Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Here's a thing I don't like and it's not mentioned in the list. If I submit a story I can't downvote on any of the top level comments. Why is that?


Presumably the same reason you can't downvote immediate replies to your comments which is probably there to discourage toxic back-and-forth downvoting.


Probably the same reason you cannot downvote any direct replies to your comments, such as this one.


I can understand why downvoting replies is prohibited, it could harm conversations. But prohibiting downvoting in submitted stories assumes some kind of self interest, which I doubt is the norm.


I think it's generally "the submitter shouldn't be able to shape the discussion too much". I.e. also why you aren't supposed to put your own spin on a headline, text submissions are separate and not supposed to be used for links (with a few exceptions).


Sure, that makes sense.


It could be as simple as: coding this would be an exception, and no one has done so.

`(if (not (eq parent.user user)) (set! allow_downvotes true))` (probably not valid Arc!) is easy to code up, an exception would be more convoluted.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: