Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I started asking my father, a concert pianist, composer, and teacher - this question when I was 4. He explained. In my head I said, “Bullshit.” I continued to press him on it periodically until I was a teenager. I still shook my head and thought, “What is wrong with these people.” Now, I can read sheet music just fine, but I still feel like … never mind. I’ve done a ton of composing without once taking any notice of what key any of it was in. And it all sounds fucking great. I prefer to do as much as possible “by ear”. I’m unbelievably stubborn.

tl;dr - Somebody really should have picked up on the autism when I was 4, and MIDI rolls don’t give a shit about keys and accidentals.



MIDI rolls don't, by themselves, make any noise or even inherently define any note frequencies at all.

The frequency of the sound produced by a given synthesizer when it receives any particular MIDI note number is up to the synthesizer. This is part of the point of the MIDI tuning system. The synthesizer and/or the tuning system may very much care about keys and accidentals.


do share! I'm a "MIDI composer" myself and love to hear what others do :)

obligatory self-promotion, https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCUmdU7WpuhAv3imtVqkGpIA


That's good stuff! Reminds me very, very vaguely of:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vapZZdog0NI

Here's a small sampler. I include one that's maybe a bit similar, the one called 'crsh'

https://soundcloud.com/w37hlwyq0a/sets


I liked that Overworld theme a lot, reminded me of the Nexomon Evolution theme




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: