Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more throwawayjava's commentslogin

> People at the low end of the market are already scratching for jobs and they're running out of higher land to run to.

It just hit me that the Mythical Man Month might have entail pretty important consequences for the future of mass (un)employment.


Huh. My impression was always that "universal prediction" got replaced by various branches of statistics, ML theory, and probability theory, each considering more specific questions that used to fall under a single umbrella?

Perhaps a best comparison is "cybernetics", which doesn't get funding these days except, of course, for the billions upon billions of dollars thrown at robotics, self-driving, factory automation, and so on.


It's fascinating to me how some of these "cures" continue to persist with modernized marketing script. See e.g. some of the claims made about essential oils ([1] contains a concise list for example), many of which were thought to be curative in antiquity mostly because of their powerful aromas:.

[1] https://www.fda.gov/iceci/enforcementactions/warningletters/...


The problem is that there are only few controlled trials for herbs and supplements, mainly because there is no money to be made because the substances can't be patented. If company A finances a controlled trial, then company B can just copy the claims.

Another problem is that these herbal cures may work initially (through placebo effect or a real mechanism), and then stop working. However, at that point the word has already been spread. This is especially troubling in the internet age, where people post reviews after one day of trying something.


There are many quack remedies and elixirs that have been around forever and long ago obtained protected status with government regulators.


Of these, the following are attributable to "static variables become dynamic" (and highly nonlinear at that...):

- Your stopping distance can effectively change every few feet

- A foot of snow accumulation may be transferred from the roof of the car in front of you to the windshield of your car with little to no warning

The following are hard planning problems:

- Lane lines cease to be a thing, even if you can see them, you're better off not following them

- Stoplights also mostly become a guideline, it's sometimes safer to run them than spin out

But these are just damn hard and probably the true limiting factors:

- Signage or signalling may or may not be visible at all

- Other cars or pedestrians may or may not be visible at all even in daylight

But I'm not an expert on perception so... maybe that's my bias showing.


The one glimmer of hope that I have is that I am literally incapable of driving in the snow without substantial software assistance, and that's true for literally every other human I know.


I learned to drive on snow and ice in the midwest in a stick-shift car from the '70s.. of course, I would rather have traction control and ABS, but it can certainly be done (and it was for many years before the modern conveniences)


Sure, people could learn how to drive without software assistance.

Just like people could learn how to drive a stick shift.

But most people (at least in the US) don't know how to drive in a stick shift or how to navigate snow without ABS and TCS.


I think everyone should learn how to drive in the snow without ABS and the like - just like I did, and I'm 30. The car was $400, front heavy, and had rear wheel drive Learning when you should be applying gas, when you should simply take your foot off, and when you should brake (rarely!) in icy conditions is hard to learn otherwise.


You and the people you know may just not be suited for driving in those conditions. Mountain areas in California have plenty of people capable driving in some serious snow with older cars, ABS is usually the only thing they have, no traction control or other software help. Anecdotal, of course, but so is your comment.


> You and the people you know may just not be suited for driving in those conditions

...northern Wisconsin gets its fair share of snow.

> ABS is usually the only thing they have

I think you've just agreed with me. ABS and TCS are exactly the systems I was referring to, and most of today's drivers have never encountered a car that doesn't at least have ABS.

I've driven a car without ABS or TCS in the snow. It's extremely difficult. Kind of similar to driving a stick shift for the first time. The idea is simple, but getting it into muscle memory enough that you're not constantly making mistakes is non-trivial.


Some basic knowledge of traction and momentum go a long way. Your car will generally go the way it is heading, as far as it can slide. Every time I see people lose control in the snow and ice, it is because they're driving with their brakes and not their momentum.


How did people survive before ABS and traction control?

It's not that bad. You just dial back your risk taking to reflect the situation.


Frankly, many of them didn't. Highway deaths have come down a lot since the invention of ABS.


People not driving drunk less and wearing seat belts more has a heck of a lot more do with it.


I don't disagree. Tons of factors contribute to gradually making highways safer over time.


Is that with proper winter tyres or not ? With good tyres you can drive in pretty bad conditions.


Snow tires are a big help for getting going. They are much less help for stopping.


To the contrary, "winter tires" actually have comparable benefits for stopping. Here's are the first three findings (of ten) from a recent University of Michigan report:

Finding #1: The main benefit of winter tires is improved tire adhesion, braking and cornering performance–not acceleration performance.

Finding #2: Winter tires provide improved traction on roads that are below 7 °C (45 °F) even when snow and ice are not present.

Finding #3: Stopping-distance performance of winter tires on packed snow is typically about 35% shorter than all-season tires and 50% shorter than summer tires.

http://umich.edu/~umtriswt/PDF/SWT-2016-10.pdf


I agree, but "winter tires" are quite different from "snow tires".

Moreover, I was implicitly assuming that the stopping would be on snow, and not packed snow but, say, just snow as it fell although maybe a minute ago to several days ago.

For stopping on wet or slushy streets or just, say, 1-2 inches of snow, then, sure, "winter tires" not only help stopping but likely are better than snow tires.

But when my driveway has 8" of fresh snow, to get out I need snow tires, tire chains, or a tractor to pull me out. Then in stopping, say, from 30 MPH in such snow, nothing helps much except tire chains and there are questions about those.

Again, what is good about snow tires is that the big bumps on the tread let the tire, when it is spinning trying to drive the car, dig into the snow, kick it backwards out of the way, and let the rubber meet the road. For that, the aggressive tread, with the bumps, is essential. But the bumps work because the tire is spinning and digging, and that action won't work for stopping unless, say, going forward with, somehow, the drive wheels spinning in reverse.

The advantages of "winter tires" are how the tread cuts through water and thin layers of snow and has softer rubber with a better coefficient of friction when the rubber does meet the road.


I have driven in 8" of fresh snow with winter tyres, more than once, they work well. I do remember my grandparents having tyres with deep treads but that kind of thing isn't common in Europe.


This is so incorrect it hurts.


My point is clear if just consider a little of how snow tires work: The main point is the big bumps in the tread. These big bumps permit spinning drive wheels to dig down in the snow to find some traction, maybe the hard surface below. This digging down has the bumps grab a lot of snow and throw it back and out of the way and let the tires get down, through the snow into some traction. Ordinary tires just spin and throw far too little snow. Works great.

But in stopping, there is no such "spinning" or "digging". Instead, all the snow tires can do is roll or slide.

So, snow tires help a lot in going but not much in stopping.

Typically get into winter car wrecks from not stopping, not from not going.

So, once snow tires have you going, be darned careful about stopping -- the risk is not stopping, and snow tires aren't much help because the lugs don't get a chance to dig and throw snow.


>"My point is clear if just consider a little of how snow tires work: The main point is the big bumps in the tread. These big bumps permit spinning drive wheels to dig down in the snow to find some traction, maybe the hard surface below. "

That's not how snow tires work. Not at all. Independent of the design. And no, they don't 'stop' the way you describe either.


Modern snow tyres don't have big bumps in the tread.


The ones on my car do.


> "Capitalism" is totally orthogonal to this

The rest of your post fails to substantiate this claim. Concretely, the "this" that you claim is orthogonal to capitalism is that:

>> When [social benefit of a service is completely misaligned aligned with the profit of realizing that benefit], they may pretend to do a job while they are actually doing a very different one.

Unsurprisingly, this is not a big problem for economic systems that do not reward profit-making. It is certainly true, as you note, that there are other ways in which the distribution of reward warps behaviors even in systems that aren't organized around profit-making.

But the problem of social benefit being misaligned specifically with profit-making is very much a quintessentially capitalist problem. Witness e.g. the fact that capitalist systems always end up realizing and attempting to solve this problem with a patchwork of laws and regulations.

Also, consider that your comments about psychology are mostly comments about your own biases and value systems. People who grow up and are successful in other political/value systems tend to say similar things about their own milieu.


> The rest of your post fails to substantiate this claim.

Re-reading what you posted I have to agree with this.

>Unsurprisingly, this is not a big problem for economic systems that do not reward profit-making.

There are few examples of such systems and they are extremely unstable, there are certainly no examples surviving more than a hundred years or so.

> Witness e.g. the fact that capitalist systems always end up realizing and attempting to solve this problem with a patchwork of laws and regulations.

All systems end up solving all problems with a patchwork of laws and regulations, except the problems that go away by themselves, or the problems that are not addressed at all.

> But the problem of social benefit being misaligned specifically with profit-making is very much a quintessentially capitalist problem.

Again, this is just a tautology. Above you effectively define capitalism as the system that rewards profit-making. So any feature of any system that is specific to profit making can only exist in capitalism in the structure you set up, so it's not a meaningful claim at all.

> Also, consider that your comments about psychology are mostly comments about your own biases and value systems.

No, this is simply not the case. If you think that mammals don't inherently have a concept of personal property you should see how my dog reacts when the cat is sleeping in her bed. We have to spend countless hours teaching children to share, not because it is natural for them, but because what is natural for them is not adaptive to life in a society. Our social structures have evolved much faster than our biology.


This isn't a very helpful answer for students at that level. It's necessary to say these words at some point, but without lots of examples students will have no idea what "good argument", "follows trivially from the last", or "counts as trivial" mean.

The only method I've seen work for a large set of students is to show lots of examples of what "good" and "not good" versions of "show your work" look like. Preferably on problems that look similar to the homework problems. And emphasize this during lectures.

E.g. after doing a derivation on the board: "by the way, this is what I expect to see when I say 'show your work' on a <insert problem type> problem."


I think an even broader generalization can be made, that I only learned by accident as a student: A huge part of classroom education is learning to communicate knowledge by imitating the teacher.

Nobody ever explicitly tells you this, but a few lucky students guess it at some point, preferably long before they get to college.

Teaching is an art. To some extent, "show your work" is an art as well. The techniques of art are never perfectly well defined, and are always somewhat arbitrary, but people do manage to learn it. Learning an art by imitating the masters is as old as the hills.

Perhaps my biggest frustration while teaching the algebra course, was not that I was confused about "show your work" means, but that there was such a gaping hole in the preparation of my students.


The German beer example is funny and seriously dates the article.

Turns out that "how to get rich" (as opposed to stay rich) in American beer making between 1999 and 2018 was 100% to copy the German model. Regional and microbreweries soared from ~4 bbls ~22 bbls between 2004 and 2017.

And that definitely wasn't the result of "government intervention". It was the result of people realizing they should be able to make and drink good beer without flying to Germany with empty suitcases...


I think a major factor in the rise of the micro-brew in the US was removal of "government intervention". Brewing your own beer was illegal from Prohibition until Congress and Carter changed the law and 1978. Home brewing was no longer outlawed and now one can legally brew up to 100 gallons of beer a year without paperwork. Much easier to get interested in brewing beer if you can easily do it legally.


Turns out the Germans are actually looking to revise a 500-year-old law defining beer. You see, the Americans have developed a taste for flavored craft beers, often from these same microbreweries, and exported it worldwide... Meanwhile, in Germany, beer is legally defined as being made solely of barley, hops, water, and yeast. The time-honored German beer industry can't keep up with the shifting tastes.


My understanding was that Belgium has always been big on a huge variety of non-traditional beer styles; lambic beers, champagne beers, dubbel, tripel, quadrupel, etc. I would think that would be a much closer and longer-term influence than the craft beer movement in the US. I've never been over there but really want visit those two countries specifically for the beer.

One of the things I really like about beer is that its moderate shelf-life means it doesn't transport well. Everyone who goes to Ireland has some sort of variation of, "I don't even like Guinness, but it's amazing and completely different over there." It doesn't help that beers like Newcastle, Becks, and Heineken use clear or green bottles that ruins them more quickly. I've heard anecdotes from Australians who get their hands on American craft brews and were disappointed by off flavors--but later find out it's because it was skunked or stale in transport.

I feel like that moderate shelf life keeps local beers local and makes traveling to new areas interesting.


I don't know if it is like this across the entire US, but at least here in the Pacific Northwest, every small scale brewery seems to offer a choice between an IPA or... another IPA. In this regard, I'd much rather the choice among a Pinkus Alt, a Koeztritzer schwartzbier, or a Bitburger, even if they do outwardly appear outdated following a 500-year old law.


I really dislike most all IPAs. I hear the hop craze has been much worse on the west coast. I hate that the choices are often three IPAs or a pilsner--but that seems to be what sells.

I am grateful that places like Stone, known for their IPAs, has a good Stone Smoked Porter...it seems fairly popular, but much less widely distributed. Same with Alaskan Brewing; they have a good Smoked Porter, and it's been around for years, but it's "Limited Edition" and harder to find.

I feel like IPAs have slowly started changing from "punch you in the face with tree sap" to more floral hop varieties, which I like more.


>I hate that the choices are often three IPAs or a pilsner

It often worse than that - three IPAs, a "Pale Ale," a "Golden Ale," a "double IPA," a "Hazy Pale," a "Fresh hop Ale," and another IPA. Then they throw in a hoppy gose just to be edgy.

It's cool, I get it; there are a lot of beer drinkers who like a heavy hop flavor, and they are often passionate and outspoken about their beer. But I about lost it when I went into a place and ordered a schwartzbier that had the flavor profile of an IPA. There is a rich tapestry of beers, for all palates, and I really hope US brewers get back to realizing that.


IPAs are definitely a very popular type of beer, but I don't think I've ever seen a brewery that only does IPAs.


In the summer it can be a struggle to find something that's not an IPA or a mass market pilsner around here. My wife hates IPAs and this is a frequent complaint.


Labeling it as something other than Beer seems like an easy compromise.


Heck -- label it Bier for real beer, and Beer for beer with extra crap.

(Disclaimer: I pretty much dislike all beers I've tried, so I don't have a horse in the race)


Barley wine, malt liquor, grain champaigne?


> On the other hand, I've known a few people who are able to clock in and clock out, do a competent job, and not get too stressed about stuff. I'm still trying to figure out how they do it.

This is an amazing skill I only learned during a PhD, and only after burning out half way though.

Obviously, step 0 is clear boundaries and reasonable work hours. Clock out at 5 or 6 (or 7 or whatever -- point is, put in your 40 hours and leave).

After that, things get more difficult.

For me, the answer was to work out directly after work (so before the commute home even!) and to listen to an interesting audiobook/podcast during my workout.

That way, when I got home, I would have something on my mind other than work. Fortunately, my personality is such that as long as the audiobook/podcast was interesting, that's what I will focus on/think about the rest of the night.


Working out before going home works great for me, too. And it has the added bonus of helping you skip some of the traffic on that commute home by pushing the start time of that commute back a bit. Depending on where you live and when you work, I suppose.


> 2) When I asked the math professors how to explain "show your work," some of them bluffed and blustered, but none of them could give me a straight answer. At worst, I got, "they should just know."

It sounds like you were teaching calculus or maybe college algebra ("they should know" is actually good advice for the higher level mathematics courses -- most departments have a whole course that's more-or-less about how to write proofs).

At research universities, the tenure-track professors rarely teach anything below Calc II, and might not teach any Calculus courses at all. Certainly nothing below Calc I.

If you ad junct again, consider asking the other ad juncts/instructors instead. They're more likely to have lots of exposure to that university's demographic in a relevant course.


I'm not conceding that it's reasonable for a professor to answer something with "they should just know," but I think the issue here is that they seemed incapable of explaining it. It's one thing to say to a class "you should know how to $x, so I'm not going to teach it to you right now" but another entirely to be either unwilling or unable to explain exactly what they mean to a colleague.


Keep in mind that teaching is its own skill. Especially in universities, that skill can get awfully specific awfully fast.

In particular, for a TT professor at an R1, odds are extremely good that they've NEVER taught anything below calculus and may have never even been the instructor of record even for calculus courses! They were hired to do research and teach graduate/upper-level undergraduate courses.

Teachers that know how to explain and assess everything in a graduate analysis course with perfect clarity might not know how to handle the situation where a student doesn't know what it means to "show you work" in the context of calculating a derivative or solving a linear equation. In fact, they might not have even thought about learning/teaching that material themselves since early high school or maybe even middle school. This doesn't make them a bad teacher. It just makes them a bad calc I/college algebra teacher. Which is okay -- teaching those courses is not their job and is not what they were hired to do.

So this is somehow a bit like complaining that a web programmer isn't particularly adept at kernel hacking. That doesn't make them a bad programmer, it just means they focus is elsewhere.

Again, most universities do hire experts in teaching the lower-level courses. They're just not typically tenure-track professors.


Indeed, the professors are either surprised or offended that the university even offers college algebra, which they obviously never had to take, and which they consider to be a few levels below remedial.

Admittedly, I was a math major in college, and was unaware of the existence of college algebra until I was hired to teach it.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: