> Stop focusing on stuff you disagree with. Tell us why. For example, devops may be BS, but if so, why, and what is the alternative? There are answers.
Also, consider the possibility that you are wrong about the fad being stupid precisely because you've already accepted the fundamental premise behind the koolaid.
The original instantiation of devops is actually the "fad" that made me realize this particular truth. I had only ever worked in situations where all the infra people sling scripting languages along with the best of 'em and the software developers are as comfortable with iptables and apt and load balancers as they are with their editor/ide/compiler of choice.
So to me, devops sounded like a lot of ridiculous hot air -- it's just a new name for how things have always been; how can all these promises about productivity improvement make any sense to anyone?! And besides, the stuff that wasn't obvious was often ridiculous cargo culty stuff.
What I didn't know was the sheer number of shops where the IT people didn't have any programming skills and the programmers had never become competent with CLIs! In many shops, IT folks knew some recipes in the Windows Server GUIs and the devs knew how to use one IDE. When I first encountered a shop like that, I suddenly realized devops isn't hot air, even if for me the core tenets are just a description of how you should obviously do thins and how they've always been done...
And what do you think about the current trend wherein 60% of people who use the term DevOps do not understand any of what you said and just use it as the new word for System Administration?
IMO the central thesis is that society should have a negative view of tech companies and tech workers. That's the only thesis that each argument made in the post actually justifies. So if that's not the true thesis, then I guess the article is just a sequence of incoherent and poorly constructed arguments about UBI, education, corporate taxation, etc.
A counter-argument to the "you should hate tech people" thesis might be the pronounced support among tech workers for fixing the problems their industry helps create. The author argues that this is actually yet another reason why we should have a negative view of tech companies and tech workers, because UBI won't work and because we could fix college affordability by forcing Harvard to fund a few more full rides.
> Education is ripe for disruption. There’s a commonly believed fallacy right now that technology companies, specifically VC-backed technology education companies, are going to disrupt education. That’s bullshit. Instead, Harvard, Yale, MIT, and Stanford are the favorites to disrupt education when they fall under heavy and sustained government pressure over the irrational and immoral hoarding of their mammoth endowments. Harvard claims it could have doubled the size of its freshman class last year with no sacrifice to its educational quality. Good. Do it. More students, paying no tuition, at the best schools will disrupt the system.
Harvard matriculates a teeny, tiny fraction of all university students. Doubling that number is not a solution. Even doubling that number at all ivies and elite universities is not even remotely close to a solution.
UBI may not be the correct solution, but even UBI isn't this out of touch.
Maybe I'm just cynical, but I have a tough time believing that the preference for graduates from "top" colleges is entirely because they produce the best results rather than just a way to (necessarily) artificially limit access to a scarce resource. Just for the sake of round numbers, let's say there are enough quarter-million-dollar-a-year jobs for 1% of the population, but 10% of the population, with a bit of training, could step in and do those jobs. What do you do? You set up some semi-artificial, but still realistic, hurdles to limit the applicant pool. Doubling the applicant pool isn't going to solve the "problem" (if you even see it as a problem); it'll just necessitate an extra hurdle.
> Maybe I'm just cynical, but I have a tough time believing that the preference for graduates from "top" colleges is entirely because they produce the best results rather than just a way to (necessarily) artificially limit access to a scarce resource.
This is not really relevant. The author of this piece suggests that the path to affordable higher ed in the US is elite institutions doubling their full-rides. But that's a drop in the bucket; "everyone go to an ivy on a full ride" is not a sustainable or realistic way of decreasing the cost of college.
> Just for the sake of round numbers, let's say there are enough quarter-million-dollar-a-year jobs for 1% of the population, but 10% of the population, with a bit of training, could step in and do those jobs.
This is also not a problem. Most people who go to college would be perfectly happy with a stable 80k. Or even 60k. The problem is not that folks can't get 250k. The problem is the massive amount of money they have to spend to get certain jobs that pay those wages, even at lower-tier universities. And more Harvard scholarships aren't going to solve that problem.
GOFAI, as a 10ish year era of easy money for CS research agendas, was a relatively cheap investment and ultimately a tremendous financial, economic, and scientific success. If you're using functional languages, sql databases, or networked computers then you're benefitting from GOFAI. ATM you're using all three.
GOFAI was around for a lot longer than 10 years - it arguably started at the Dartmouth workshop and was still going strong in the '90s - so at least 40 years.
That wasn't my experience - few people were really doing AGI (though some were, even up to the early 90s) but most effort in any area that was explicitly identified as AI was generally in applications (e.g. fault diagnosis and qualitative modelling - the areas I worked in).
Illich's work is interesting. On schooling, medicine, and transportation, I think he gets at a fundamental problem, highlights a great partial solution for part of the population.
But Illich also generalizes too much and has a weird reactionary twist. (It makes perfect sense to me that he was the sort of person who would devote his life to the church but subsequently run into political issues with the church.)
Schooling:
Learning Webs are basically the internet with some tokens for video-conferencing a teacher once in a while. (Proposed in the 70's, no less!)
And it's a great solution for some people in some subjects.
But many students don't have the discipline or need extra hand-holding, and so on in at least one vital subject.
For every student in some subject who learns on their own and whose frustration with the system holds them back, there's at least one student in some subject who just won't learn the material without something resembling a traditional school environment.
And the weird reactionary twist: he sort of harkens back to the good old days while ignoring the fact that we used to just not bother educating most people, and also dismisses anything that's not explicit deschooling.
I remember hearing a recording of him basically telling a teacher that the only way they can truly educate well is by totally giving up on schooling.
I lost a lot of respect for Illich's prescriptions after hearing that, even if I still think he has a great eye for some problems and potential partial solutions. Because I lived in the age of the learning web and could see in my own life that excellent teachers could overcome a lot of the barriers in the system, and there were a lot of things I couldn't learn just from books/websites and friendly folks on IRC and forums.
Also, that poetic tangent at the end of Deschooling always made me cringe.
Medicine:
You could say Illich predicted the opioid epidemic and prescribed lifestyle changes decades before modern medicine caught up, but at the same time if every doctor and medical researcher followed his prescriptions oncology would be stuck in the 70's. And a lot of his work would fit right in among anti-vaccination folks.
I mean, 90% of healthfulness is about lifestyle issues, and medicine in recent history has done a really poor job of stressing that component of treatment. But Illich kind of hard lines about the other 10% in a way that's totally unreasonable.
Transportation: Another great example of a 90% solution that goes off the rails when Illich demands that extra 10%. I'm 100% on board with biking everywhere (and I even do so in the summer, although even then often exceept 15kph). But also, it's nice to travel to different states without going on a months-long pilgrimage...
Illich was very much a brilliant reaction to the more damaging trends that started in the 1950's to 1970's, but he fell in that "extreme ideology" pit that a lot of politics from that era also suffered from.
Ever drive 8-12 hour days for 2 days straight? Used to do it 4-5, but sometimes up to 10, times per year. I'd pay many thousands for lane-keeping on rural interstates in a heartbeat.
The proposed regulation provides that, for the science pivotal to its significant regulatory actions, EPA will ensure that the data and models underlying the science is publicly available
The public availability requirement sounds nice on paper, but in practice, it means ignoring a lot of science during rule-making because the original data can't be published due to genuine privacy concerns.
There are some common-sense workarounds. For example, requiring an EPA or third-party audit of the original dataset and analysis. Or simply carving out exceptions for research whenever it can be demonstrated that an IRB (and therefore federal law) would not have allowed the research without restricting public access to data/analysis.
> The public availability requirement sounds nice on paper, but in practice, it means ignoring a lot of science during rule-making because the original data can't be published due to genuine privacy concerns.
It is more limited if you read the whole sentence, which goes on to qualify which data they are interested in (specifically "publicly available in a manner sufficient for validation and analysis.").
which de facto excludes 90% of medical research because medical patients have privacy rights and researchers have legal obligations to respect those rights.
These rules are a hot political topic that are years in the making. The people pushing them are not scientists and have never expressed genuine interest in reproducibility outside of this one issue. And scientists who have spent years fighting for reproducibility have publicly stated they oppose this rule. And all the major proponents have strong anti-regulatory preferences.
These rules are not about reproducibility. This rule is an intentionally crafted Catch-22 designed to exclude medical research from consideration so it's easier to justify repealing or not implementing environmental regulations. Otherwise, the rules would find a middle ground; e.g., by allowing the EPA access to relevant scientific data and analysis without risking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/De-anonymization by posting sensitive medical information about thousands of patients on the public internet.
It's very hard to believe it is not possible to publish medical data in an anonymized fashion that does not infringe privacy rights. If that's true, how people validate any medical research at all? Do they just ignore the validation, and if some research has an error - well, tough luck, we'd base policy on it anyway and if it turns out to be a disaster, we'd just shrug? Giving up on reproducibility and validation means giving up on one of the most important features of modern science, I have very hard time believing that's the only way to do modern medical research known to our civilization.
> Otherwise, the rules would find a middle ground;
They actually did, if you read the actual proposal, which talks about disclosure in ways that enough for validation but does not infringe privacy. But you seem to have arrived to pre-determined conclusion already, and there in fact can be no middle ground that would be acceptable to you, as it seems.
A lot of environmental medical research results in dense and small data instead of sparse and large data, which obviously means it's even easier to de-anonymize.
And the really important take away from the above paper is that you need to know about all the other public data in the universe in order to really ensure anonymity. Even when anonymity seems like it's "obviously" not going to be a problem.
You never know what dataset will be leaked/published tomorrow correlating columns D-F in the spreadsheet you gave EPA to someone's first and last name. So privacy is like computer security: you can never be totally sure. So when the stakes are high you should be extra cautious. And the stakes when sharing medical research are very often high.
> If that's true, how people validate any medical research at all?.. I have very hard time believing that's the only way to do modern medical research known to our civilization.
This isn't exactly a new problem, so scientists have had a little while to figure out how to make peer review work.
You share the data. You share with trusted, relevant third parties who promise to preserve the anonymity of study participants. Just becuase you do not publish possibly de-anonymizable and definitely sensitive medical information on a public website does not mean you don't share the data with interested and relevant third parties.
> But you seem to have arrived to pre-determined conclusion already, and there in fact can be no middle ground that would be acceptable to you, as it seems.
On the contrary, I do literally exactly that in my very first post in this thread: There are some common-sense workarounds. For example, requiring an EPA or third-party audit of the original dataset and analysis. Or simply carving out exceptions for research whenever it can be demonstrated that an IRB (and therefore federal law) would not have allowed the research without restricting public access to data/analysis.
The situation where IRB says "no" to public disclosure should explicitly trigger exemption, with the duty falling back to the agency to prove the IRB was wrong in the first place. The fact that this exemption is not automatic is what makes this a catch-22 that pins researchers in-between their IRB and the EPA administrator in charge of evaluating their exception.
Nothing in that article (with which I of course was familiar) says anything about "not possible to publish medical data in an anonymized fashion that does not infringe privacy rights". What it talks about is that some data sets may be improperly anonymized, and Netflix data set is one of them. It is undoubtedly true that anonymization is harder than it appears to a naive observer. It does not mean it is impossible.
> important take away from the above paper is that you need to know about all the other public data in the universe in order to really ensure anonymity.
I do not see how it's takeway from that paper.
> You never know what dataset will be leaked/published tomorrow correlating columns D-F in the spreadsheet you gave EPA to someone's first and last name.
You also never know whether somebody doesn't just break into your system, downloads all secret data and publishes them. Yes, you have no guarantee against bad actors and mistakes. But if that's the border condition then no research should be performed at all - after all, once the data exists, there's no guarantee it won't somehow get leaked out.
> The situation where IRB says "no" to public disclosure should explicitly trigger exemption
IRB is a part of the institution, right? So you essentially delegating the decision about the exception to (part of) the institution. What the point of having the rule then if every organization can make their own exceptions on demand? And that makes trivially easy to hide the data in sloppy research - just sprinkle some private data on it, show it to IRB, they cry out "no, this can't be released, no way!" - and voila, you are safe from review.
>..."not possible to publish medical data in an anonymized fashion that does not infringe privacy rights".
1. Sometimes it is.
2. I already gave substantive reasons why this will commonly occur in environmental medical research -- dense datasets about small populations that capture sensitive information about individuals.
> I do not see how it's takeway from that paper.
Because that's literally the only assumption in the adversarial model other than "access to the published dataset". And correlating with an auxiliary dataset is literally how all actual instantiations of this attack work.
> just sprinkle some private data on it, show it to IRB, they cry out "no, this can't be released, no way!" - and voila, you are safe from review.
1. My proposal doesn't say "IRB happened to say you can't publicly publish this one particular protocol." My proposal says that IRB explicitly judges that no such protocol exists.
2. IRBs are not that arbitrary and are themselves audited.
3. If you're this paranoid about intent, then you can't trust the research anyways. If the research is committing intentional fraud, they could just do it at the data collection step.
The way I see it, either:
A. Even if we can't trust individual scientists, we can more-or-less trust a broad subset of scientists with different and well-aligned motives (as in, a whole group of: the IRB board, the PI, the people reviewing the IRB board) when they say that data can't be shared for privacy reasons; or,
B. We should expect that literally dozens of scientists, all with different motives, will routinely and actively collude to commit wide-spread fraud.
If (A), my approach makes sense. If we max out paranoia and go with (B), then I don't know why we should trust the data regardless of whether it's published publicly...
Is science good (or "the best!") if the available data are not sufficient to verify the analysis? This is not a "world leader" doing anything that could be described as "shunning science".
I don't know. Is Newton's work worthless, because we no longer have access to the full set of raw data that he based it off?
There are thousands of old studies for which the data is unavailable, incomplete, was lost, etc. Are you going to pay for all of them to be reproduced? Are you ready to give up penicillin? Surgeons washing their hands between operations? The links between tobacco and cancer? Every single medical advancement (Because patient confidentiality precludes the release of raw data that goes into medical studies)?
I'm all for reproducibility, but this has enormous consequences.
Consider the following scenario. A chemical X is spilled in river. A sequence of very small towns with similar populations dot the river both up-stream down-stream. This is a dream setting for good science -- a true natural experiment with lots of genetic and environmental similarity between the groups in each small town, but radically different levels of exposure to X. Fast forward 10 years and researchers find that concentrations of X above some threshold N drastically increase the prevalence of birth defects. However, due to the size of the populations, researchers may not be able to publish their data and analysis publicly without de facto publishing almost complete de-anonymizable data.
The scenario is not so hypothetical. The circumstances and particulars change, but this situation describes a lot of medical and environmental research.
Should the EPA take the researcher's word? Maybe not. But there's a lot of workable middle ground in-between "blind trust" and "anyone with access to a library computer and a stats textbook can figure out participant 494 -- who math tells us can only possibly be Johnny D. of Smallsville, VA -- has testicular cancer".
And the situation is even more difficult than this because de-anonymization is an active area of research with some surprisingly powerful results published in recent years; i.e., it is highly non-trivial to determine if a dataset is de-anonymizable. And the answer always depends on what data about a person's identity is publicly available, which especially in the age of annual massive data leaks change from year to year. So even if researchers don't think it's possible to de-anonymize study participants using today's mathematical tools and today's public datasets, they'll often choose to keep the dataset private just in case.
* NSF gets $250M for quantum research and a mandate to establish 5 centers and to establish graduate traineeships in quantum fields. These traineeships are earmarked for US citizens.
* DOE gets $625M and a mandate to create up to 5 research centers, which go up for review after 5 years.
Also, consider the possibility that you are wrong about the fad being stupid precisely because you've already accepted the fundamental premise behind the koolaid.
The original instantiation of devops is actually the "fad" that made me realize this particular truth. I had only ever worked in situations where all the infra people sling scripting languages along with the best of 'em and the software developers are as comfortable with iptables and apt and load balancers as they are with their editor/ide/compiler of choice.
So to me, devops sounded like a lot of ridiculous hot air -- it's just a new name for how things have always been; how can all these promises about productivity improvement make any sense to anyone?! And besides, the stuff that wasn't obvious was often ridiculous cargo culty stuff.
What I didn't know was the sheer number of shops where the IT people didn't have any programming skills and the programmers had never become competent with CLIs! In many shops, IT folks knew some recipes in the Windows Server GUIs and the devs knew how to use one IDE. When I first encountered a shop like that, I suddenly realized devops isn't hot air, even if for me the core tenets are just a description of how you should obviously do thins and how they've always been done...