Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

From 2015.


And it's really hard to verify what people heard in the past. “Our kings, presidents, judges, and officers begin their tenures with oaths to the now-silent deities, taken upon the writings of those who have last heard them.” How do we know that they weren't just doing poetry or fiction, or creating religion to control the masses?


Nietzsche wrote at length about the "death of god," which was his way of symbolizing the unseating of god from society's abstract throne, and the dangerous power vacuum that blood would be shed to re-fill. You can't walk three feet through the past couple centuries before finding some text discussing, cheering on or mourning the transition from a society where god is generally assumed to be behind things to one where he isn't.

If a similar phase change had occured 3000 years ago, I'm pretty sure it would have been well-documented. I have a hard time believing that this event is for the first time being seen clearly from a vantage point three thousand years distant!


> If a similar phase change had occured 3000 years ago, I'm pretty sure it would have been well-documented

Documented where?

The Sapiens book makes a similar assertion, that something changed in the brain about 10000 years ago, when agriculture was invented.

Before that people hunted and gathered for 200k years with little progress and suddenly there was an explosion.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: