Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | tom_jones's commentslogin

A great example of the difference between academic knowledge and real world experience.


Be careful not to write it off too lightly. As far as I can see from the article, the professor did have real world experience, and still got into bad trouble by being overconfident.


Still massively overconfident and un-prepared. Its easy to have "experience" but be lacking in the correct type of experience. Simple examples here: treefall. His previous experience was in the alpine, so maybe he wasn't expecting this? Also, its not clear how much basic experience he had was in the back-country (self-supported). That would seem to explain his lack of basic preperation (re: 10 essentials). Nor is it clear how well he studied his maps--lots of water-crossings--some of these issues should not have been surprises.


Yep. The more general lesson I see to be learned from this story is: never take inherently dangerous activities or situations lightly, even if you've done it a few times before and nothing seemed to go wrong.


Maybe an answer would be to allow anonymity on the web but only as a legally registered pseudonym. The only way this legally registered pseudonym can be revealed is in legal action against a comment on conviction. That way people can have the right to anonymity so long as they stay within the law.


>The only way this legally registered pseudonym can be revealed is in legal action against a comment on conviction.

So they would convict you before they knew who you actually were? Awesome. No need to defend myself, I guess!

How about instead, we respect the concept of free speech, and allow people to say whatever ridiculous shit they want without threatening to imprison them if they say something that makes us uncomfortable.

> That way people can have the right to anonymity so long as they stay within the law.

What does that even mean? If the system is designed with the express purpose of allowing the law to punish you for something you said, it's not anonymous.


Thanks, this was an interesting read and one I can identify with.

I think developers, anyone who writes software that really matters, are particularly susceptible. I’m not talking about someone who codes a pretty website for a small company, I’m talking about people working on core systems that people RELY on for things like accessing their money, security systems, and engine control systems in their car. These are the projects that will keep you up at night worrying about whether you left any bugs in the code.

The rub is that the general public have NO idea how thin the line is that these developers walk. If they do their job properly, thoroughly, then the product costs too much and nobody buys it. Or it misses time to market and the company slips behind its competitors.

The majority of code is pushed out in barely working state. That’s why we hear of problems like cars that suddenly stop on a freeway. If developers were given more time to finish their work, higher quality of code was prized over speed of development, then a whole industry would be less stressed and society would benefit as a whole. But everyone just wants the newest gadget faster and faster, and we are not patient.


Providing broadband connectivity to rural Americans should have priority over giving 'fast lanes' to those who already enjoy broadband service.


The latest statistical analysis suggests that baseball involves more matters of chance than anyone would like to admit. Beyond home runs and strikeouts, it's mostly random. Luck and skill are all around us to varying unmeasurable degrees, including in a game of poker.


I've seen many a publication where the scientist urge restraint in interpreting results, but then the newspapers completely ignore their pleas and go instead to proclaim "Study of 10 subjects proves X could make you immortal!". It's irresponsible journalism.


I think the answer is the total guileification of the (extended) GNU operating system. We need to facilitate cross-talk between bits of the operating system, and there would be no more natural way to do this in GNU than to make all commands understand literal Scheme lists of arguments, and give back literal Scheme lists of data (including the response to '(help), which would make the entire system introspective!), so that inter-operation between sub-systems becomes natural.


As a Guile hacker, I also think that more programs should be extensibile via Guile. However, I don't think programs need to "understand" sexps in the way you're describing. Programs can continue to work as they have, taking in textual input and outputting textual output. What you get with Guile is the ability to use the program's API via the REPL so you can interact with and extend that program, much like Emacs.


Interesting but it doesn’t get past the a priori objection to the NBN having been adopted without any economic or commercial assessment to justify it as a political fix when the election promise to provide better broadband at one tenth the cost of the NBN was shown to be hopeless and an embarrassing shambles. And it doesn’t demonstrate that the a priori probability that a proven entrepreneur in the field of Internet based services would be able to do the essential job more cost effectively.


I agree, there are many absurd components of the NBN, the most obvious being the idea that the government should spend $2 billion to launch two satellites into orbit just to provide internet to the 400,000 most rural customers who can't get cellular wireless (yet).


It's not so ridiculous if you consider the fact that, with decent internet, that 400,000 might grow considerably in number, reducing housing pressure in the major urban centres and allowing Australia to grow without having to slather on MOAR INFRASTRUCTURE to Sydney and Melbourne's already groaning transport systems.


I think it is fascinating because of what it could have been had Walt Disney's vision continued. It's right there in the opening line: a place for people to find happiness and knowledge. Judging from my visit last weekend, today that line would say "a place for people to spend money and trudge through queues to experience self-contained stories with no room for imagination or learning." It's an object lesson — Walt Disney was clearly as proud of his accomplishments in business as well as his creative endeavors. He was an old school Republican, who thought that American business could make the world better. Sadly, that part of the equation was lost over the decades. And so, Disneyland is still a little model of world in microcosm: from a place where you could imagine and learn to a place where you can spend and ride a "convenience vehicle" and spend a little more to get VIP treatment.


"today that line would say "a place for people to spend money and trudge through queues to experience self-contained stories with no room for imagination or learning." "

people see what they want to see

I always find Disney's attention to detail, especially for what is really a giant coorporation, sort of inspiring


Nice post, just goes to show the value of properly validating uploads!


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: