Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>Honestly, I cannot think of a good reason to delete any article at all, unless it's obviously fraudulent...

I find this opinion extremely ironic. The whole point of wikipedia was to be an encyclopedia, including all of the baggage that word carries. We don't need another raw dump of information--that's what the internet is for. Wikipedia has a special place in the mind of the world; having an article there gives your cause an air of legitimacy that simply being on the internet doesn't have anymore. And this is exactly why people want their pet causes plastered all over it.

If Wikipedia were just another dump of information, no one would care to have their information on it. That is what is ironic about this argument. The only reason people care to be on wikipedia is precisely because of the "deletionists" and editors who work to keep articles on the site notable. Without them, wikipedia simply wouldn't matter.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: