Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

If I had an app that showed me all tcp headers and you somehow hid your tcp headers from that app, I’d be upset.

Especially if I had to pay for each tcp header.



You don’t have an app that shows all SMS. You have an app for communicating with other people via SMS.


"Just signalling," seriously? Apple and the carrier are also "other people." Whose phone is it anyway? Any action taken by a device one controls should be made transparent and auditable by the device's owner. They are meant to be tools, not undomesticated semi-wild animals with a will and mind of their own.


> Just signalling," seriously?

Yes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Signaling_(telecommunications)

> Apple and the carrier are also "other people."

Don’t be silly.

> Whose phone is it anyway?

Whoever bought the phone.

> Any action taken by a device one controls should be made transparent and auditable by the device's owner.

Ok, this is a moral and ideological position in favor of all designs of all silicon, all circuitry, and and all software being entirely open source.

It’s valid to argue that we should live in such a world, but it’s not an argument that Apple using SMS for signaling is equivalent to malware. Sorry.

> They are meant to be tools,

They are tools.

> not undomesticated semi-wild animals with a will and mind of their own.

Weird analogy to use to describe signaling traffic.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: