Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

More like:

Police: "We have a warrant for your apartment, let us in"

Suspect: "Sorry, I lost the key when I went hiking in the Rocky Mountains, there's no way in. Oh, and be aware that if you try to force your way in more than 5 times, the apartment will catch fire and destroy everything inside"

What would happen in this case? Can the suspect be held in contempt?



Probably obstruction of justice IMHO


Doesn't that require intent and planning? If the arrangements were in place before the crime was even planned, how can it be obstruction?


It's obstruction if they didn't actually lose the key, or the deliberately "lost" the key.


That is a degenerate argument. an apartment is clearly yours. Without your password there is no way to conclusively prove that a phone is yours. SIM cards can be swapped, for example. The incriminating is not stating the password. it is the fact that you are proving the phone as yours.


Phone's have serial numbers tied to the hardware. It's certainly possible to prove that a given phone is the same physical unit that one purchased.


Which does not in any way prove that it is yours. Over my lifetime I purchased over 30 phones. Only two of them are currently mine. If you were to place another one I have purchased, but long ago sold in my possession, that would not be enough to prove that it is currently mine. if I happen to know the password, that might be very convincing.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2027 batch! Applications are open till November 2.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: