Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

You say this like the Hallmark channel or Lifetime don't exist.


Certainly those channels have never been marketed as "a channel for white people" as an explicit statement. Just because they are channels for white people and white American culture doesn't change that.


I am not familiar with those channels since I'm not american, but I am fairly certain that they are not marketed as "for white people".


They are not, but their programming makes it quite obvious who their target audience is. And I don't think this is a bad thing, at all. For example, Hallmark has a large number of programs where characters are very overt in talking about and praising their faith and religion, which is much less common on other networks.

To echo what others have said, though, if you are not a member of a minority, it can be difficult to understand how affirming and wonderful it can feel to experience, just for a brief moment and even if by fantasy, to exist as if you were the majority. For example, I am gay, and here are some common thought processes that go through my head that are basically completely foreign to straight people:

1. When I walk down the street with my partner of 20 years, deciding to hold hands is not something I can just do spontaneously. It is essentially a political act when I do it, and so my first thoughts always go to (a) am I safe and (b) do I feel like making a political statement right now.

2. When I travel, the first thing I think about is whether I am going to a place that is accepting of gays. I'm just too old to want to deal with anti-gay attitudes when I'm supposed to be enjoying myself on vacation.

3. When I introduce myself to new people, I do a mental calculation as to whether I feel like mentioning my partner and thus outing myself in that situation. Again, it's always a conscious calculation, where it almost never is for straight people.

So the first time I visited the Castro (a well-known gay neighborhood in San Francisco), it was kind of magical to me, to just walk down the street and have people assume I was gay before assuming I was straight, and it was really the first time I could completely relax and feel like what it was like to be a member of the majority.

So that's what things like BET, LogoTV, Telemundo, etc. are really about, it's about actually feeling like you are the focus of attention for a short time.


They're well known for being the most reductive, base, inoffensive content possible.

In the sense that shows and movies seem like the result of endless series of meetings, where anything that anyone might object to is censored and removed.


What are you saying about non-white people who enjoy those channels?


That they are like white people listening to Hip Hop. You're allowed to like it, but you should never expect them to cater to your demographic.


I'm sure non-black people are welcome to this too.


That they're boring? (But then, that's true of white people who enjoy those channels too)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: