Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I am not a climate change denier and I believe humans have contributed significantly to it with green house gases. That said. This headline and article are way over the top and give the deniers another article to point to as climate hysteria. Where on earth did it used to be habitable by humans but no longer is? There must be some if this article is true. I can't think of any.


Does the article actually mention that parts of Earth are no longer habitable already, or just that the conditions are moving into that direction? The title of this post seems to indicate the latter.


It says "human activities have breached safe levels for six [out of 9] of these boundaries and are pushing the world outside a “safe operating space” If we are over a majority of the set points but there is no inhabitable area to point to, then maybe the set points are wrong.


You can learn more about this framework here:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planetary_boundaries

It is just a way to quantify something very elusive. The point is we are doing a lot of harm without any consideration for our actions. Profits over all.


Thanks. I had ChatGPT Plus read it and then asked questions. I now understand the problem. It's similar to the methane release from Siberia, a run away effect that can't be reversed. These are other modes of run away effect.

Crossing 6 out of 9 planetary boundaries would not necessarily mean that parts of the Earth have become uninhabitable for humans, but it would signify a very high level of risk for abrupt and potentially irreversible environmental changes. These changes could severely disrupt the Earth's systems that make the planet habitable in the first place.

The concept of planetary boundaries is designed to identify the "safe operating space" for humanity. Crossing multiple boundaries increases the risk of triggering non-linear, abrupt environmental changes on a continental to planetary scale. These could include extreme weather events, loss of freshwater resources, collapse of ecosystems, and other severe disruptions that could make life increasingly difficult for humans and other species.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: