This is false because many fields do care very much. E.g. medicine (and not just mds), law, the patent bar, and many engineering fields care about accreditation. Even degrees from highly acclaimed universities aren't enough if the degree isn't accredted by the right body (eg ABET for the patent bar).
This is also not relevant because, in practice, places with good reputations are typically accredited.
I would agree with this. Many fields care a lot about accreditation.
I do think there are people that don't care, but I suspect they also don't care about the degree as well. They are more concerned about the real world performance of the individual. I think you'd be hard pressed to find someone in the above mentioned fields like that.
I also think that a Math degree falls into both of those "ideals", but more so on the side of accreditation is important.
For example Stanford CS is not ABET accredited, or nationally accredited at all. Do people get turned away for having a Stanford degree because ABET haven't rubber stamped it?
Probably not often because software companies don't care about PEs and because Stanford CS graduates are unlikely to apply for positions in non-CS fields (unless they also have an education in those fields).
But yes, there are a lot of jobs out there that even Stanford CS graduates aren't qualified for.
Note: the patent bar's eligibility rules have special exemptions for CS degrees that are not ABET accredited but do satisfy other criteria, so many Stanford CS graduates will automatically qualify for the patent bar based upon those alternative standards. But that doesn't mean the patent bar doesn't care about accreditation.
And it's worth noting that any institution with a half-decent reputation has some form of accreditation. Again, this was the second point of my post -- accreditation is actually does do a very good job at over-approximating the set of educational institutions whose degrees mean something.
Most everything mentioned here that's administered through a university is "valid" in the usa and canada. Many Indian universities are also recognized by USA and Canadian firms/universities (eg certainly the IITs).
Note, however, that you won't get e.g. OPT from an online degree.
Like it or not, in the USA cash is king. It is what people optimize for.
If you FIX a highly-rewarded measure for a nontrivial time period, the "take best comers" approach kicks ass. As long as your fix apriori and them measure. That's what we see here. GDP was defined before current immigration policy was set, after all.
If we have faults, they are in our system for doling out rewards. Not in the color/creed/religion of the people we let compete for those rewards.
If you want better social cohesion, design social systems to REWARD that cohesion. Then, communities will offer what you seek. To your great surprise, I suspect, those communities will be highly diverse.
Otherwise, you end up with sub-populations that severely under-perform on actually measured metrics and go out to search for bullshit alternative (under/arbitrarily)measured metrics by which they win. Again, that's what we see in your comment.
I want to suggest that perhaps those students in CA really were that much better. Not in terms of raw talent, but in terms of the previous 10+ years of their life.
I learned a lot in PhD school, but the most important thing I learned was that others' high school experiences really did prepare them for academic rigor and business success in ways that mine decidedly didn't.
The George Dantzig case actually isn't a counter-anecdote to the XKCD observation, because Dantzig was already a graduate student in a phd program at a top statistics department when he solved those problems.
XKCD isn't criticizing the positive mindset of naive-but-gifted researchers; it's criticizing the attitude of experts in one field that their expertise necessarily gives them unique and powerful insights into solving problems in another field.
Perhaps a better counter-anecdote would be all of the mathematicians in the 1950s - 1980s who solved hard program design problems with little or no experience actually programming computers. That really was a counter-example to the XKCD mentality: a bit of mathematics was far more useful than knowing the instruction set of the latest IBM mainframe...
To clarify, that quote is not something the journalist wrote. It's the opinion of Jarle Brivik [1]. It is also a statement that was made in the context of a few current moonshots aimed at solving cancer, and is referring specifically to concrete issues Brivik has with the paradigms underpinning those concrete attempts.
In particular, the quote is not meant as some sort of claim about the metaphysics of cancer or anything ridiculous like that. Rather, it's a (perhaps not so eloquently stated) way of pointing out that the mathematical and biological models underlying the current (and again, concrete) moonshot attempts fail to account for certain important issues and that this strongly suggests that those models are not going to result in cures.
The rest of the article summarizes some of Brivik's warrants, which are well thought-out. The claim is that the models currently used are fundamentally incapable of explaining how certain environmental factors effect cancer and the rest of the body, and that these environmental factors are important for understanding how to "solve" cancer because cancer evolves over time in often unexpected ways. The article points out, for example, that there are modeling assumptions baked into Microsoft's approach that are empirically falsifiable.
Finally, I'll just re-iterate that the argument made in the article is made in the context of current proposed/ongoing moonshots, so various comments about nanobots at the like are totally off-topic.
The article is not about science fiction. The topic is not whether maybe one day in the far future we might have enough knowledge about cancer cells to take a purely mechanistic approach toward curing cancer. Whether, the article is about the allocation problem in real science, today, and makes an argument against the efficacy of the approach taken by some current, concrete, well-funded moonshots.
> so they're supposed to give you a chance to pick up your litter to avoid the fine but some don't do that.
That seems like an ineffective mechanism. Just litter and pick it up in the very rare cases where you get called out.
If I were council dictator for a day, I would make the fines stiff and immediate but require that 100%^1 of the revenues are refunded to all residents at the end of each year.
That way there's still a stiff disincentive to littering, but no significant incentive for abusive/dishonest enforcement.
[^1]: (perhaps sans some low and more importantly fixed amount to cover enforcement costs)
Surgical robots -- at least the ones that actually exist and work today -- are designed more like traditional safety-critical robotics platforms and less like a one-off case study for a nice visualization/table for an end-to-end deep RL paper. There is no "the model".
A lot of scientific insights are obvious in hindsight. IMO especially in applied mathematics, but maybe that's just because it's a field I know well enough to notice.
A lot of ideas are obvious even without hindsight (again, especially in applied mathematics, and again, maybe that's just my bias). None-the-less, the person who said it first gets their name on the important idea.
There are lots of "<person's name> operator" and "<person's name> theorem" in big-but-not-core fields of (again, esp applied) mathematics where this phenomenon occurs.
I've been party to a lot of conversations that go something like "<person's name> idea or <person's name> technique is just '<fairly basic thing> applied to <fairly commonplace thing>' and it's stupid that it's named after <person's name>".
I always remind the speaker that this is good news -- one route to science fame is to just state the obvious loudly enough and early enough ;-)
> go to one of the Liberal Arts colleges, or non R-1 state schools, like any of the Cal States in California, or non-flagship schools in other states.
...and look at the instructor's salaries. PhD's from top universities who could easily make 300k+ in the private sector but instead take positions that pay 60k-70k. Even with tenure, that's a labor of love.
Blaming highly paid admins would be great, except that university presidents at teaching colleges are the highest paid (reminder: branch campuses and liberal arts colleges never have Div 1 sports programs) and still make $50k-100K less than a green phd out of a top 10 CS program (200k is good money for a president of a branch campus or liberal arts college -- and remember, that's typically a person with 30+ years experience and a uniquely positive track record).
I worry about what will happen to the American teaching college (public or private) over the next 50 years if the current war on college -- which this article typifies -- wins out in the public mind.
If you doubt a single word of this feel free to reply to this comment. I'm extremely familiar with both markets. When I say that (even tenure-track) CS teaching requires a 200k paycut, I really do know what I'm taking about.
> Blaming highly paid admins would be great, except that university presidents...
When people talk about the cost of university administration, they're not always talking about the cost of the most highly-paid, but rather the aggregate cost:
"Since 1980, the number of administrators per student at colleges has about doubled; on most campuses their numbers now match the number of faculty,” the study reads. “Here are some of their titles: senior specialist of assessment; director for learning communities; assistant dean of students for substance education; director of knowledge access services."
> Since 1980, the number of administrators per student at colleges has about doubled
I don't doubt that's true; I see it at my college. But I also see at my college that the percentage of students who need extensive administrative attention has shot up in the past ten years. (I teach at a SLAC, so if I have a concern about a student then I call an appropriate administrator and they genuinely try to see if the student is OK. For instance, not too long ago I called about a student and it turned out to be a suicide risk and my call and others prompted an intervention, and the student is OK. I don't know how many hours of administrator attention was clocked on this one person but I expect it was a lot.)
There may well be a need for more administrators these day. Not saying I agree, but I'm sure some people (like Jonathan Haidt) would say this is because we over-coddle young people – and by the time they reach college they are not as independent as students a generation ago.
Note: I am not at all saying this applies to suicide risks, which obviously are not new and which colleges have had support staff for going way back.
> some people (like Jonathan Haidt) would say this is because we over-coddle young people
I'm sorry, I don't know that person. But we try our best to deal with who we have in front of us. I don't know what else we can do, in good conscience.
I am not saying that all additional admins are accounted for by this kind of thing. I don't know enough about it.
(Actually the cost is a mystery to me but I've never been an admin of any kind.) I'm only saying that some of the increase I see on the ground is in response to trying to meet real needs.
Agreed. I think a big part of that is the expansion of access to the academy that we've seen since 1980. Applicants to Berkeley increased 4-fold from 1976 to 1986. (It's gone up another 4-fold in applicants and two-fold enrollments since then.) The increased applicant pool and enrollments probably means that a lot more less-well-prepared students were attending, and the schools staffed up administrative services to meet those students' needs:
https://academic-senate.berkeley.edu/sites/default/files/kar...
We've also added a lot of services for disabled students, transfer students, etc. All to the good, I would say give more students access to a quality education, but the services needed for 6,000 students of 80,000 applicants is way different from when they were enrolling 3,000 students of the 5,500 who applied.
I probably come from a very certain camp on these kinds of issues, but...
Most students are hardly adults. They look it, but they are not necessarily yet fully equipped to manage themselves.
And what if the people the same age who didn’t attend college— well, I would push for more and improved social programs to help them. Of course then you could reduce the staff at the colleges.
I’m all for being proactive about rising needs like social and mental health issues, but I also think a reactive response needs to take place in the interim.
The approach of “here’s a helpline phone number, now deal with it” hasn’t proven effective so far so why lean into it?
somewhat cynical perspective: maybe the long-term cost of a suicide on campus is greater than the cost to prevent them? one or two over the course of many years is sad, but probably not that damaging to the institution. on the other hand, if your school becomes an outlier, you probably start to feel it in the admissions department.
Yup. When i taught a class (contract) at a local U i had 6 supervisors, none of which taught students. I had a list of another dozen who while not direct supervisors could still command things (diversity coordinators, access to education people etc).
But when i was at law school my contracts prof was the semi-retired former dean and all the admin taught at least a couple courses. Admin was a secondary duty to teaching. That old school still exists in places.
I don't doubt any of it. The CS market is an outlier though, so I wouldn't make too many arguments based entirely on that. For someone with a decent degree in a biological or physical science, the pay cut for a tenure-track position compared to industry is not that bad. (The work-life balance and employment market may be worse, but that's a whole 'nother issue.)
> with a decent degree in a biological or physical science
Mathematics is as close to "humanities" as the STEMs get in terms of compensation and employment options for PhDs, and even top 10 mathematics PhDs can make 2x in the private sector with at least 2 years fewer opportunity costs.
Basically the only fields where what you're saying is true are the humanities and social sciences, but those aren't expanding programs or cost centers.
Work-life balance is one of those things that you would think would better in academia, but is often actually not.
The broader point is that outside of R1, prices mostly reflect the fact that for most students education doesn't scale very well and experienced human labor is more expensive than ever. Those are self-reinforcing, for obvious reasons. Case-in-point: the would-be educator who can't afford a 200k pay cut because of the loans they took out for their own education.
> The broader point is that outside of R1, prices mostly reflect the fact that for most students education doesn't scale very well and experienced human labor is more expensive than ever.
Education scales fine with motivated students or with mechanisms to help students with their motivation. I did a MicroMaster’s with EdX that covered ¼ of a Master’s degree. Now I’m doing a Master’s with SOAS, University of London. Exam and essay marking aside marginal costs per student are close to zero. MOOCs work with motivated students.
For students who are tackling subjects with steeper learning curves scheduling and project based learning seem to work very well along with initial selection. Lambda School is 40 hours a week for 30 weeks. It’s entirely online but the lectures are live so it’s cohort based and you are on the same schedule as the rest of the class. They have a university like method with TAs and lecturers, where the TAs can solve most problems. It seems to be a pretty good system, people have gone from lambda school to MicroSoft and Google.[1]
Education scales fine. The fact that it hasn’t been scaled yet means we’re getting started.
I do agree with your comment. Education scales fine as long as your students are independently motivated and have the study skills that help them help themselves. Unfortunately, that describes a surprisingly tiny fraction of the US college population.
Yeah, I think we largely agree. At just a 2x pay cut, and the potential to be an tenured scholar, there are plenty of people who want to try for it. It's also close to the height of the job market right now, with unemployment very low. That pay disparity may go down quite a bit during the next recession.
>The broader point is that outside of R1, prices mostly reflect the fact that for most students education doesn't scale very well and experienced human labor is more expensive than ever. Those are self-reinforcing, for obvious reasons. Case-in-point: the would-be educator who can't afford a 200k pay cut because of the loans they took out for their own education.
The challenge here is that for the 85% of students getting an education from a public school, is the increase in tuition costs they've seen due to increases in expenditures (which I haven't seen any supporting data for), or a decrease in state funding of tertiary education (which is wide-spread)?
what tier of liberal arts colleges are you talking about here? the president at the college I attended made over $400k base and that was five years ago.
"Robert Brown earned nearly $2.5 million in 2015, according to the most recent tax filings." (President of BU)
"Three other leaders had seven-digit earnings in 2015: Harvard President Drew Faust, who will retire at the end of the school year, earned $1.57 million; Northeastern President Joseph Aoun notched $1.45 million; and MIT President L. Rafael Reif took home $1.03 million."
Maybe the OP isn't talking about the same tier of school, or maybe Boston is an unusual place for university president salaries, but those numbers are pretty far from $200k.
None of those are even close to teaching colleges. MIT, Harvard, Northeastern, Boston University... those aren't just R1s, they're top-tier R1s. Located in one of the most expensive cities in the country, no less.
I'm talking about places with words like "south eastern" and "central" and "state" in their names. And SLACs with endowments below ~100M. In other words, I'm talking about the vast majority of universities and colleges -- the ones that aren't (literally) Harvard or MIT. Places that don't have phds programs, and maybe don't even have sizable masters populations.
Given that the student loan system and accreditation process already imply significant central planning, I think it is fair to ask if these places are net positive for society as a whole.
Conditional on them existing students are forced to attend in order to keep up in the credentialism race, but a supra-market force like the federal government could impose a more globally efficient solution.
If you look at california public payroll records for CSU system, the first few pages are dozens of people getting 400 to 500k altogether. Vice president of this and that, administrator IV, etc. But you're right that the people putting in insane hours and putting their hearts in are paid significantly less. (Still over 100k for assistant prof. Or department dean)
The only person making $400k+ is the Chancellor of the whole system, the majority of people making $300k+ are presidents of the individual CalState schools, and the administrators over $250+ are almost universally CFOs and senior executives at each school. Many presidents of the smaller schools are in the $200k range. You only start getting to non-executive administrators under $200k.
PS: There are people getting $400k-$500k total, but over $100k of that is benefits.
$90k (9 month salary) is the bottom 10th percentile for a starting assistant professor in CS. $200k (9 month) is the 90th percentile for a full professor with 16+ years.
This obviously varies by school and region, but $60k-$70k is what you would expect for an instructor at a very low rank school, which is not a position PhDs from top universities would be applying for.
My posts are all about teaching, as opposed to more research-oriented academic labor.
> $90k (9 month salary) is the bottom 10th percentile for a starting assistant professor in CS.
That's only because your data includes professors at R1s and also not including instructors at R1s. This is doubly misleading, since those professors you are including spend most of their time on research and those instructors you aren't including are the ones doing the bulk of the teaching.
And outside of R1, 90k is damn good for ast professors.
If you are teaching for a living, as opposed to doing research, $90k is in the upper 10th percentile at the asst prof rank, and $100k is a ceiling for tippy-top candidates at the asst prof rank.
> $200k (9 month) is the 90th percentile for a full professor with 16+ years.
...and is also bottom 10th percentile for wet-behind-the-top- ears top 10 PhDs, who don't have 16+ years experience on top of their 5+ year phd...
> This obviously varies by school and region, but $60k-$70k is what you would expect for an instructor at a very low rank school, which is not a position PhDs from top universities would be applying for.
Sure, but outside of top 10 $150k is still pretty typical industry salary for phds.
The same problem exists at every scale.
Your assertion is also fairly confusing; lots of smart people decide to teach at places where they can have the greatest impact, which is typically not a large-endowment private school...
There are literally hundreds of liberal arts/teaching colleges...
Also, Colgate definitely isn't in the tuition-dependent, take-all-comers mold of the vast majority of teaching-oriented colleges and universities in the USA. Their acceptance rate is below 30%, whereas most teaching-oriented colleges take 70+% of applicants (and draw from a much less well-prepared population of applicants to begin with).
This is false because many fields do care very much. E.g. medicine (and not just mds), law, the patent bar, and many engineering fields care about accreditation. Even degrees from highly acclaimed universities aren't enough if the degree isn't accredted by the right body (eg ABET for the patent bar).
This is also not relevant because, in practice, places with good reputations are typically accredited.