Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more throwawayjava's commentslogin

> The ones that are able to pick up coding early just don't bother. They get hired through their family's network

Heh. Indeed. Only an idiot would be born into a family without a strong professional network ;-)

Less sardonically, I did have this option after high school (although not through a family network). Fortunately, I took full advantage before finishing school and did a ton of freelancing plus an internship. I noticed, before it was too late, that the sort of software engineering work available without a degree was not going to keep me happy for 30+ years.

This is the advice I give bright young students (as opposed to those who merely have family connections): make certain that you're not going to become unbelievably bored by your late 20s.

If you can get a job doing web dev out of high school, you can land a job doing something super fun like self-driving after college and you can write your own job description with a phd.

Your advice is good for kinda dumb kids from well-networked families, but IMO terrible advice for actually really intelligent kids. They will become super bored with the sort of software development that's available without spending a few years getting a good university-level grounding in mathematics and natural sciences. You can do that without going to college but it's still a four-year full time job...

> I'd love to see data on Google employee's education levels over time.

I think you'd be disappointed; Google hires a ton of Ph.Ds and recruits heavily from tippy-top universities.


I was born on the west side of Chicago, grew up in Englewood. I got my first job at 14 at the grocery store my mother worked at as a clerk. I worked there for two years before I convinced the owner to let me look at their inventory system. I didn't even get paid extra for that job, he led me to another job where I got to do some web design and got paid right around the minimum wage. And if I hadn't taken that job? No funds for college, no idea that I was actually smart enough to go, etc.

You don't need a "strong professional network" to have your family help you find work, and I take offense to the implication that only affluent people have the means to support each other. There's no one stopping "bright young students" from getting their shoes dirty and finding someone who needs real work done. God knows there are enough kids already pushed away from programming by the elitist attitude you're displaying here. Most people can't afford to worry about what's "boring", they're focused on making sure they can survive. A degree is an expense that can be delayed until it's necessary.


> Most people can't afford to worry about what's "boring", they're focused on making sure they can survive

Isn't the point that kids (transitioning to adults) who can get the good jobs without college are going to be out of the "just trying to survive" category? They'll make enough money that they have time, and they are bright enough and motivated to learn enough that they are likely to get bored.

A better response would be that autodidacts are more likely to keep learning on their own, and therefore have less need of a college degree to develop the skills for self-driving car work or whatever else.


Yeah, more or less what I was getting at but I bit the throwaway bait. Live and learn. Thanks for clarifying.


I'm glad you got lucky.

> You don't need a "strong professional network" to have your family help you find work

No, but it certainly helps. Especially software development work.

Regarding the rest, your original comment singles out "really intelligent kids". I was largely replying to that description.

In general, advising people who fit that model to prematurely optimize so early in life is doing them a huge disservice.

A "really intelligent kid" can get college mostly paid for through scholarships and have the world at their feet after graduating.

The urge to take that dev job after high school is strong (been there), but it's generally a huge net loss for someone who is actually "really intelligent".

> Most people can't afford to worry about what's "boring"

I'm very concerned by your attitude that folks from modest means aren't capable of boredom, aren't capable of burnout.

I'm also saddened by the fact that you seem to take offense toward encouraging "really intelligent kids" to actually use that raw intellect just because they happen to come from a modest background.


> He seems to have jumped into the "online resources will cause the traditional university to fail" bandwagon a bit late.

This consulting firm advertisement is a very useful mental model, and I think MOOCs are probably on their way up and out of the trough of disappointment into the plateau of productivity: https://blogs.gartner.com/smarterwithgartner/files/2017/08/E...

> They won't be replaced by a disruptor, they will just no longer be able to crank out mediocre educational product to people who now realize that a Bachelor of Something Or Other from Podunk U isn't actually a ticket to the middle class.

This seems likely. My model for predicting college bankruptcy has exactly one input, which is this dataset: https://ifap.ed.gov/DefaultManagement/DefaultManagement.html


> This seems likely. My model for predicting college bankruptcy has exactly one input, which is this dataset: https://ifap.ed.gov/DefaultManagement/DefaultManagement.html

This is a good dataset. It's important to remember that while the top 100 schools dominate the conversation around college, many many students go to smaller or non-selective schools that have a very different setup.


> Why are the deadlines at an online school any less real than those at a physical school?

I'm not in education atm but have a lot of experience working with students.

This is a real psychological effect even if it's maybe hard for tech types to understand. I think it has to do with the fact that social pressure is avoidable online (you don't have to show up and face the teacher whose work you didn't do). That perception has a strong effect on students; they feel shame for not doing their work even when teachers don't really give a damn about whether they did their homework/project.

Maybe not impossible to overcome, but a real problem. Education disruptors ignore these sorts of strong psychological effects around education at their own peril...


It's the anonymity of a large university classroom that makes it possible to feel like it's acceptable to stop attending - my best attended classes were those where the professor knew my name. I imagine there would be worse absenteeism in online courses.


In practice, this is an extraordinarily delicate and dangerous process.

Suppose you are a CS professor at the sort of no-name university that this article is talking about.

Odds are, you're more than qualified for a lot of industry roles (and have former students who would hire you on without blinking). Also, those industry roles have much higher salaries than your teaching gig. However, you stay at No-Name U. because it's a pleasant life and you enjoy teaching.

Then admin comes along and chops half your tenured colleagues. Suddenly, No Name U. is a hellish place to work. Time to leave.

Now multiply that across all of the faculties that have private sector options.

Now notice that those are exactly the majors that are difficult to recruit faculty for in the first place [1] and, moreover, are exactly majors that students are interested in these days.

That's the risk. At universities, cutting back means firing people. And firing people means low morale. And low morale means losing exactly the people who were going to power your turn-around story.

[1] https://cra.org/articles-addressing-shortage-of-cs-professor...


See also: why hasn't any car manufacturer purchased an auto insurer and use on-car sensor suites to generate fine-grained behavioral risk profiles?

To some this may sound like a dystopian invasion of privacy, and I probably would not opt-in to such a system. But the alternative for young men is massively subsidizing other young men's stupid choices... which IMO is even more dystopian.


The statistics about masters and professional degrees are mostly irrelevant; those aren't research degrees and, although there are some exceptions, people with those degrees don't publish science.

1.77% of the 25+ population has a doctorate degree. Even among those, a huge amount are not PhDs and are not really research-focused. E.g., go read the CV of the typical University of Phoenix doctorate holder.

Furthermore, it's worth noting that the world got a lot more complex since the mid-20th century. The entire field of Computer Science happened, for example.


Definitely great points. On the other hand, even when you really lowball the numbers - I do think the point remains. 1.77% is 3.5 million people with doctorates in the USA alone. Perhaps we can see this issue manifest is something more directly quantifiable. Postdoctoral researchers tend to be some of the most highly educated and ostensibly skilled individuals in our population. Yet an average postdoc [1] will tend to earn [much] less than a mailman [2]. It seems difficult to explain this outside of a severe oversupply. And should the rate of people pursuing doctorates be increasing, which seems to be the case, I think we can expect things to get even more silly both in terms of compensation as well as output quality.

[1] - https://grants.nih.gov/grants/guide/notice-files/NOT-OD-15-0...

[2] - https://www.bls.gov/oes/current/oes435052.htm


First, I'm generally skeptical that "the market" is accurately pricing the value of work produced by either postdocs or federal mail carriers.

Second, a postdoc is still a training position. Medical residents are also not paid much better than mail carriers either.

Third, postdocs select for two types of people: those who want R1 professorships and those who need a position to stay in the country. Both of those groups drive down wages. I.e., it's sort of meaningless to compare a group of people who are working for the money to a group of people who are working for a shot at a seat in the upper tier of a tournament-style profession.

Fourth, both annual and lifetime earnings of PhD holders (at least in STEM) continue to outperform high school graduates (including mail carriers).

There's an oversupply of people interested in R1 faculty positions, but that doesn't mean there's a oversupply of phds per se. The labor market seems to absorb these people quite readily and at apparently high salaries as soon as they decide to quit academia.


The market is not created by some third party. It simply represents the meeting point between what people are willing to buy for and what people are willing to sell for. That postdocs are willing to work for scraps relative to their skill level is indicative that supply has gone way beyond demand. For instance software developers also face similar issues of what you're mentioning with lower wage foreign workers willing to accept much less thus driving wages down, yet nonetheless high demand keeps wages high.

This is not particularly controversial and some have even suggested that starting to increasingly restrict the number of graduate students admitted could be the right path forward, as mentioned in this article [1] from John Hopkins: These and other suggestions for career preparation make one implicit assumption: that the nation needs the current number of biomedical scientists. A radically different approach to balancing the biomedical workforce equation would be to simply reduce the “supply” — that is, admit fewer students into science graduate programs. The article ends on what was apparently supposed to be an up beat note suggesting that instead of such draconian measures, perhaps we can look to people who are doing things like aiming to go teach high school science, with a doctorate.


And on the other hand you see things like https://cra.org/articles-addressing-shortage-of-cs-professor...

Just like there's a glut of wordpress plugin authors and a shortage of ML experts, different fields of academia have different levels of supply/demand.

Also, USPS really is not a prototypical example of free labor market: those salaries/pensions/benefits will be a lot smaller if/when usps privatizes...


I never understand why there's this thinking that more education "should" lead to a higher salary. It's not borne out by either theory or practice. I've heard several PhD's complain that they don't earn as much as someone with not degree at all. Is it something that PhD candidates tell themselves to get through the misery?


It comes down to supply versus demand. If what somebody learns in increasingly advanced education has any practical benefit then it would imply that they would have a practical skill that few other people would have.

Of course this is premised on the rarity of supply, which is no longer really true with millions of phds and growing out there. And it's also premised on the existence of a practical and meaningfully valuable skillset gained in the process of obtaining the doctorate which is I think reasonable, but still certainly debatable -- and at the minimum going to be contingent on what/where somebody studies.


> But it would seem reasonable to me if there were adjacent experts. What do engineers or chemists want to see in physics?

A natural experiment in this already exists: there are interdisciplinary journals and conferences with heterogeneous editorial boards. From the outside looking in, I suspect mostly what happens is that either people stick to reviewing the subset of papers from their own community or else do a poor job of reviewing papers from outside their own community.

> But if nobody outside a field cares about a line of research, or trusts a line of research, then maybe that's a bad line of research.

I'm skeptical; a lot of research is useless until it's groundbreaking, and the phase shift is rather late in the development.


Wouldn't those drones have to be completely autonomous -- not merely unmanned -- in any conflict with a real peer (e.g., Russia or China)?

And if so, are we there yet, technologically speaking? I.e., not just peacetime autonomy but actually dealing with a combat situation -- possibly with friendlies in the skies -- completely autonomously? My impression the last time I talked with a uniform about this was that the answer is still no.


The drones do not need to be fully autonomous. See https://www.realcleardefense.com/articles/2014/11/05/is_a_mi...


> once that remote role is established there's enormous pricing pressure from literally every other worker on the planet

This is the important point.

> freelancers without any deep connection to any one company or city. This is happening... but very, very slowly since most workers are terrified of such an idea.

That's because outsourcing and freelancing are mostly a mechanism for fleecing labor. Workers SHOULD be terrified of this.


tl;dr: Everyone is different. Don't be that weirdo who tries to push advice from random internet listicles on people.

Aside: if a board member tells you that you don't need a raise because you can use fucking coupon books, and you don't immediately get extremely offended, then maybe you're under-rating common sense and over-rating "rationalism"...


What is the value in being offended, like, ever? Surely if you could genuinely acheive your goals by leveraging coupon books, wouldn't that be worth considering? And, if after consideration, you Vickie it's not a viable substitute to a raise, you'll have an understanding of why it won't work beyond "well it offended me". Assuming that the math work or such that using coupons would result in the same outcome from the perspective of your bank statement, the most likely reasons I can think of are either status (you don't get any from using coupons, but you do for having a higher salary), or the externalities if putting a coupon book habit into place and the overhead of actually using them.

Of course the problem in the article was really one of communication. If the only problem to be solved was "keeping up with inflation" then coupon books could be a solution... once, until inflation continues and overcomes the buying power provided by the coupons. However it's a communication problem because the problem isn't "keep up with inflation", it's "maintain a consistent quality of life despite inflation". The latter would have meant the overhead of the coupons was a non starter unless they actually increased QoL beyond merely overcoming the impact of inflation on my back statement, which, they don't.

It's a bit of a ramble as I've written it here, but this is the approach I find valuable (not saying you should do the same, only that I find it works well for me), and I would never take the time to do this kind of thinking if I rejected ideas that "should offend me" without consideration.


> What is the value in being offended, like, ever?

It's a good bullshit detector. Instead of wasting time dealing with my board member's asinine suggestions, I can study interview questions and get a job at an employer that doesn't suck.

An employer who suggests coupon books in lieu of CoL adjusted salaries is probably out-of-touch or manipulative in a lot of other ways. Call me irrational, but I don't want to spend my days working for a super manipulative employer...

> Surely if you could genuinely acheive your goals by leveraging coupon books, wouldn't that be worth considering?

Sure. But in lieu of raises that keep up with CoL? Hell No.

> you'll have an understanding of why it won't work beyond "well it offended me".

Again, I suggested common sense!

Until I start seeing 2 for 1 mortgages, 1/2 off gasoline, BOGO surgeries, and 25% off tuition in coupon books? Well, it doesn't even take a spreadsheet for me to know that the things moving my CoL up aren't stocked in the Target or grocery stores...

Again, hyper-rationalism that distracts you from using common sense is silly.

> However it's a communication problem because the problem isn't "keep up with inflation", it's "maintain a consistent quality of life despite inflation".

CoL is a quantitative measure of QoL. I'm having a really hard time imagining situations where inflation in the face of stagnant wages doesn't translate into lower QoL. Especially for folks who work for a living.

> and I would never take the time to do this kind of thinking if I rejected ideas that "should offend me" without consideration.

So you would really response neutrally to your employer handing out coupon books instead of annual raises?

Then you're being had.


> I suggested common sense!

Common sense is far from infallible and in the face of an apparent in-good-faith suggestion I'm willing to question my common sense rather than follow it blindly. Note that this isn't the same as ignoring it, I'm just willing to admit that I might be wrong to start with.

> Until I start seeing 2 for 1 mortgages, 1/2 off gasoline, BOGO surgeries, and 25% off tuition in coupon books?

If I were really offered coupons as a solution to CoL, I would look into if such things existed. Sometimes what exists if you care to look for it can surprise you.

> So you would really response neutrally to your employer handing out coupon books instead of annual raises?

Realistically I would react as follows:

A) Immediate surprise and perhaps some incredulity depending on how the suggestion was delivered, but still thank them for the suggestion and let them know I would consider it.

B) Knowing basically nothing about using coupon books in this context, I'd take a few tens of minutes to look into how viable such a solution would be.

C) Conclude that while potentially useful in isolation, the overhead involved in implementing the suggestion wipes out the usefulness.

D) Return to my employer and inform them that their suggestion is not a viable solution and that I wish to continue salary negotiations in good faith.

This whole process would take less than a day.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: