Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>One can't just look at revenue, debt and Moody's rating of guitar makers and dealers and proclaim the guitar, the most popular instrument today by a huge margin, is dying.

The "most popular instrument today" is misleading, considering modern R&B, Hip Hop (and to a lesser degree) EDM dominate everything charts and sales wise, and they use mostly computer DAWs and plugins, something that wont register in "instrument sales" lists or music schools.



Can't compare a DAW to an instrument though. Lots of guitar players use DAWs as well, so that's not really comparable. It's a whole different segment in fact.

To correctly account for "computer-only musicians" we would have to also eliminate electronic artists that have a primary instrument such as keyboards or drums/percussion. And in any case, computer-based instruments do register sales and have their place in most music schools.


>(Can't compare a DAW to an instrument though. Lots of guitar players use DAWs as well, so that's not really comparable.*

Yes, but they use it as a recording/mixing device, whereas for electronic musicians they use it for music generation.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: