Have you thought about distributing the data, for accessibility and reproducibility? As well as save the taxpayers a little bit of dough in case someone else wants to request the same data.
That's interesting. I've often had to pay small to medium-sized amounts - always reasonable, I might add - for the price of producing said information.
You can often request that the FOIA officer waive the fee so long as the public's interest outweighs the burden to collect and redact the info. That's almost certainly what happened with my IL requests.
Sundar Pichai and Satya Nadella are US citizens who live in the US. They are not foreign nationals.
MSFT sells ICE a lot of software and regularly sells software/services to the DoD as well as other parts of the USG.
Google was opposed to working on military tech for years before Sundar Pichai became CEO.
> I realize this won't be a popular view here
Blatant factual inaccuracies and ignorance of extremely obvious alternative explanations should be unpopular. Both are avoidable and both derail potentially productive conversations.
There is a huge difference between a foreign national and a naturalized citizen. Proceeding in a conversation on this topic without using these terms correctly will only lead to confusion.
> You're assuming bad faith.
On the contrary, I misinterpreted your meaning precisely because I was being charitable.
Your original post could've been interpreted in two ways:
1. Charitably: you simply didn't know that these people were citizens of the USA, and are reasonably suspicious of someone who built their career and fortune here but who doesn't want to obtain citizenship.
2. Uncharitably: you distrust people because of where they were born.
I choose to judge people by their actions. Their actions are not up for debate. They are working against the US military and law enforcement community through their actions, while the American born Bezos is impartial in assisting US government. That's a huge difference and will be attributed to their national origin by many American born citizens. Those two CEOs are not be eligible to run our country as president under the constitution, but they are running two of our most powerful institutions as president and using those institutions to weaken US military readiness. At some point soon, this becomes a national security matter.
I would not work on autonomous weapons or mass surveillance technology, and if I were the CEO of a company, I would abstain from deploying that company's resources in this fashion.
In your mind, does this statement provide sufficient evidence to prove that I obviously intend to work in the interests of whichever country my ancestors immigrated from?
You not working on them is entirely different than Google not working on them AND the looming threat of a Google patent lawsuit preventing anyone else in the country from working on them too.
"...and if I were the CEO of a company, I would abstain from deploying that company's resources in this fashion."
Including Google. If I were the CEO of Googe, I would do this.
Don't avoid the question. In your mind, does this statement provide sufficient evidence to prove that I obviously intend to work in the interests of whichever country my ancestors immigrated from?
More-over, I don't think parent is giving enough credit to certain types of computer scientists and certain companies.
Facebook, Google, and some game companies definitely do hire lots of human-computer interaction Ph.D.s who definitely are trained in exactly this sort of thing.
There's a reason the title is "computer science researches" and not "computer programmers".
> What else are you going to do? Look at the stuff "deep" people are generally into, it mostly revolves around POSIX some way or another. And databases, but nobody wants to talk about that.
Self-driving cars (controls, perception, planning, safety, sensor design, localization, mapping, integration, security, etc.), human-competitive NLP/image classification, advanced robotics (repeat list from cars here but for things in the air, off-road, on the water, in the water, in orbit, in deep space, ...).
Those are all examples of real things that real people get to work on every day.
Operating systems topics don't even scrape the top 20 of stuff I think of when I think of deep expertise.
And even if we limit ourselves to the sort of things you mention, most people who work deeply on languages, tools, and standards view these as manifestations of their deep exploration rather than the focus or subject of the dive.
For example, TensorFlow. The framework very much is the product. But even if some other framework won the day tomorrow, the people who worked on TensorFlow would not have "wasted" their time thinking deeply about how to build the system.
This is why researchers whose original contributions were made in the 70s and 80s none-the-less continue to establish themselves as desired experts in new technology trends (e.g., Leslie Lamport and cloud computing or Martin Abadi and ML frameworks). Because they were focused on ideas and fundamental problems. The problems never disappeared, just changed form. And ideas have a lot more staying power than their manifestation in code.
Most people working deeply on systems today are not "revolving around POSIX in some way". See the proceedings of OSDI. And most deep experts choose other topics, most of which your post doesn't mention: graphics, programming languages (making them and analyzing programs written in them), compilers, security, robotics, user interfaces, NLP, ...
Your definition of "expert" seems to revolve around using things, mostly things based on ideas and techniques that were well-understood already 20 years ago and that are related to building a particular type of software system. Which, if anything, seems to deepen the author's point.
Someone gets to fill the AI research labs, staff the self-driving car companies, work at NASA, build core infra at large tech companies, and build the foundation for the next 20 years of trendy growth areas.
It's possible to get to those places without a degree, of course, but a degree is by far the path of least resistance. And in most of these cases, learning the material from the degree isn't optional; you're probably going to have hard time doing that controls engineering job at a self-driving car company if you never made your way through a calc sequence, some physics, and an algorithms course.
It's also worth noting that very often, building wordpress plugins pays more than doing all of those things I mentioned. I guess it's all about what you want to spend your life doing, which is exactly what the author says at the end of the article.
Self-driving cars are new. You've missed my point. The OP is from an older age. There wasn't a lot back then, so for choosing what to focus in, weren't a lot of choices.
Funny, you mention graphics, what do graphics usually involve? C, C++. Back to POSIX. Operating systems? Same. Robotics? C. Basically, if you picked C, you're good.
On the other hand, how often do you hear about a Java expert? Someone who knows the intricacies of the GC? All about the JVM? Not that often. They exist. But it's not hip. They chose "poorly".
These days, there is a lot more choice, so what are you going to pick? On what is that choice based? What do you do if you picked the wrong thing? This is problem is very modern and didn't exist to such a degree before.
> Self-driving cars are new. You've missed my point. The OP is from an older age. There wasn't a lot back then, so for choosing what to focus in, weren't a lot of choices.
RALPH, a 1990 Pontiac Sport minivan, drove across the US 98% autonomously. In 1995.
Much of the control theory, robotics, and AI work that enabled the current self-driving gold rush was invented decades ago.
The Dartmouth workshop was in 1956. Dearth of choices? Please! Those days provided an enormous surplus of choices, almost all of which were good ones! People from that older age invented reinforcement learning, image classification, natural language processing, OOP, hell, even the notion of a pointer! And the list goes on.
Today there are far fewer choices than there were back then because so much has already been done.
That is, of course, assuming you're in the business of "doing things no one else has done before" as opposed to the business of "following a well-trodden path".
So, I guess if your view of the world is confined to "using things other people already invented and explained to me", you might consider the 1950s and 1960s a bleak period when no one knew how to do anything. As opposed to the cusp of a century-long period of continuous innovation...
Again, as the article says, I guess it boils down to what you want to get out of a lifetime of work.
> Funny, you mention graphics, what do graphics usually involve?
And that's just the undergrad stuff, not the cutting edge.
Oh yeah, knowing C/CUDA/OpenCL is nice. But when compared to deep expertise, it's a rather trivial time investment and is completely orthogonal: an implementation detail, not the fundamental content.
> Operating systems?
Kernels, scheduling, device drivers, caching, distributed systems, energy models, timing attacks, and the list goes on.
Of course, knowing C is essential, but that's the easy stuff when compared to wrapping your head around a modern OS, or even a tiny piece of a modern OS
> Robotics?
SLAM, sensor fusion, filters, actuation for various types of novel actuators, PDEs and ODEs, optimal control, stability and robustness, system identification, model-predictive control, motors, servos, simulation, etc. And that's just the software side.
Oh yeah, knowing C is nice. But when compared to deep expertise in robotics, it's a rather trivial time investment and is completely orthogonal: an implementation detail, not the fundamental content. Many of the fundamental ideas at techniques in robotics pre-date C by decades.
> On the other hand, how often do you hear about a Java expert? Someone who knows the intricacies of the GC? All about the JVM? Not that often. They exist. But it's not hip. They chose "poorly".
I know a few true, honest-to-god Java experts. They all make insane amounts of money (even by SFBA SE standards) and love their work. Turns out Google has quite a bit of Java code and a metric shitload of money.
You think graphics, robotics, and OSes are just "C and POSIX". That's not true. C and POSIX aren't even table stakes. They're the thing you pick up in a few weeks or maybe a semester so that you can spend several years obtaining the table stakes -- see the list above. Then you need to build true expertise on top of that.
The path from "I know C" to "robotics expert" or "graphics expert" is at the very least a multi-year path. And that's assuming you're bright and have your full work day (and then some) to dedicate to following advances and building your own.
> For instance, in a profile of biologist Jill Bargonetti, The New York Times quotes one of Bargonetti’s colleagues saying that, “Jill makes a fantastic role model... because she is married, has two children and has been able to keep up with her research.” It’s hard to imagine anyone saying this about a scientist named Bill. The story’s subtitle piles on, reinforcing the stereotype that women are nurturing and selfless with “A Biologist’s Choice Gives Priority to Students.”
The paragraph hits on so many ways in which the popular (press) conception of science and academia is toxic, and sexism is only one part of that toxicity.
Yes, the disparity in how female scientists are described in a problem. But that fact that these attributes are absent from descriptions of male academics is also troubling. How are there so many profiles of Professors that don't mention teaching or mentoring even once?!
When new phd students ask for advice on choosing a Ph.D. advisor, I give them three strictly ordered criteria:
1. Is this person a good mentor? (Where are their former students? Do those students speak positively and also candidly about their advisor?)
2. Does this person have a work-life balance? (Family? Intense hobby? Good friendships outside of the department? Encyclopedic knowledge of their favorite TV series? An inappropriate percentage of their net worth invested in cars/wines/whatever? Literally, any non-trivial time invested in something other than work most weeks.)
3. Are you excited about the research agendas that they currently have (relatively fresh) money to explore, and do you think this person has the expertise needed to help you push those agendas in the way you want?
Those three questions, in that order. If you can't find someone who meets some minimum reasonable threshold for all three, maybe consider expanding your research interests or finding a new department.
Profiles of male academic scientists should go beyond individual contributions to discuss teaching/mentoring and work/life balance. After all, it's a profile of a person who is a professor! Teaching/mentoring is a huge chunk of the job, and the person is more than their work.
If there's nothing to say about the person other than some brilliant results? If their former students resent them and their family life is in shambles? That's a tragic personal interest story. If the person has a normal relationship with their students and a normal personal life? Then there's no personal interest story at all and the article should maybe just talk about the results instead of profiling the person.
The RealClimate.org piece is a very nice piece of scientific prose; I enjoyed the historical preface. The scientific discussion was clear enough that I could get an overall sense of the field but specific enough that I know where to look if I want to make a deep dive into any one of the various related claims: http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2018/07/does-a...
More generally, though, climate science makes me queasy. I'm more than happy to accept the dominant theories and sort of understand that there's a lot of people who understand enough of the related science to have an informed opinion, but I feel like it would take at least a Ph.D. and a postdoc before I could really get to that point. There are just so many complex systems in play.
If you want to take a deep dive, the IPCC is the place to be : https://www.ipcc.ch
> The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) is a scientific and intergovernmental body under the auspices of the United Nations, set up at the request of member governments, dedicated to the task of providing the world with an objective, scientific view of climate change and its political and economic impacts. It was first established in 1988 by two United Nations organizations, the World Meteorological Organization (WMO) and the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP).... The IPCC produces reports that support the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC), which is the main international treaty on climate change.
IPCC reports cover "the scientific, technical and socio-economic information relevant to understanding the scientific basis of risk of human-induced climate change, its potential impacts and options for adaptation and mitigation."
The IPCC does not carry out its own original research, nor does it do the work of monitoring climate or related phenomena itself. The IPCC bases its assessment on the published literature, which includes peer-reviewed and non-peer-reviewed sources.
Thousands of scientists and other experts contribute (on a voluntary basis, without payment from the IPCC) to writing and reviewing reports, which are then reviewed by governments. IPCC reports contain a "Summary for Policymakers", which is subject to line-by-line approval by delegates from all participating governments. Typically this involves the governments of more than 120 countries.
The price of forever ranges from a few hundred to millions depending on how resilient you want to be.
In reality, it would probably be more effective to dedicate nearly $0 to infrastructure and $N,000.00 to an endowment for 1-3 hours of engineering time each year.
Figuring out how to host a static site for free and moving the site to that service requires almost no time for a competent engineer. But finding a solution that is guaranteed to exist in 100 years with zero human intervention would probably cost millions...
That's along the lines of what I was thinking. The www.mywebsite.com foundation, worth a whopping 10k, invests it's 300$ annual interest in updating the hosting for www.mywebsite.com.
More-over, he had time on earth to accumulate the experience/maturity that eliminates stupidity as an explanation, but also not enough time to accumulate the responsibilities that sometimes explain fraud.
Fraud at 18? -> Stupid kid (obv., fraud is never ok)
Fraud at 45 with three dependents on the verge of bankruptcy? -> poor bloke, the choice between a big personal risk vs. failing your family really sucks (obv., fraud is never ok)
Fraud at 27 with no real responsibilities in life? -> WTF?
Turns out a lot of the scheduling software out there was written by people who without formal training or who weren't paying attention in their algorithms course.
E.g., one year:
Me: requests A and B
Friend: requests A and non-honors B
hour 4: Me in non-honors B; friend in gym.
hour 5 (only hour honors B is offered): Me in A; friend in honros B.
Based on a few years of observations, I'm almost certain courses were filled using some variant of this algorithm:
for each student s sorted by student number:
for each non-filled course c in hour 1..n:
if(s wants c and not in c): assign s to c and continue to next hour.
for each non-filled course c in hour 1..n:
if(s wants c' and not in c' and c is like c'): assign s to c and continue to next hour.
because students with lower student numbers tended to get their choices (correlated with when student joined district far better than class status) and courses late in the day were always half empty while courses earlier in the day were always filled to the brim.
Things got better each year but never in a way that would suggest someone finally decided to pick up an algorithms textbook.
I suspect by now they've purchased something that works or else managed to prove P=NP and the solution is billions of if statements fixing special cases the teachers/students complained loudly enough about...
I don't know the details, but I know my school had a person from IT with a computer science degree on secondment to the studies department at the beginning of each year to get the timetable sorted out. The phrase "least constraints matching" is something I remember being mentioned when I asked.