Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I guess that's because many/most countries don't have the concept of a private emergency department.

It doesn't really matter how much money you have if you have a broken leg as you'll be queuing up with everyone else for the triage and initial treatment.

I have amazing private healthcare coverage in the UK through my employer. I've had certain treatments done in under a week where the NHS waiting lists for the same procedure are measured in years.

But if I have a serious acute illness, or break a bone, my private healthcare can't help other than give me a telephone appointment with a doctor within 10 minutes at which point they'll say "What are you doing calling us? Go to the emergency department now!"

After the initial triage/treatment/stabilisation there may be a different pathway for people with private healthcare, but the doors of the emergency department are the first port of call for pretty much everyone who is in dire need.

(I'm sure for people who are seriously rich there are private arrangements, most people with serious money have doctors/dentists/etc on retainer, but these are the 0.001%)

 help



Australia reporting in.

We have private emergency rooms. We call them urgent care and you can go and see a qualified physician with allied health services (radiology, pathology). If they can fix you up they will. If not you get transferred via ambulance to the nearest public hospital and triaged as required.

I took my kid to one last weekend as they had been diagnosed by our family Dr as having pneumonia. The emergency physician ordered chest x-ray and full suite of pathology and we had results in less time than we would have waited in the public hospital waiting room. Yes we paid.


Also Australia reporting in.

I've unfortunately had a number of emergency visits over the past few years. I'm a bit torn on the public vs private situation. For certain classes of issue (e.g., broken bones) my friends who work in hospitals have repeatedly said they'd go public purely because the volume of patients those surgeons have to treat daily means the teams in the public systems are typically incredibly experienced. And yet, I smashed my hand to pieces mountain biking on a holiday weekend and when I arrived at the ER the place was absolutely rammed and it was going to be a many hours wait to even get triaged. We got straight back in the car and drive to the private ER 5 minutes down the road and were seen immediately.

In the moment I was incredibly appreciative of that option. It does make me feel uncomfortable that it was only an option because I could afford to pay to jump the queue though.


Does it make sense to get an x-ray for that? I’m sympathetic to the desire, but isn’t the end result for pneumonia always antibiotics anyway?

If it's not pneumonia, antibiotics might not help.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: