Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Is buying stock always taking other people's work, or just when the state does it?


When the state concentrates political and economic power in itself, it's theft.

When, say, the Koch brothers concentrate political and economic power in themselves, it's just markets and capitalism.


But you buy stock with your own money, the state doesn't.

The state does not have any money, it takes money in taxes we all agreed on to use it in fair way, and that is not to use the power of the state to buy up your livelihood and give that to a party member, that would be unfair.


For a value of "we all agreed" that expands to "was decided via a free and fair democratic process", then it appears that the Swedes did all agree, at least for a time, that this was a fair way for their government to use their tax money.

For any other value of "we all agreed" then it sounds like you're arguing that the vast majority of government expenditures are unjustified. That seems like a much more expansive claim than what you're trying to make.

Why should it be okay for the state to use tax money to purchase a tank or a mile of road but not to purchase a share of stock?


Swedes did not agree, hence losing the following election.

State can of course buy stock. State owned companies can work just fine.

But there is a difference in intent. Intent here was union controlled ownership of all major companies. Creator of idea explicitly quoted Marx.

It think also we got bit sidetracked in this discussion with the word buy that I misused, it was not buying at the stock market, it was "buying" with legislation, exchanging profits for stock.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2027 batch! Applications are open till November 2.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: