Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Historical figures aren't the only exogenous things in written works, and historical figures are far from the extent of the external structures and themes that are present in Dante's Comedy, I would go as far as to say that the historical connections in the comedy are not that significant, and serve mostly to distract one particular class of reader.


Ok, but you aren’t participating in the discussion being had here.


I responded directly to your comment where you suggested that the work of identifying and/or interpreting "references" was unique to or characteristic of Dante.

And I am adding that while always interesting and rewarding for those that are obsessed with a work, "getting" the references in Dante's Comedy or any other work of merit is not the point, and they are not all that important in the work.

And further, since I am near the subject, I am engraving my personal ad hominem, that it is the characteristic mark of a certain class of readership (which I hold in low regard) to fixate on which 7th century monk in which manuscript first introduced some mentioned doctrine before having (and never-to-have) attempted to commune with the work itself.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: