Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> forgetting that the US has hundreds of large, dense cities

Those large US cities really aren't anywhere near as dense though once you're comparing the actual MSA (US) or FUA (EU). The population densities of those actual whole areas are nowhere near the same.

For comparison relevant to this article, only 25% of the Swiss population live in single family detached houses. About 60% of US households live in single-family detached housing.

https://www.bfs.admin.ch/bfs/en/home/statistics/construction...

Zurich and Milwaukee both have ~1.5M people in their Functional Urban Area/Metropolitan Statistical Area. One has a density of ~750/km^2 and the other is ~418. Guess which is which. Or compare Lausanne to Modesto CA. Both have ~550k populations. One 637/km^2, one is 144/km^2.

Such big and dense cities we have here in the US!

Either way though, I do think its often less to do with population densities and more about political will of the local populace and regulatory capture.

I have family that lives in a pretty newly developed area in the middle of an already well-developed area with tons of homes having fiber-to-the-home. The local cable company managed to convince the builder to let only them install coax services to these homes. Now it will cost the fiber company a lot more if they want to eventually go into that neighborhood, so they haven't bothered.

You see the same thing with pole attachment rights in our cities. Incumbents shut down competition and prevent those who push for change.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: