Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Whenever this issue of iMessage crops up on HN, I’ve come to expect the usual points from both sides. However, the one thing that’s never addressed is the “why” of it all. For a group that ostensibly values openness and interoperability, why spend so much effort and energy to climb into a walled garden?


Because half our friends/family/etc own an iPhone and they either use iMessage or WhatsApp, and neither is acceptable for the likes of me. And since they don't 'stoop' to the level of Signal, we can 'stoop' to the level of iMessage (but definitely not WhatsApp).


Whats wrong with WhatsApp?


It's own by Meta.


Blue-bubble envy is real. I myself am a green-bubbler but every once in awhile I feel this tinge of "otherness" when I see "Loved an image" in the group chat.


it's location tracking and sending money that you don't feel.


To pry a closed system open and force it to interoperate. Climbing into a walled garden and breaking down one of the walls.


Receiving videos which aren't crunched down to 320x240 resolution would be nice.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: