Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
This is a really good idea for disrupting the RIAA. Think it'll work? (sellaband.com)
1 point by kf on Aug 24, 2007 | hide | past | favorite | 2 comments


This won't have any impact on the RIAA.

Sellaband looks like another site trying to make a buck on the hard work and naivety of struggling musicians. Their "expert" producers are c-list producers at best, their A&R people aren't any of the industry's big names and are a completely unnecessary part of the transaction. The company takes a publishing % into perpetuity, owns masters, and it looks like they're over inflating costs - that's probably where they're making their profit. This is a really bad idea for any band, and a waste of money from the fan perspective.

Amie St. is a company that I think has some really good disruptive potential in the music indsutry. I love the idea and am glad to see they're getting some weight thrown behind them.

Zaydana: I think there's potential for someone to come in and do this properly, Sellaband has exploitive industry slime all over it.


I wasn't quite certain, then I looked at the "leaders". Theres already quite a few artists who have raised over $25,000, and are over half way there! The top 10 artists alone have raised over $200,000 so far.

Its a great concept. It sucks for me though, because I had planned on doing something similar, and now I find out my idea isn't that original :-(




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: