Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

From his campaign page: http://www.ronpaul2012.com/the-issues/abortion/

  And as President, Ron Paul will continue to fight for the same 
  pro-life solutions he has upheld in Congress, including:
  
  Immediately saving lives by effectively repealing Roe v. Wade and 
  preventing activist judges from interfering with state decisions 
  on life by removing abortion from federal court jurisdiction through 
  legislation modeled after his “We the People Act.”

  Defining life as beginning at conception by passing a “Sanctity of Life Act.”
It's very difficult to interpret that as anything but being anti-abortion at the federal level. Passing a law outright banning it is unnecessary if life is defined at the federal level as beginning at conception.


Passing a law outright banning it is unnecessary if life is defined at the federal level as beginning at conception.

This is false. Such an official definition would probably be only symbolic. The thing is, the federal government does not have any general police power.

Even if, by their definition, abortion were murder (and there's a lot more defining to be done before we could arrive at that conclusion), it really wouldn't matter. Consider that today, we would define all living people as "alive" (duh), the federal has no laws forbidding murder! Any murder charge is the result of state laws (other than in national parks and in DC, but those are a different argument).

The only way this could affect real life legalities is in the way it interacts with the 13th Amendment. But since that's got the goofy doctrine of incorporation, there would be no net change unless the Supreme Court were to recognize the right with respect to this new/clarified definition. And that just puts the ball right back into the SCOTUS court, which is where it sits today anyway.

(I upvoted you because I think it's worthy of discussion, but this is the way the answer is going to fall out in the end)


The act being referred to merely allows states to ban abortion and removes federal funding from abortions, it does not ban them.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: