Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This....

But then I still hear people say that this is what the 2nd amendment is for... Meanwhile, to make sure they have the heavier weapons, law enforcement goes absolutely bananas on what they carry.

The second amendment was written in a time when a firearm was a musket.





Grandpa's 30-06 from WW2 from 200 yards will penetrate anything but trauma plates.

If it's a hand-carried firearm of any kind (including crew-served weapons like the M249, M240B, M60), it's not a "heavy weapon."

> The second amendment was written in a time when a firearm was a musket.

At the time the Second Amendment was written, there were entire private navies with actual cannons far more destructive than any man-portable firearm available today. No background checks on those ships or cannons, either, btw.


They didn't just have muskets at that time, repeating firearms were just too expensive to outfit entire armies with them. When you can supply 10 guys with muskets for the same cost as 1 guy with a repeating firearm, you pick the 10 men even if the 1 guy can fire just as fast.


The Kalthoff repeater was invented in the 1600s. Here's a Forgotten Weapons video on it https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ghKrbNpqQoY

There is also the Cookson repeater available in the late 1600s. And in 1756 was advertised for sale in the Boston Gazette.

Multiple founding fathers, including George Washington, were also offered purchase of repeating firearms, some for use in the military, some for personal usage. But of course this is still before interchangeable parts so production is of course still expensive and repairs must be done be a highly skilled gunsmith and not just some apprentice blacksmith.



Then it's useless and should be abroged.

> The second amendment was written in a time when a firearm was a musket.

Second amendment was written for children in schools.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: