Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more throwawayjava's commentslogin

A crucial distinction: Of total endowment distribution is VERY different from of total spending.

Tuition-dependent colleges and universities tend to look very different from their large endowment counterparts.


Yes. You can also integrate a recursively defined function(s). E.g., recall your undergraduate differential equations course.


not sure what this means?


It means that technique is taught in the undergrad course.


yes i'm asking which technique - the only thing i remember that vaguely resembles this is power series solutions


Lack of mid-distance transit is also a huge problem.

Mid-sized USA cities tend to have half decent transit around their urban core (often woefully under-served especially in cities that don't have either trains/subways or else dedicated right-of-way for buses, but none-the-less serviceable).

However, the thing that mid-sized cities almost uniformly lack in the US is any form of regional commuter rail.


We have regional commute rail in the SF Bay Area and in the NYC Metropolitan Region. It doesn't seem to have done much except drive up housing prices near rail stations and create silliness like 5-yr waiting lists for parking at them.

It seems clear that commuter rail is not a silver bullet. Housing density is probably what we really need.


It's both. Rail lets you be more flexible about where to put that density.


Counter-anecdotes: in Chicago (e.g., UP-N), Boston (e.g., Fitchburg), and much of Europe (e.g., many major cities in Germany), the commuter rail systems do take you out into very affordable areas.


I used to commute into SF from Redwood City with the Caltrain. If I couldn't have taken a bike with me on the train, it would have been impossible because the last mile at both ends was completely undoable with local buses.


They want collaboration and access to great minds, not influence. Also, every if they did want influence, the ivy pay would make even more sense bc the ivy tail wags the academic dog. Better to influence a generation of future faculty than one Dept of current ones...


"Collaboration and access to great minds" comes from influence. As does the opportunity to shape postdocs and graduate students - the generation of future faculty you're talking about.


The influence is no good if the research isn't high quality. There are other initiatives besides labs by Google.


You make the huge assumption that only elite institutions produce high quality research. Especially for narrow specialties, this isn't necessarily true either.


> A populace not subject to daily economic anxiety is more willing to tolerate less representation in government without there being widespread discontent.

No one has figured out the whole "prosperity without scary periods of scarcity" thing yet.

> almost always tracing back to economic anxiety, even when masquerading as xenophobia or racism.

Xenophobia has a bit of a chicken-and-egg relationship with economic anxiety.

Does the xenophobia cause economic anxiety, or does economic anxiety cause xenophobia? I don't think the answer is so straight-forward, especially this time around history's block. It's not like 2016 was the 1930's... even economically depressed parts of the country were doing better than they were for decades.

Are people anxious because they're xenophobic and believe that "those people" are out to get them where it hurts (for them, the pocket book)? Or, are they anxious because they're afraid of losing their way of life and the objectively most likely cause of that loss is "those people", thus causing xenophobia?


> but there are loopholes, and the developer was using them


If this were true, then other large patent holders would be toe-for-toe in spaces like web advertising. Spoiler: they're not.


Woah! Two years of education changes someone's life!

...if only community colleges and branch campuses of state universities had VC marketing cash, we would hear these uplifting stories on the daily.


> Let's stop teaching lectures to undergrads in medieval style in 500 person lecture halls

Although I agree with this sentiment, you have to realize that the alternatives are either a) worse, or b) don't scale.

I prefer the ones that don't scale (small number of students in a class who get real continuous feedback and fully participate in the lecture). It works really well, but this model is enormously expensive compared to the 500 person lecture hall.

500 person lecture halls suck, but what's the scale-able, better alternative?

MOOCs aren't the answer -- that's just the old 500 person lecture hall model with a pause button. Woohoo. Plus, it doesn't actually solve the real problem, which is that you need the humans running the course anyway. For a well-oiled machine of a course, maybe 10% of the actual time spent on teaching is spent in the classroom. And for non-well-oiled courses, creating the MOOC and keeping it up to date is a hell of a lot of up-front cost, and with a lot of risk.

> and instead get them engaged in research as assistants right away.

I can tell that you haven't worked with lots of undergraduate students on research projects.

Most undergraduate students aren't ready to participate in research. Of those that are intellectually prepared, few have the grit/persistence required. Of those with the intellectual preparation and persistence, fewer still have the imaginative faculties to actually do research (as opposed to e.g. acting as a tech).

This is true even in very applied areas. You'd be surprised how few CS undergraduates would succeed at implementing something as simple as an experimental change to a kernel or a tweak to an ML algorithm.

At some point you simplify the research problem enough that it's indistinguishable from a course project or homework assignment. In fact, that's even where some course projects and homework assignments come from. But at that point, you're not "involving students in research", unless "doing homework or programming assignments" = "research" that is.

> We need more science and less "publish or perish" politicians posing as professors engaged in grant grabbing.

At times I have certainly felt this way about academia! But I could say similar rude things about every profession.

> Tweed jacket welfare recipients if you ask me.

There are ineffective people in every field, and most of them manage to stay more-or-less employed throughout their working years.


The two of you must have had a different experience than I. At least for my classes, fundamental stuff that hasn't changed in decades was taught in big lecture halls- single variable calculus, physics & chemistry 101, etc. Then as you advanced in your discipline, class sizes shrunk, all the way down to 5-10 pupils in some of the most specialized classes, which was where the close interaction with the teacher was most valuable.

Most undergraduate students aren't ready to participate in research. Of those that are intellectually prepared, few have the grit/persistence required.

More indirectly, few have any kind of serious investment in the research. In college I volunteered to help on a plant study. I was assigned to meticulously clean dirt from dried plant roots and weight each plant. For like four hours at a time. Thousands of specimens. It needed to be done, but I had no investment in the project aside from general excitement, so I just didn't care enough to suffer the drudgery week after week.


Yes, CS is a completely different beast for two reasons.

First, our intro-level courses are fairly stable but nowhere near as stable as Calculus or Physics intros. If you don't change your intro for a decade, it starts to show. Whereas I'm pretty sure my children will take more-or-less the same calc course that I took, and my calc book was pretty indistinguishable from my mother's. To really emphasize the point, my mother's CS course was done on punch cards...

And it's not just content. Student preparedness has been changing a lot lately. We reached "peak physics/calc" in high schools a long time ago (hell, my grandpa took calc in high school). But students showing up at university knowing how to program is relatively new for most institutions.

Third, enrollments have been increasing exponentially (yus, really exponentially) year over year (yes, every year) for close to a decade now (yes, a decade).

So. Yes, CS ed is very different from the more stable STEM fields, especially recently.


Your experience matches mine in CS; the large lecture halls were only used by a handful of early required courses that bottlenecked the students, a basic prerequisite for a variety of other courses all done in smaller classrooms.


> Most undergraduate students aren't ready to participate in research.

Part of the reason may be that most undergraduate students didn't enroll to university to do research; they came for the degree they need to have a shot at getting better-paying jobs. Reintroducing vocational schools and making university research-focused again could help increase research-readiness of undergraduates.


I would argue that if you come to a university for science or engineering, you come to do research. whether that is through working in a lab or internships, extracurricular work is the most important factor in getting the high-paying job in your field.

CS may be different, but all the recruiters I have talked to, and all of the people doing actual hiring don't care about the degree, they care about projects, and whether you are going into academia or industry, your undergraduate degree is not nearly enough to land a job.


Clinton was a hawk but think about what you're saying.

You really think she would have drone bombed an embassy in the heart of fucking London? Come on. That's clearly delusional.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: