Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more throwawayjava's commentslogin

> I think it's absolutely morally repugnant to walk past them and not give them money, because instead you're paying people to sit around thinking about AI.

This is not a new argument. Sister Mary Jucunda, a Zambian nun, wrote to a NASA scientist (Ernst Stuhlinger) in the early 70's with a similar critique of funding for space research.

You can read Ernst's cogent reply here: http://www.lettersofnote.com/2012/08/why-explore-space.html

My favorite excerpt follows:

> About 400 years ago, there lived a count in a small town in Germany. He was one of the benign counts, and he gave a large part of his income to the poor in his town. This was much appreciated, because poverty was abundant during medieval times, and there were epidemics of the plague which ravaged the country frequently. One day, the count met a strange man. He had a workbench and little laboratory in his house, and he labored hard during the daytime so that he could afford a few hours every evening to work in his laboratory. He ground small lenses from pieces of glass; he mounted the lenses in tubes, and he used these gadgets to look at very small objects. The count was particularly fascinated by the tiny creatures that could be observed with the strong magnification, and which he had never seen before. He invited the man to move with his laboratory to the castle, to become a member of the count's household, and to devote henceforth all his time to the development and perfection of his optical gadgets as a special employee of the count.

> The townspeople, however, became angry when they realized that the count was wasting his money, as they thought, on a stunt without purpose. "We are suffering from this plague," they said, "while he is paying that man for a useless hobby!" But the count remained firm. "I give you as much as I can afford," he said, "but I will also support this man and his work, because I know that someday something will come out of it!"

> Indeed, something very good came out of this work, and also out of similar work done by others at other places: the microscope. It is well known that the microscope has contributed more than any other invention to the progress of medicine, and that the elimination of the plague and many other contagious diseases from most parts of the world is largely a result of studies which the microscope made possible.

I think there are many parallels between AI/ML and the microscope, and I think safety research is a very reasonable inquisitive lens for developing these new technologies.


Well, fighting poverty also grows the economy and number of brains available for research in the future. Today we are bringing people out of poverty for good, much charity isn't money in a bottomless pit.

The pit has a bottom as evident by the very realistic goal to end extreme poverty by 2030.

Still basic research is important, because it has such a long tail. Just saying both approaches have validity and will bring massive progress.


I certainly won't argue with that! We should be spending much more money on poverty reduction than on basic science.


That's a rather condescending reply, lecturing her like a schoolchild. Funding space research is one thing, but spending $billions on poor designs like the Shuttle is another and on expensive American lifestyles is another.


> That's a rather condescending reply

The reply begins with a sincere "...First, however, I would like to express my great admiration for you...".

The denoted intent of the letter is certainly not condescending.

Perhaps the content is what makes the letter condescending? The letter, if written today, might come off as condescending. It states many obvious truths, such as the observation that space development provides valuable tools to Zambian nuns. Today, this is obvious [1], and to point out such obvious facts to an expert borders on condescension.

But GPS wasn't at all an obvious implication of NASA funding in 1970!

If the letter comes off as condescending today, it's only because time (and science funding) has turned the impossible into the pedestrian.

[1] http://www.slate.com/articles/technology/future_tense/2011/0...


Not remotely applicable.

For one, so far everyone predicting doom about AI has been a layman a subject. Maybe you aren't aware, but this is a field that people do PhDs and get professorships in. Noone respected agrees with the doom-sayers.


> For one, so far everyone predicting doom about AI has been a layman a subject.

This is a myth. It was arguably true 5-10 years ago, but concern with AI safety is not a fringe position even among the highest levels of AI researchers now.

Stuart Russel (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stuart_J._Russell) is the co-author of one of the most popular AI textbooks in the world and he has repeatedly said that he thinks the alignment problem is important and that AI presents an existential risk: https://www.technologyreview.com/s/602776/yes-we-are-worried... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WvmeTaFc_Qw

Marcus Hutter (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marcus_Hutter) is another respected AI researcher who, along with, Tom Everitt (http://www.tomeveritt.se/) (a researcher at DeepMind, one of the most advanced AI companies in the world), is also working on the alignment problem: http://www.tomeveritt.se/papers/alignment.pdf

You can read through list of grants granted by the Future of Life institute for AI Safety research, almost all of which are to researchers associated with respected universities, not laymen, here: https://futureoflife.org/ai-safety-research/


> Maybe you aren't aware, but this is a field that people do PhDs and get professorships in.

I'm aware of my own existence, thanks ;-)

> Noone respected agrees with the doom-sayers

But many, many, many respected AI researchers (who I've talked to about this) certainly do agree that AI/ML safety/robustness are important topics of inquiry.

Including researchers at all the top CS departments, at Deepmind, at OpenAI, etc.

Consider critiquing the concrete projects that are funded with AI safety money. Very little of that money flows to research about "preventing malicious superintelligence" or whatever strawman you have in mind. And even projects that consider those questions also consider many much more near-term AI safety questions.


There is a difference between AI/ML safety/robustness (as in ensuring self driving cars don't behave erratically given unexpected inputs), and the skynet predictions.

> Consider critiquing the concrete projects that are funded with AI safety money. Very little of that money flows to research about "preventing malicious superintelligence" or whatever strawman you have in mind. And even projects that consider those questions also consider many much more near-term AI safety questions.

But this ("preventing malicious superintelligence") is EXACTLY what we are talking about. The comment in the OP was quoting the following

> Grants will likely go to organizations that seek to reduce global catastrophic risks, especially those relating to advanced artificial intelligence.


> Walmart, I think, would probably be doing better by their employees if they offered a more traditional tuition reimbursement plan

By cutting deals with a few institutions and offering mostly online programming, Walmart can keep prices way down. I suspect they do it this way because the equivalent value of the tuition reimbursement would be way too low for any of their low-level employees to actually afford the education.


in California, community college tuition is on the order of a grand a year, full time (in state) - less if you are only going part time, which you probably would be, if you're working enough hours to get the walmart reimbursement.

At those rates, the expensive part is the time off work, even when you are only making $11/hr. (I mean, employer reimbursement is still a nice gesture, every little bit counts.)

I find it... unlikely that the private universities are cheaper than the community colleges.

Now, your last two years, at a state school, in California are closer to six or seven grand a year, full time, so half that for your half-time plan, and that's a much bigger bite, but I still kinda wonder what kind of private school could do cheaper, though we're getting more realistic.

In California, at least, if you go to any of our very good public schools, you will almost certainly be paying more just to keep yourself alive than you will be paying in tuition

(which isn't to say I don't think we should subsidize them more; I'm just saying that most of the cost of going to california public schools is... living in California.)


But this is for college tuition, not community college tuition, and California is very much the outlier. Also, this focuses on particular areas of need for Walmart:

> Walmart will pay only for degrees in business and supply-chain management because those areas of study “will be relevant across the industry and for future work opportunities,” according to spokeswoman Erica Jones.

They also cover books and supplies, which I imagine would be way more expensive without a single standardized curriculum across all of their employees.


I think community college in California is the best chance working adults have of getting into prestigious schools. My understanding is that you have a significantly better chance of getting into an undergrad program at Berkeley from community college than even the better California state colleges.

Really, the options for working adults are mostly geared towards the remedial. Community college is one of the few options available to someone like me to get back on the prestigious school track.


> Walmart is cheaper on many things

Caveat: only if you need a car anyways. If you only need a car to run errands, Amazon is pretty competitive for pretty much anything except fresh groceries.


In other words if you live anywhere in the country outside of a couple of cities.


That's probably a bit of an exaggeration but I daresay that there are very few people who own a car solely to run errands today. If I need to own a car to run errands, I probably need a car for other reasons too.

What is true is that there are people who live in cities and use Zipcar, Uber, regular rentals, etc. instead of owning. If that's the case, the cost calculus changes if you need to pay in order to run errands.


It's not. The amount of places where you can get by without having your own car is pretty small in this country.


I honestly don't think anyone who doesn't live in the center of a city everyone's heard of uses a service like Zipcar, but sure, if you need to rent a car to go Walmart looks less attractive. If you need to rent a car to go you also probably don't live near a Walmart, which as far as I know has abandoned the urban concept and decided to stick with their rural/suburban box store.


I'd put the number closer to 100. All states have at least one metro area with good enough transit, and most have either two larger metros or at least one good-sized college town.

I'm not sure which "couple of cities" you're thinking of, but I'm pretty sure I haven't lived in either of them. And even when I've owned a car, I've never used a car day-to-day.


This has not been my experience.

I live (barely) inside the city limits of a town of 13,000 people, in a county of 37,000. My wife and I both have vehicles and we use both of them probably 80% of days - and I work remotely to boot.


"A couple of" cities was not meant to mean two, but 100 sounds like too many, and even if you live in the best-served metro areas, the service is usually limited to a small portion of it.


I agree with that. There's one US city where it's completely normal and ordinary not to own a car. There are maybe a dozen others where, if you live and work in a relatively central area of the city, you can probably get by without one without too much hardship. Go much beyond that and you may be able to get off without one but a lot of things get harder and you have to compromise on your activities.


18 cities have >25% households without a car. 8-9% of households lack cars.

http://www.governing.com/gov-data/car-ownership-numbers-of-v...


Yes, much less than 100 cities. I live in the Phoenix area, and can't imagine how hard it would be without a car. It's so spread out that it isn't funny. I have a car mostly because I like driving, but still would have one if I didn't, just not the same kind of car.


I also feel like a certain number of those people are carless not by choice but because they cannot afford a car, and are putting up with a pretty extreme level of inconvenience.


I will tell you that South Dakota absolutely does not have that, and unless you're in the dorms of one of the schools and can bum a ride with someone who's already going, a car is required.


> Academic journals don't result in any value creation for society

Journals do provide some value. Editing, printing, and herding academics through the camera-ready process all require non-trivial effort.

I would have absolutely no problem with a handful of universities/non-profits/even for-profits devoting some staff to the curation/archival process. And also no problem with those organizations charging others modest fees to fund that work.

The problem with journals is that they capture a lot more value than they provide, that value is not distributed back to the people doing the actual work, and the prestige signal/branding provides a strong moat.

I REALLY think this is an important point. If we continue to behave like all of this stuff is trivial and obvious to replicate, then we'll be forever stuck with predatory journals like Nature.


There is no one answer. The answer will change drastically depending on the sort of research you're doing, and your role in that research.

Are you a mathematician simulating a dynamical system? A theoretical computer scientist exploring the effects of parameters that are difficult to nail down analytically?

Are you a computer scientist working on a new sort of system? Is the point of that system to support a long-running research agenda, or to demonstrate the feasibility of a general notion/idea?

Or are you a software engineer supporting a natural scientist (e.g., in a large bio/neuro/chem/physics lab)?

Are you the PhD student, the research scientist, the supporting engineer, or the PI?

But in any case, the correct answer will start with interrogating the purpose/role of the software in your research project. And that answer could range from "hack out the MATLAB and sanity check" all the way to "lives are on the line; practice extreme rigor". And certainly not excluding "convince your funding agency/PI that it's time to hire a professional"!


> Who "just has money" and doesn't control capital?

1. The vast majority of middle class wealth is locked up in (non-investment) housing. That money provides a roof and access to quality education, but in almost all cases, it's not being efficiently deployed as capital.

2. Whatever remaining money that is deployed as capital, is not done so in a way that implies control over their chosen investments. Think "majority shareholder" vs. "just another investor". That's the difference between "controlling capital" and merely having a bit of skin in the game.


> The vast majority of middle class wealth is locked up in (non-investment) housing.

There are literally 0 people I know who think owning a house is not an investment.

If you're trying to make a distinction between income generating assets and assets that don't generate income, you're just digging yourself into a hole - housing doesn't generate income, but it does save cost - namely rental cost. In that sense, it is a better investment because the return is less risky.

> 2. Whatever remaining money that is deployed as capital, is not done so in a way that implies control over their chosen investments. Think "majority shareholder" vs. "just another investor". That's the difference between "controlling capital" and merely having a bit of skin in the game.

That's well and good, but it's just as true for most people above the 10% line as for those below. You have to get to some truly lofty heights before you find the activist investors.


> There are literally 0 people I know who think owning a house is not an investment.

I thought of my house as a "use asset", like a car. It's nice when the house appreciates. But I couldn't sell it and "cash out" if I had to use the proceeds to buy another house. But, as you said, it saved on rental costs.


Owning a house is an intergenerational investment -- your kids can sell it and make a tidy unearned profit on what you spent, or live in it and pocket that amount of money in not having to pay for another living arrangement. It contributes to the high IGE of the US the author was talking about.


> You have to get to some truly lofty heights before you find the activist investors.

That was exactly the point the GP was trying to make...


> I think you're being too harsh. Lots of marginal students are encouraged to go to college

Notice that "don't go to college if you're going to drop out" is NOT the article's fundamental claim.

That piece of advice would be above the author's criticism. But it also wouldn't get a single upvote, let alone make the front page, because it's prime facie obvious.


Checking in from an old auto town. Our region is exactly the opposite of yours. We are saturated with jobless gear-heads but there's HUGE demand in healthcare.

Shop techs around here make ~$10-15/hr, aren't guaranteed 40, no benefits, never get overtime, and there's no upward mobility unless you start your own shop (which for almost everyone requires taking out a big loan, and most attempts flop). Finding work is easy, but you can do MUCH better in the service industry or in healthcare. Hell, I have a relative who breeds dogs because it pays better than the auto work he can find after his last attempt at opening his own shop failed.

But the hospitals are starving! With a Bio grad degree, the hospitals would pay you to get into nursing. From there, with the degree, it's easy to get into a PA program. And there's insatiable demand for PAs.

> You wouldnt believe how many trades pay close to six figures that are incredibly understaffed

My general observation, at least in our region, is that six figures are a high water mark, not an average. Six figures for the last ten years is A LOT different from six figures for all thirty years. And even the last 10 years is wishful thinking. But again, the recently closed factory might've put a huge downward pressure on salaries throughout the trades in our region.

I think that "trades are the answer" is just as stupid as "college is the answer". Inserting "community" into "just go to college" doesn't change the fundamental problem with the advice, which is that it's suggesting a global heuristic for a problem that has varying solutions from region to region and especially from person to person.

It's not about "trades vs. white collar". It's all about knowing the (regional) labor market.


> It is sometimes, but there are plenty of jobs that require highschool level skills but will filter out those who don't have a degree just because they can.

There's also "the minimum viable candidate" vs. "cheap value-add".

E.g., an admin asst that does the job as described vs. the admin asst that occasionally helps with spreadsheets, does some basic graphic design work, and proof-reads both user-facing and technical documentation.

Does an admin asst need a college degree? No. But I'll take the admin asst with some art, accounting, and writing skills ANY day. Those skills completely re-define the role and add tons of value at very low cost.

I've seen the same in tech roles. Given two candidates who are both obviously capable of doing the primary duties of the job, the one with a deeper background (either from college or self-taught) is obviously preferable because versatility outside of the designated role is always a nice value-add.


> vs. paying full price at an Ivy League school. Just think what you could do on a fraction of the cost.

Or the most obvious and common choice:

- go to literally any other college.

Also, of your alternatives, only one makes a lick of sense. Both

> Travel the world

and

> Use some of the capital to start a small online business

are 1) not actually options for anyone who has to take out loans for college, and 2) FAR more financially risky than the college route.

(2) is the most important point. Is college a great option? Often, no. However, are the plentiful better options? Often, no. (And the ones that do exist don't scale... not everyone can be a plumber.)


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: