> Nobody is looking for "human intelligence" on other planets. Maybe that's why you think it's impossible. I'd say dolphins are intelligent.
One proviso there is that it'd be very hard to establish that there are dolphins on another planet since the only signature that we have to go on are things that manipulate the light spectrum. We could, perhaps, infer something from an atmospheric condition that we might someday be able to detect, but observe, for instance, how difficult it is for us to determine if there is or has ever been life on Mars, even though it's right next door. For all we know, there could be dolphins on Titan. Sending an exploratory probe that would take millennia to reach its target (and then several hundred years to send data back) will probably remain impractical for an extended period of time.
You cut out the part where I mentioned computer systems when you quoted me. That part was important. It was an attempt to show that there could be radio-communicating, non-human entities with entirely different 'intelligences'.
> will probably remain impractical for an extended period of time.
I don't deny that. I only deny that it's impossible.
One proviso there is that it'd be very hard to establish that there are dolphins on another planet since the only signature that we have to go on are things that manipulate the light spectrum. We could, perhaps, infer something from an atmospheric condition that we might someday be able to detect, but observe, for instance, how difficult it is for us to determine if there is or has ever been life on Mars, even though it's right next door. For all we know, there could be dolphins on Titan. Sending an exploratory probe that would take millennia to reach its target (and then several hundred years to send data back) will probably remain impractical for an extended period of time.