose non-trvial amounts of business.

If it's costing more money than it's bringing in, then it's no longer worth it. If it's bringing in more money than it costs, then it's a good thing for the business.

If a business needs to hire a dedicated phone person because they are getting so many appointments filled, they aren't going to be upset. But if they get so many flakers that won't show up, they are losing money as customers that will show up are getting pushed out, so they will block Duplex. There are also other ways to solve this problem, require a phone number and name and block or charge people for missed appointments if they try to reschedule. Require some kind of down-payment over the phone when making the appointment. There are tons of solutions to this problem.

At no point is "Pay google to handle the calls" an option. This is really only for places that don't have an online appointment system (that possibly integrates into google), so the solution to the duplex calls would be to invest in one. Since "pay google to handle duplex" would look a lot like an API to a scheduling system anyway, and an independent one (with integrations into Google's systems) would reach more customers.


Google may not be making money from direct payments from businesses, but getting access to yet another aspect of the life of their users (in this case, appointments made with what business and when), would be invaluable to them.

Just one more way that big business is taking over our lives. The world is becoming incredibly scary.


> or for some other logistical reason

The development of a system of airports (+ new planes that could fly trans-oceanic flights without stop-overs in far-flung locations).


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: