There seems to be this new crop of ridiculously overdesigned websites recently. Versionate, Docstoc, iscrybe, etc. I'm not sure how I feel about it.
I was reading Viktor Frankel's holocaust memoir recently. He makes the claim that people find meaning in their lives through meeting people, going places, doing work, and through unavoidable suffering.
I think he's right. And sometimes I think that web designers would do well to add a little unavoidable suffering.
Some of these new websites seem user centric to the point of being obsequious. It's kind of like when a guy is following around a girl and constantly doing nice things for her. You'd think it would be cool, but it gets kind of creepy after a while.
The concept is solid and the technology is brilliant. It just makes me a little uncomfortable for some reason.
Suffering may (or may not) be good for people, but that doesn't mean it's the job of designers to supply it. Especially not the designers of something like Versionate. Versionate is a tool, and tools should be self-effacing.
Plus, most people are already way over their lifetime allowance for software-induced suffering.
You seem to have noticed that discussions are far better on news.yc than they are on reddit, but you clearly haven't figured out why. Most people who decide to comment make sure their comments actually add to the discussion, which the grandparent poster did, even if you disagree with him. You, however, didn't.
This is exactly the kind of comment that drags down reddit (and digg and slashdot). If you disagree with something, refute it instead of just calling names.
I was reading Viktor Frankel's holocaust memoir recently. He makes the claim that people find meaning in their lives through meeting people, going places, doing work, and through unavoidable suffering.
I think he's right. And sometimes I think that web designers would do well to add a little unavoidable suffering.
Some of these new websites seem user centric to the point of being obsequious. It's kind of like when a guy is following around a girl and constantly doing nice things for her. You'd think it would be cool, but it gets kind of creepy after a while.
The concept is solid and the technology is brilliant. It just makes me a little uncomfortable for some reason.
/least useful criticism ever :-)