Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Why did you go for a pistol? If you expect things to go really bad then surely a hunting rifle would be more useful, and perhaps a shotgun for personal defense.


The economic meltdown version of Godwin's law clearly seems to be when someone suggests buying gold and weapons. Often even with the requisite response: why a gun instead of a pistol?

For an account (previously on HN a few times) from someone in Argentina who really went through total currency meltdown:

http://www.frugalsquirrels.com/cgi-bin/ubb/ultimatebb.cgi?ub...


I won't even mention who Godwin's law refers to, but I'd like to point out that they were alive at some point. By the same token, shit-hits-fan scenarios are awful and usually warnings are false alarms, but they happen. I don't think that doesn't mean we can't talk about them without getting into a flame war. I think HN is civilized enough to address these topics once in a while and come up with an interesting discussion.



why a gun instead of a pistol?

A pistol is a type of gun.


For reasons outlined by FerFAL at http://www.frugalsquirrels.com/cgi-bin/ubb/ultimatebb.cgi?ub...

Handguns: Revolver or Pistol? Pistol ALL THE WAY! Yes, I saw the video of the guy that accurately emptied his S&W in ½ a second. I also saw the shooting range and the crowd behind him, watching the event. Can he shoot and reload that way if he is in his car, driving with one hand and shooting with the other, while a bunch of scum bags in another car are shooting at him? Hey, maybe he can. I know I can’t. Can you? Generally speaking, the revolver is more difficult to master than the pistol. The double action is hard and it affects speed and accuracy. It can be done, but I found that pistols are easier, as did many shooters. Also, even though they seem to be more simple, revolvers are not as rugged as service pistols, the mechanisms that cycles the cylinder and cocks the hammer is both complicated and fragile compared to auto pistols. Before anyone starts casting evil voodoo spells at me for insulting their prized S&W or Ruger: I own revolvers and like shooting them, I just don’t think they are the best option for self defense, and I see that everyone I talk to in my country who is worried about security as I am also chooses pistols. Quality pistols resist sand, mud and dirt in general better than revolvers, where a small pebble locked in the mechanism may render the revolver inoperable.


Handguns: Revolver or Pistol?

A revolver is a type of pistol.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: