Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> It's because Java has strict memory limits.

Java doesn't have strict memory limits.

Sun's JVM has a setting for maximum heap size, but there are of course lots of other JVM's, and there are lots of other ways to consume memory.

> The limit of a bad C++ app is your machines whole memory (in theory more)

Well, that depends. Most people run operating systems that can impose limits, and you can certainly set a maximum heap size for your C++ runtime that works similarly to Java's limit. You just don't tend to do it, because you're already explicitly managing the memory, so there's no reason for setting a generalized limit for your execution environment.

> so most people never notice if an app continues to leak memory or has weird memory spikes where it needs ten GB instead of one for a minute before it goes back to normal

It also helps that short running apps and forking apps tend to hide the consequences of a lot of memory leaks, and in the specific case of C++, where memory mismanagement is often a symptom or a cause of severe bugs, you tend to invest a lot of time up front on memory management.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: