Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more throwawayjava's commentslogin

This topic has been discussed at length on HN and has been the topic of many flame wars.

If you're genuinely curious for an answer, in the United States it's absolutely the case that you are legally

> obligated to throw out the conclusion

when it comes to many of the things you mentioned (e.g., you can't consider race, or often gender and sexual orientation depending on the state, when you evaluate a loan/employment application).

The reason for those laws is that, historically, overtly and openly racist people used the loan application process to discriminate in housing.

Asking to be able to use any accurate statistical model for any application is an inherently political request, because bad actors in the past have attempted to exclude people based upon skin color. We can't make that discrimination legal whenever someone can dream up a plausible mathematical model justifying an ultimately racial intent.

The real point of my post is that a discussion on this topic devolves into a flame war unless everyone agrees that we can't turn p-hacking into a legally justifiable way of allowing racial discrimination in important social processes like housing loan or employment applications.


> We can't make that discrimination legal

> an ultimately racial intent.

I reject your assertion that by studying data, data scientists or analysts are somehow complicit in discrimination or any -ism. Their job is to make business decisions based on data, WITHOUT relying on "gut feel" or other human biases. I also reject the expectation that data scientists have an obligation (or the ability) to "fix" whatever biases may be revealed by the data.

> p-hacking

Again, you are making assumptions that data scientists are somehow evil, engaging in shady or illegal tactics to promote discrimination rather than simply doing their job in a straightforward manner. P-hacking is often done by individual researchers looking to get a study published in a scholarly journal (as opposed to months/years or research failing to reach a statistically-valid conclusion), rarely by companies who are looking to make profitable decisions based on what the data is indicating.


It appears that you make the false assumption that the data itself are unbiased and are always factually correct. This is untrue. Data does not appear magically in a dataset. It is the interpretation of the world by humans and may therefore carry the original bias, intended or not, of humans. This is why analysts have to think about what the data means whenever they do their analyses. I would say that is their ethical responsibility.


> think about what the data means

of course they do that, that is literally their job.

But to reverse-engineer the biases that may or may not exist in an original data set -- please explain how this should be accomplished, because I don't see how someone could accurately quantify the amount or degree of race/sex/age/religion/nationality-ism without introducing additional "bias" based on that person's own opinion.

> Data does not appear magically in a dataset.

Right, so why isn't the boss, or exec, or department head, or 3rd-party, who sourced the data responsible for de-biasing the data before even handing it off to the the data scientist, so s/he can just do the job of data science-ing, and not political science-ing? You're putting a whole lot of "ethical responsibility" on just one person -- ironically, the one least likely to be good at interpreting human emotional tendencies -- within a much larger ecosystem.


That's the point, it is very difficult to correctly interpret analyses. That's why you don't take conclusions for granted, and work from the basis of what you think is biologically relevant. There is usually a whole phase preceding the actual analysis. You can visualise potential relationships in directed acyclic graphs, to try and see where bias might be introduced. However, that phase is very often skipped by medical researchers.

I never said the analyst was the sole person bearing the responsibility. You are right that just as much as responsibility must be expected from those that designed the information model, those that collected the data but also the person who ultimately analyses it and prepares it for whatever kind of dissemination. Everybody involved has to take their individual responsibility so that we achieve collective responsibility.


I never make any of those assumptions (notice how you have to quote sentence fragmets and even single words to set up your stra man...)

What I assume is that not all humans are perfectly rational individuals whose only goal is profit maximization. And thatwe cannot see peoples souls, so we need laws that err in the side of caution.

I also assume that homo economicus is explicitly disincentivized from reasoning about feedback effects and historical context, which are two things many actual homo sapiens care about (for obvious reasons).

E.g., disregarding feedback loops and the long arc of history, ie in a vaccuum, supporting racialized slavery is perfectly rational for non-enslaved people interested in profit maximization. Cinsider also a completely not raciat loan lender with vested interest in high property values who knows dark skinned people lower property values. Even if the data scientist is perfectly unbiased, bias and hatred in the underlying population can result in data driven, profit motivated decisions that harm marginal groups. The fact that this really actually happened en masse is WHY we have these laws...

Regarding the latter point, you are effectively dismissing all non-consequtialist ethics and associated legal traditions as "gut feelings". I submit that these gut feelings play an important role in human societies made up of irrational people. In fact, they are even important in societies with perfectly rational people who are not super reasoners with perfect forsight.


I'm not sure I agree with the article's main warrant for its core argument (i.e., the "but they're wrong" part):

> But there’s an extremely important caveat: Students aren’t fleeing degrees with poor job prospects. They’re fleeing humanities and related fields specifically because they think they have poor job prospects. If the whole story were a market response to student debt and the Great Recession, students would have read the 2011 census report numbering psychology and communications among the fields with the lowest median earnings and fled from them.

IME Psychology and Communications attract students who are looking for an easy degree. Humanities majors are typically more rigorous than the Psych or Comm majors.

Psych/Comm attracts a lot of students who hate reading/writing and math equally.

> Or they would have noticed that biology majors make less than the average college graduate, and favored the physical sciences.

Again, IME, most of those bio majors are planning on med school, nursing, grad school, or teaching.


> So they have an actual class dedicated to teaching you about this, and that class fails to enumerate all of your options?

Two thoughts: (1) such courses are often opt-in and don't necessarily have tons of free time for off-topic discussions; and (2) many schools with such courses do in fact have robust CC-tracked options that all-honors students are not exposed to.

1. A class like this was offered by my high school (years and years ago...) I didn't take it. However, from what I remember talking with friends, our school's course was explicitly for people who were planning on going to college. So it'd be kind of weird to discuss alternatives. That would be like mentioning in a Biology course that Physics or English are also legitimate fields of study.

You'd think such a course would be wishy-washy and have plenty of time for discussing alternatives, but actually it was quite a serious thing.. Most of the students who took the course thought they were on-track for ivy league applications and then got a dose of reality in the form of a below-average standardized test score. They had a couple months to learn how to pattern-match and flash-card their way into the 90th percentile starting from the 50th percentile. I distinctly remember more than one person dropping AP Calc so they could focus on the college prep course...

(In other news, grade inflation and subjective grading are harmful because they are sparse & deceptive reward signals!)

2. Community college was very much not looked down upon; in fact, we had a robust partnership with the regional CC system and many students would spend junior and senior years splitting their week between HS and CC.

However, if you were honors/AP/college-tracked, then you wouldn't really know that those students even existed unless you socialized with those students. I only knew about these programs because of my friend group.

At a recent reunion, I talked with some guys who I recognized from my AP courses. They were complaining that our high school didn't offer non-college-tracked options. I mentioned the various programs my friends had made use of and they were shocked and swore up and down that those programs didn't exist when we were in school.

I wonder if either of these two things is true for OP. IME it's fairly rare for an entire high school -- let alone an entire school district -- to not have robust options for CC-tracked students. Maybe in super-affluent areas?

> Sounds like my sex-ed class in Georgia which never even discussed birth control.

Yeah... state law. Same for me. I had a teacher who risked her job to give us good info. If that was the case for anyone else reading this, consider looking up that teacher and sending a gift card or something their way. Doing so is a huge personal and professional risk.


IME the idea of "tracks" is totally foreign to most urban school districts. We know about "honors classes" and the "vocational students" from movies, but the whole school system only exists to get students to pass state minimum requirements in whatever sketchy, technical way they can, or else house them until they turn 16 and can drop out. The "advisors" presumably exist to check a box on some state form: they certainly don't offer any actual assistance or advice in applying for school beyond being the office where you sign up for ACT or SAT test dates and handing out FAFSA forms.

The idea that a high school would have anything to do with preparing you for post-secondary education, or advising you on what type of institution to get it from, is totally foreign in districts like this.


OP here: You're on the right track in that I go to boarding school. Definitely not super-affluent (it's Louisiana after all!), but not an average high school either. We've got very good teachers and a wide selection of advanced classes, so it makes more sense that college is pushed hard here.

But regarding the first point, the program is mandatory. As for the second, I haven't heard of any other options and I doubt they exist, but as you point out it may just be the circles I interact in. And of course attending boarding school is a choice, though I can't speak for what the situation is at the other schools.

> I distinctly remember more than one person dropping AP Calc so they could focus on the college prep course...

This comment really made me smile. I wonder how much that was actually motivated by wanting to focus on college and how much was just wanting an excuse to get out of AP Calc. AP Calc sucks.


8.5% of private non-profit students default, and 13.5% of public non-profit students default.

Those are both pretty high numbers, and those are just the defaults; i.e., the worst-case scenario. It's not counting the tens of thousands of people who defer housing, defer saving for retirement, defer saving for their own children's education, or end up on a perpetual treadmill of loan payments that will destroy their ability to retire.

We are heading is the worst possible direction wrt regulation of private for-profit institutions; the available data incontrovertibly demonstrates they should be subject to more scrutiny, not less. But that's definitely not the whole story.


> Experience only results in being able to lie to the public, to further the establishment.

This is not the case in other fields such as Engineering, Medicine, Education, or Law. More experienced engineers, doctors, lawyers, and educators tend to be better at their craft. Failing to keep up with new methodology/technology is also a problem.

It's almost like the quality of the person is more important than their age or seniority.

Now, I don't have any first-hand experience with legislatures. However, based on analogies in fields I'm more familiar with, I am a bit suspicious of the claim that there aren't any advantages to seniority and experience.

Also, consider this concrete question: would term limits fix the student debt problem? I don't see any arguments in this thread that it would.


I think the biggest counter argument to why we need experienced people in government is that the tide has turned where old people have their interests represented but young people do not.

Student loans fuel retirement accounts for old people.

Lack of upward mobility helps old rich people.

Tax cuts for the rich by and large help old people.

We have a nation governed by geezers who only care about geezers.


I think this understates the real problem. As people become professional politicians, their interest becomes more and more about what benefits themselves. It's not about geezers caring about geezers -- it's about geezers who only care about themselves.

You can consider this in a really simple, but also regular and real, scenario. You're faced by a decision. One choice you think is bad for the country but is strongly supported by various special interest groups who will likely run major positive advertising and other positive 'propaganda' for you, if you go that route. The other decision is good for the nation but vehemently opposed by these same interests. You can expect negative advertising and other consequences should you go this route. It's not hard to see which decision a "professional" politician is going to pick, regardless of whether they're 20 or 90 years old.

Ideally this would all be a nonstarter since you stay in office by getting elected. So do what's good and you get elected again, right? But this goes out the window when people are so easily swayed by the media and misinformation. A very large chunk of people don't measure the results of the nation independently, just based on what they hear in the media or by easily exploited emotional responses.


This quote needs a date. It is from, at the very latest, maybe 1940.

Inflation-adjusted, that's like $10 million.


Why would it be 1940 at the very latest? He ran IBM till well into the 50s. It has multiple variants, the longer ones involving a sale and a million dollars.


Woah, what was IBM up to back then?




Genocide. Dehomag and Watson Business Machines.


producing technology and selling it to the third reich

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_and_the_Holocaust


The original motion makes a more nuanced argument than this thread gives credit for. In particular, the motion does not claim that border searches in general are unconstitutional. It makes a much finer scoped claim that:

without individualized criminal suspicion, the off-site search of an electronic device taken at a border is unconstitutional. No such suspicion of ongoing or imminent criminal activity existed in the case of Ms. Lazoja giving rise to reasonable suspicion to search and seize her property. Consequently, neither was there probable cause, nor a warrant. Therefore, the search and seizure of Ms. Lazoja’s property violated her rights under the Fourth Amendment.

To make this argument, the motion mentions some precedent. Most notably was United States v. Kim (page 12):

In Kim, where DHS agents seized a laptop computer at Los Angeles International Airport and later sent it to a laboratory to be copied and searched, the district court found that the lengthy post-seizure retention of a laptop at a second site, outside the airport, “did not possess the characteristics of a border search or other regular inspection procedures,” and that it “more resembled the common nonborder search based on individualized suspicion, which must be prefaced by the usual warrant and probable cause standards.” Id. at 58 (citing United States v. Brennan, 538 F.2d 711, 716 (5th Cir. 1976)). The court in Kim questioned whether the seizure and imaging of a laptop at the border “can accurately be characterized as a border search at all.”

And furthermore that doing so for a cell-phone is particularly egregious; recent supreme court cases strengthen the argument that if we're going to protect laptops then we certainly need to protect cellphones (page 13):

The Supreme Court recently expanded the categorically heightened privacy interests in data located on cell phones, specifically addressing cell phones’ location data.

The motion also makes auxiliary arguments about retention and duration: even if the border search was constitutional, shipping the device off to a lab was not constitutional without a warrant. And even if shipping the device to a lab was constitutional, retaining it for so long was not constitutional. And even if retaining the device for so long was constitutional, retaining the data indefinitely is not constitutional. At least, not without warrants.


"Jane Doe and John Does 1-2 provided Ms. Lazoja a receipt (No. 1199376) dated February 26, 2018, documenting CBP’s seizure of her iPhone and SIM Card, and indicating the iPhone and SIM Card were “Sent to DHS Lab.” (Rejhane Aff. ¶ 27); see Ex. A."

They took her phone and retained it for 130 days. Presumably, during that time they copied all of the data off of the phone (and perhaps also decypted that data). Regardless, the plaintiff argues that keeping the phone for that period of time without a warrant was unconstitutional in the first place.


> They took her phone and retained it for 130 days. Presumably, during that time they copied all of the data off of the phone (and perhaps also decypted that data).

My understanding is that the data can't be (feasibly) extracted and decrypted from a modern iPhone, though. Isn't that why the FBI made such a big fuss about Apple not "cooperating" to backdoor devices?

I understand the argument about the seizure being unconstitutional, but I'm talking strictly about the cryptographic aspects here.


There are commercial tools for breaking iPhones. For example, $15k buys you 300 unlocks with this: https://www.forbes.com/sites/thomasbrewster/2018/03/05/apple...

Of course, it’s Cat and mouse and I believe Apple will or already have squashed that.

The iPhone is the most secure consumer mobile device, but not bulletproof


> My understanding is that the data can't be (feasibly) extracted and decrypted from a modern iPhone, though.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/thomasbrewster/2018/02/26/gover...

Also, the motion requests:

Plaintiff Rejhane Lazoja respectfully asks this Court to order Defendants to return her Data, to expunge any copies made of the Data, to disclose all third parties who received and/or retain copies, partial or complete, of the Data, and to provide information about the basis for the seizure and retention of the property.

If the judge grants all of these requests, it will be interesting to watch what happens with the request:

...return her Data...

If it comes to this, I hope the plaintiff asks the court to know whether the data was decrypted. I.e., if you decrypted my data, you need to return that to me. The original image doesn't suffice.

Maybe "correspondence with council" is the groundwork for this later request? I.e., something along the lines of "I have a right to know what the government now knows about my private correspondence with my council."

The "partial or complete" portion of the request is also relevant for answering this question: the information is legally relevant (and the request reasonable) because some of the correspondence was between the plaintiff and her council, and also because if they shared partial information that almost certainly means they were able to decrypt the data.

The govt's response to the timeframe arguments will also certainly leak some information about the government's capabilities; e.g., I imagine the gov't will argue that 130 days was necessary in order to execute the search, and/or that they need to retain the data so that they might one day be able to execute the search.


> Isn't that why the FBI made such a big fuss about Apple not "cooperating" to backdoor devices?

They did a hell of a spin job grandstanding about the "impossibility" of cracking iPhones (protip: it never has been), but the FBI only made a stink about it because they can't crack the phones without paying Cellebrite a ton of money to develop new 0-days, which in the end is exactly what they ended up having to do. If Apple would factory-backdoor the things, the FBI could crack them themselves.

Every LE department has been handing seized iPhones over to Cellebrite for years for important enough cases. LE don't want to have to rely on a third-party (and foreign) contractor with a service monopoly anymore.


Here's the motion: https://regmedia.co.uk/2018/08/23/lazojamotion.pdf

A few interesting aspects:

* Lazoja is suing over the data, not (just) the physical device (Her phone was already returned to her.) Also, she is making additional arguments that the duration of retention for both the device and the data on it are unreasonable. I hope at least one of these claims succeeds; even if warrantless border searches are permissible, retaining hdd/sdd dumps should not be allowed.

* The motion mentions several times that the device contained persona, private information including "pictures of her in a state of undress, as well as privileged communications with her counsel". She requested all data (and especially this data) be deleted and the response was radio silence.


> I don't know what to attribute the area of lower-age married fertility in eastern CO + western KS to, or other scattered areas.

I would lump in KS/eastern CO with OK and with Missouri minus KC/STL/JC.

So three or four regions:

* The bible belt - the black belt

* Mormons

* The lower midwest and "eastern west" (e.g., eastern CO but also maybe even to some extent parts of NV, the Dakotas, and the rural eastern partns of the PNW). Maybe this is two groups that sort of blend at their boundaries?

No two places are exactly the same but that last grouping makes at least as much sense as the bible belt. IMO, at least.

I'm not a demographer or anything, but I bet that you could explain some of the cultural differences between the bible belt and the lower midwest+eastern west in terms of historically dominant congregations/denominations of Christianity. (And also some other things, most notably slavery.)


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: