He's not saying that the total dev environment is bigger than the total prod environment. He's saying that this one cluster of dev machines is much bigger than other clusters of machines (dev or prod). that could be true while simultaneously having many more prod machines than dev machines.
The author explains: however there is one cluster that was built significantly larger than the others and hosted around 2,000 development environment workloads. (This was an artifact of the early days of running “smaller clusters, more of them”, when we were trying to figure out the right size of “smaller”.)
"“It will potentially require home-sharing sites like Airbnb and their hosts to comply with local hospitality rules in every city in the United States,” Stemler told PacerMonitor. “It could also make home sharing sites responsible under the Civil Rights Act and the American with Disabilities Act. They would also have to comply with just about any law or restriction that a local government maintains pertaining to hotels.”"
Typically, philosophers would not consider a belief about a formal system justified unless that belief is backed by a proof.
In software, for known behavioral specs, you don't have a real justification until you write a formal proof. Just because formal proofs are uneconomical doesn't mean there's some fundamental philosophical barrier preventing you from verifying your UI code. Doing so is not just possible, there are even tools for doing it.
So really, this is not a Gettier case, because in formal systems a true justification is possible to construct in the form of a mathematical proof.
An example of a Gettier case in a software system would be formally verifying something with respect to a model/spec that is a Gettierian correct-but-incorrect model of the actual system.
There are almost no software systems where we have true JTB (proofs), so there are almost none where Gettier cases really apply.
Uncertainty in software is more about the economics of QA than it is about epistemology or Gettier style problems, and that will remain true until we start writing proofs about all our code, which will probably never happen.
Rationality is not ideology, but epistemology and ideology are often closely related.
Also, it's not as if rationality is "above the fray", so to speak. Differing relationships to rationality are at the core of major differences between schools of thought in both international relations and economics, for instance.
you're leaving out publicly funded labs at universities, which is where e.g. Google's "garage" days were spent.
Public labs are nice for society because they're extraordinary cheap relative to their corporate counter-parts (grad student = 30k/yr with no benefits, research scientist = 200+k/yr with full benefits)
Kolmogorov had deep insight into bandwidth needed to send information, i.e. the limits of compression. Shannon showed the limits of communication over a noisy channel. CAP teased out constraints on distributed information processing systems over large distances.
Sure. But from none of this does it follow that "Policies that work at a local level don't scale to a Frederal level".
Or to put it another way, to the extent that we interpret local and federal and so on formally enough that they retain any connection to information theory, we're no longer talking about politics.
The words either have their political meaning or their formal meaning, but pseudomathematical sophistry that conflates formal and informal statements in the same breath leads to quackery and nonsense, which is exactly one of the article's critiques of libertarianism as a framework.
The CAP theorem occupies a similar place in pseudomathematics as Goedels theorems. An important result, but almost never for the reasons that someone attempting to use it to make a non-rigorous mathematical argument thinks it is...
I enjoyed this article because it provided a level-headed and analytical critique of a topic that is mired in politically charged emotion.
For example, sections 2.1 and 2.2 resonated with me because, as a mathematician, because I can plainly see how the algebraic structure chosen by Rothbard for representing utility is going to severely impact the reasonableness of his models.
There are several other compelling examples, where anyone who has done a bit of mathematical modeling can see that the neoclassical school of thought is simply providing better tools for achieving the desired outcomes.
To take your example, Section 3.1 critiques The Use of Knowledge in Society via a critique of Human Action (which was published by Mises nearly a decade after 1942). Many of the observations in Section 3 (and 3.1 especially) are directly relevant to The Use of Knowledge in Society.
Was this with room and board? FWIW, there are many college degrees in the USA that are in the $7k/yr range, and many of then were around $20k total prior to the last round of state-level austerity in the USA.
Getting a US college degree for under $20k is still very possible if you a) commute and b) do the first two years at a community college (typically closer to $2k/yr, or $18k-$21k for 2 years cc + 2 years state college).
With a bit more public subsidy (or differently targeted subsidy), many US colleges could be well within the $20k USD range for commuting students. And some courses of study already are.
Australians tend to stay in the same city for college, so room and board are generally not required. Most students live at home with their parents. All students have access to government assistance in the form of centrelink [1] (though centrelink is a beauracratic pain to get through), and out-of state students are entitled to more.
In terms cost, UNSW is one of the top universities in the country. (EDIT: this is an ambiguous sentence, I am sorry. I mean that UNSW is one of the top universities, and cost is still lower than many US universities) I understand that US college can be done on the cheap, but it's definitely not the norm. You can always find work arounds I'm sure, but I was just emphaising that going to a top uni for this price sans-hassle is very much the norm here.
On top of this, it's important to note that even minimum wage jobs here pay pretty well (the highest by buying power in the world [2]). Thus, even if you are doing university and working part time you can do ok.
For undergraduate studies, the federal government also subsidises classes at standardised rates depending on subject.
So no matter which university you go to you'll be paying the same "Commonwealth supported place" rate for your field of study. For engineering it's $9185/yr for what's usually a 4-year degree. [0]
Postgraduate study is strange because some universities charge full-fee, some offer commonwealth supported places for certain degrees, and some offer CSP as scholarships. My masters degree at UNSW for example was commonwealth supported so I only ended up adding $8k onto my loan for it.
Living in a dorm is not very common in Australia - atleast this was my experience in Sydney. I did not have many friends who lived on campus. Most students commute from home, and among my circle of friends most of us lived with our families.
Agreed. Although as someone who has studied in both the US and Aus (did an exchange semester at Georgia tech), I'd say that living on campus does have some benefits, socially and academically.
The author explains: however there is one cluster that was built significantly larger than the others and hosted around 2,000 development environment workloads. (This was an artifact of the early days of running “smaller clusters, more of them”, when we were trying to figure out the right size of “smaller”.)