> I would like to see the CL open source community pause and consider what constitutes a healthy community.
This is in no-one's dictionary "chastising" (random dictionary plucked from search):
> chastising (Entry 1 of 2) inflicting, involving, or serving as punishment
As for "judging" - this seems proportionate. E.g. while I think your judgment is poor when you use these words, I don't think a valid criticism of your comment is that you are "judging" anything. By this definition, almost everything anyone says is "judging".
This is in no-one's dictionary "chastising" (random dictionary plucked from search):
> chastising (Entry 1 of 2) inflicting, involving, or serving as punishment
As for "judging" - this seems proportionate. E.g. while I think your judgment is poor when you use these words, I don't think a valid criticism of your comment is that you are "judging" anything. By this definition, almost everything anyone says is "judging".