Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Why is it bad to go through metal detectors to go to school?

I go through a metal detector when I go into work.

I go through a metal detector when I enter a courthouse.

I go through a metal detector when I go into the Capitol.

None of these things detracts from the gravitas of those places, and none of them makes any of those places feel less safe.

Especially when the alternatives include impinging on fundamental rights or forcing kids to go through sometimes horrifying active shooter drills, I have a hard time understanding the objection to metal detectors.



I'd be surprised if schools with metal detectors don't have active shooter drills. Mass shooters aren't deterred by metal detectors. They show up armed and walk into the building shooting.

Metal detectors are better at preventing situations like gang violence where rivals carry every day "just in case".


> none of them makes any of those places feel less safe

Experiences certainly vary: security checkpoints definitely make me feel less safe, whether or not they include metal detectors, so I avoid going into any place which has one.

I would go to some significant effort to avoid putting my child through that experience every schoolday. What a drag on one's educational experience that would be!


i have a hard time understanding the requirement.

then again i only ever went throu a metal detector at the airport; which neither detected my pocket knife nor the screwdriver in my bag, but the guards made a real fuss about that half-filled bottle of juice.


Metal detectors in schools solve school shootings?


Security measures deter mass shooters, including school shooters, yes.

> Drake told reporters that "there was another location that was mentioned, but because of threat assessment by the suspect, too much security, they decided not to."

https://www.newsweek.com/covenant-school-shooter-audrey-hale...


Active shooter drills are very boring and met with mockery fwiw.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: