Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Great write up, love all the details. Surprised that nobody is mentioning Cisco Meraki gear in the recent HN networking posts.

My ideal (budgeted) setup is:

  - (1x) MX65 -- 12 GbE with 2 PoE+. PoE+ powers the access points.
  - (2x) MR33 -- 802.11ac Wave 2 powered via MX65.


Doesn't the MR33 cost around $400 each? You can get 3 Unifi AP Pro's for the cost of one MR33.

The MX65 costs around $600 -- a 24 port (all with PoE) Ubiquiti EdgeSwitch costs about half that much.

I think the reason Ubiquiti gets a lot of write-ups for home use is that it's priced reasonably for the quality. I've had an 8 node small office deployment running flawlessly for 3 years now.


Yes Meraki is absolutely more expensive.

  MX65 - $1,072 with 3 year enterprise subscription 
https://www.amazon.com/Meraki-Branch-Security-Appliance-250M...

  MR33 - $646 each with 3 year enterprise subscription
https://www.rhinonetworks.com/product/device/meraki-mr33?gcl...


I wonder how the UI and firmware updates compare to Ubiquiti. Is it IOS or something else?


Meraki is completely cloud based. Firmware upgrades happen automatically although you have some options about when they get applied (and you get notification before hand).

Having built a software platform that integrated with the big enterprise wifi vendors, I can comfortably say meraki's is the most intuitive and easiest to use.


> Meraki is completely cloud based.

So, you're happy with someone owning your devices and network, and you being said "renter" on your network? This is DRM of the worst kind: the logic is locked away behind their servers.

Nope nope, a flaming rake of fucks nope.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: