Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The Apple Music thing is my pet peeve. I bought a $2500 iMac. I carry a nearly $1000 phone. I don't want Apple Music.

Leave me alone. I get periodic full screen ads when I try to listen to music. Is that too much to ask?



Oh, fully agreed. Have you gotten one of those ads when you don't have good network connectivity? Fails to load, fails to respond even if you go into airplane mode -- you have to wait until it can talk to Apple servers again before being able to use the app. Just happened to me yesterday.

I just bought my first iPhone (switching from an Android, the droid maxx - great battery life) largely because I missed being able to easily sync music with my phone. What do I get? Broken music player. Two of the four tabs at the bottom of the Music app are Apple Music-related (radio, "connect"). The UI for switching between displays of my library - artist, album, song - has degraded terribly. And I had to painstakingly delete all of the "cloud" versions of things I'd bought long ago from iTunes. Figured out how to only show music local to my device and now there's an annoying bar across the top of the app at all times.

I mean, fuck, how do you screw up the best mobile music player interface that hard? Just to encourage adoption of a shitty streaming service, with no way to opt out?

Do people not care about syncing music to their phone and listening to it offline anymore?


"Have you gotten one of those ads when you don't have good network connectivity? Fails to load, fails to respond even if you go into airplane mode"

Had this happen twice today on my long commute. After 15 minutes, gave up trying to make my very expensive phone play music. This on top of the usual iTunes complaints is pushing me to abandon Apple until things improve.


They're not done squeezing money out of you yet.


As someone who in general is a huge Apple fan, I feel Apple Music was entirely avoidable mistake, and detracts from their brand.

They need to rethink this app/service.


Respectfully disagree. I'm a professional classical musician, and I LOVE the access to a huge library of music that Apple Music gives me.


I don't have an issue with Apple Music -- just with the hard sell.

I have a huge collection synced to iTunes Match, and I get to spend quality time in a facility with heavily proxied wifi and no cellular coverage. I don't really need a streaming service.

Apple used to be pay more and deal with less bullshit. Add the bullshit, and the value prop changes.


Agreed. I've seen these ads twice in the music player on my iPhone in the last couple of weeks.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: