Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I guess Gitlab doesn't care about having customers that work on Windows platforms.

Meanwhile Github works just great for us.



because windows can't run browsers anymore? I would say they don't give a f*ck on the operating system you use, as long it includes a browser.

It's just their workforce, where they don't want to see anyone working with windows.


Which means their workforce doesn't give a fuck about supporting CI/CD pipelines used by Windows development, unless they have some mental powers to test them with having Windows around.


So, you think a very small Modul that communicates via http only, and written in different language then the main project (go instead of Ruby), is a reason that the developers of the main project (ruby, only supported on Linux) should also be able to work on Windows, or even be supported in doing so, cause ~three people need to support the gitlab-ci runner on windows?

Edit: oh, and testing of those gitlab-ci functionalities can easily be done in a VM.


Since when CI/CD products like a compiler, static analysis, os frameworks are a very small module?

If they aren't running Windows, I really doubt their skillset to give any kind of meaningful support.


Since when does Gitlab(-CI) Provide a Compiler or OS Framework? Gitlab-CI allows you to execute commands in some form of defined environment (Container based, insite a VM or on bare-metal), They have to make sure the commands are executed in the order you defined, and the output is then shown in the WebUI. Everthing run is "random" cli-tool you "found" somewhere.


I thought they wanted to compete against GitHub offerings, apparently not.


Compete by building another compiler? Sounds very sane.


100% Agreed. The really aggressive "fuck Microsoft" rhetoric is going to burn a lot of these startups over the long haul. It's incredible to me the number that still seem to be operating in an ideological bubble that was originally created 2 decades ago.

A lot of Serious Business happens on top of Microsoft technology right now, and the companies responsible for tending to solutions in this space are made extraordinarily uncomfortable by this kind of aura being given off by vendors like Gitlab.

Can Gitlab really afford to alienate double-digit % of its TAM in favor of this ideological position? It seems like they are already having financial difficulties based upon other recent articles.


You don't need Windows to build Web apps that run on it.


[flagged]


except they do.


I wonder how, when Windows isn't allowed.

Must be some special Pixie dust.


Unsurprisingly, they don't run CI on developer laptops, which the linked page is about.


So their developers do indeed use Pixie dust when debugging Windows build pipelines and compilers.


I am running a Linux laptop, and I regularly run and test code on Windows, macOS, FreeBSD, OpenBSD, NetBSD, DragonFly BSD, and illumos. Basically, all the systems Go supports minus Solaris and AIX because they're proprietary and I can't "just download" them AFAIK, and Plan 9 because I found it too confusing/hard to set up (and is so obscure I don't really care too much either).

The "Pixie dust" is QEMU and a zsh script.

GitLab doesn't outright ban Windows for any and all usages; you just can't run it on your laptop as the main system (although exceptions are allowed).


And naturally you can answer any Windows support question as good as a Windows developer that is running their system 8h a day.

I surely won't regarding UNIX flavours, and have been using them in some variation since 1992.


Virtual machines aren't that magic I'd say, but sure, if you think they are pixie dust, then I guess its pixie dust...


No Windows allowed....


again, "on company laptops". Surely the concept of remotely accessing VMs is not new to you?


As it is the lack of skills for a given OS people don't use on their systems.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2027 batch! Applications are open till November 2.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: